Off Topic May vs Corbyn

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
I do have a great deal of sympathy for Tessa as she was given the poisoned chalice. Whatever deal was negotiated a significant number of Joe Public and the MP’s would be complaining about the deal. She literally was in a no win situation.

Go for a hard Brexit and most people would complain. Those who wanted a soft Brexit and those who wanted to remain.

Go for a soft Brexit and most people would complain. Those who wanted a hard Brexit and those who wanted to remain.

Opt to remain and most would complain. Those that wanted to leave.

I don’t think there is any deal that the majority of Joe Public would back. She’s damned if she does, she’s damned if she doesn’t.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dorty Dogbreath
The majority of the electorate voted to leave
The majority of MPs voted to remain
That’s the problem
 
I do have a great deal of sympathy for Tessa as she was given the poisoned chalice. Whatever deal was negotiated a significant number of Joe Public and the MP’s would be complaining about the deal. She literally was in a no win situation.

Go for a hard Brexit and most people would complain. Those who wanted a soft Brexit and those who wanted to remain.

Go for a soft Brexit and most people would complain. Those who wanted a hard Brexit and those who wanted to remain.

Opt to remain and most would complain. Those that wanted to leave.

I don’t think there is any deal that the majority of Joe Public would back. She’s damned if she does, she’s damned if she doesn’t.

She has been handed a massive hospital pass. The old boys club are in full voice all smelling the opportunity to get their man in the top seat.
 
The majority of the electorate voted to leave
The majority of MPs voted to remain
That’s the problem
And we voted those MPs in at an election after the referendum result.
Maybe rather than have another referendum we should have a General Election. The new house can thrn vote on one of 3 options: No Deal, Offered Deal, Remain.
A new referendum and the so called failure of Democracy is avoided.
 
And we voted those MPs in at an election after the referendum result.
Maybe rather than have another referendum we should have a General Election. The new house can thrn vote on one of 3 options: No Deal, Offered Deal, Remain.
A new referendum and the so called failure of Democracy is avoided.
Since when have MP’s ever been bothered about what the people who voted them in wanted unless their seats were at risk? After a General Election their seats won’t be at risk.
 
There's no question that it costs something to be a member of the EU. As to whether it is value for money, though, that is a different question.

£9 billion is 3.2% of UK's current exports to the EU. If we can negotiate an arrangement which (after we've paid the £39 billion exit fee) preserves at least 96.9% of our current trading levels, then you are right: once the £39 billion is paid, leaving will be good value for money. If trade to the EU falls by 3.3% or more, then being in the EU is good value for money. Neither of us can see the future but I know what I would predict.


One futher point. The EU channels a lot of those returning funds back to the parts of the UK which need it.

If we're relying on the London-centric Westminster to replace like-with-like then it won't happen. The funds that the regions get, the various projects get, will all dry up and, no doubt, we'll get more of Boris' bridges and cable-cars over the Thames.
 
  • Like
Reactions: GeordieHalfbreed