Mags cant help themselves..

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Cant understand the reaction to DT's comments, he was being entirely reasonable and even overrated your midfield as far as you were concerned, then you laugh and say it is proof we are all muppets.

Us thinking a player wouldnt get into our team need not be seen as an insult, some players suit teams much more than others. We wouldnt play Larsson because we have a player that can do his job in Barton, same as you might argue Cabaye wouldnt get into your side but he would ours. I think a lot of us were commenting negatively about Gardner is we've had a midfielder who only scores goals (or that is his main trait) and he was an absolute passenger in the side, so while Gardner would suit you, he isnt he sort of player we'd play IMO.
 
billofengland said:
In my opinion, if Newcastle want Gibson, we should stand aside, like gentlemen, and let our neighbors have him,
that and the fact he is ****e.
Click to expand...

That's in no way a fact. It's an opinion. Don't try to feed us your opinions and label them as facts.
 
Smudger said:
Cant understand the reaction to DT's comments, he was being entirely reasonable and even overrated your midfield as far as you were concerned, then you laugh and say it is proof we are all muppets.

Us thinking a player wouldnt get into our team need not be seen as an insult, some players suit teams much more than others. We wouldnt play Larsson because we have a player that can do his job in Barton, same as you might argue Cabaye wouldnt get into your side but he would ours. I think a lot of us were commenting negatively about Gardner is we've had a midfielder who only scores goals (or that is his main trait) and he was an absolute passenger in the side, so while Gardner would suit you, he isnt he sort of player we'd play IMO.
Click to expand...

Nail on head.

As i said on your board the other day re Larsson, it's not his technical ability and overall standing as a footballer that makes him a great signing for us, it's the fact that his set play quality is a massive hole in our arsenal.

Sometimes a player who may not be the best player, can bet the best fit for a team.

That's where i feel we are getting it right this summer.
 
safc4life1986 said:
some guy on their page is stating not one of the players we have signed would get in their team, saying larsson is average, dong isnt good enough, funny seeing their bitterness i must say, roll on o shea next week, followed by gibson, who once he turns newcastle down for us, probably isnt good enough to get in their team they'll say!
Click to expand...

Uhh well, they wouldn't, and that's just the truth.

We've always had a very strong midfield. It's been out strongest area, so the likes of Larsson and Gardner wouldn't make the first team whilst competing with other midfielders like Barton, Tiote, Ben Arfa, Cabaye (if he turns out as expected), Jonas and so on. Gardner is a good player on a good day, but we're fortunate to have very strong centre mids in Barton and Tiote (and possibly Cabaye) so Gardner wouldn't get a look in the starting 11.

As for Dong, he's some kid from the asian league who scored 4 goals in the Asian Cup. How the hell can anyone say that he's 'good enough' to be in our starting 11? The same goes for Wickham. Plus, if we're only playing Ba as a lone striker, of course neither of them would get in as Ba has much more of a pedigree in the EPL and other top leagues in Europe.

And I'll say it now before you guys even sign Gibson, he wouldn't be in our first team either. Again, our CM options are too strong. When it coms to O'Shea, it depends if he's a better defender than Stevey Taylor. If so, he'd probably get in.
 
Chappaz said:
Uhh well, they wouldn't, and that's just the truth.

We've always had a very strong midfield. It's been out strongest area, so the likes of Larsson and Gardner wouldn't make the first team whilst competing with other midfielders like Barton, Tiote, Ben Arfa, Cabaye (if he turns out as expected), Jonas and so on. Gardner is a good player on a good day, but we're fortunate to have very strong centre mids in Barton and Tiote (and possibly Cabaye) so Gardner wouldn't get a look in the starting 11.

As for Dong, he's some kid from the asian league who scored 4 goals in the Asian Cup. How the hell can anyone say that he's 'good enough' to be in our starting 11? The same goes for Wickham. Plus, if we're only playing Ba as a lone striker, of course neither of them would get in as Ba has much more of a pedigree in the EPL and other top leagues in Europe.

And I'll say it now before you guys even sign Gibson, he wouldn't be in our first team either. Again, our CM options are too strong. When it coms to O'Shea, it depends if he's a better defender than Stevey Taylor. If so, he'd probably get in.
Click to expand...

This.
 
Oh no, Bruce has shafted us and bought ****e players. Sack him the bastard.

Why oh why didn't we just let a bunch of thick arseholes from NE1 do our buying for us this summer. They seem to know what they are talking about.

You couple of Muppet's Bruce and Quinn. Please run any future targets by 5 Goals Chappaz and Badger and the other **** munchers up at barcodeland will you, so that you dont keep spending our hard earned money on **** like Gardener, Larsson, Westwood, Ji dong Won and especially any more hot prospects like Wickham. We demand that you buy in total unknown foreign players and especially ones with glass ankles and knees. We'd prefer it if they had already failed medicals at 2 other clubs as well, before you even think of buying them.

Thanks Geordie bum bandits for putting us all straight now about our signings. There was I thinking that we had made some good buys when all along, they are just ****e ones after all.

Funny old game eh?:headbang:<doh>
 
To be fair id take gardner and maybe larsson as a back up.
wickham yes but not at that price and i dont know anything about dong to comment.
and no one you have signed would get into our first team (depending on how good this dong is)
larsson is no better than joey on the right and joey isnt even a rw.
Gardner is good but not as good as Tiote or Barton in the middle, or cabaye maybe? and no were near ben arfa at CAM
Dong i dont know and wickam is too young to be near a premier league first team.
 
I'm afraid I'd pick unknowns like Connor and Dong over known ****e like Loverkrands and Ameobi. Except for the derby, I'd always play Shola in the derby!

I agree about the midfield though. Newcastle do have a cracking set of players in the middle of the park.
 
Its funny but our 'second' team, ripped apart by injuries, still finished the season as top dogs in the NE and now, with the additions of 5 players, we are apparently still not good enough and after they have sold their 2nd top goalscorer?

Funny that isn't it?

The delusional, window licking **** munchers form NE1 really know their carrots dont they? Just a shame they know **** all about football though. Bless
 
French Connection NUFC said:
To be fair id take gardner and maybe larsson as a back up.
wickham yes but not at that price and i dont know anything about dong to comment.
and no one you have signed would get into our first team (depending on how good this dong is)
larsson is no better than joey on the right and joey isnt even a rw.
Gardner is good but not as good as Tiote or Barton in the middle, or cabaye maybe? and no were near ben arfa at CAM
Dong i dont know and wickam is too young to be near a premier league first team.
Click to expand...

It makes you wonder how they didn't win the league eh! <doh>
 
MrRAWhite said:
It makes you wonder how they didn't win the league eh! <doh>
Click to expand...

If none of our players would get into their team, how did virtually our 2nd string still finish above them.

They really are hapless ****wits from NE1?:emoticon-0140-rofl:


SAFC = Top NE Club
 
Cestriamackem said:
If none of our players would get into their team, how did virtually our 2nd string still finish above them.

They really are hapless ****wits from NE1?:emoticon-0140-rofl:


SAFC = Top NE Club
Click to expand...

See, this was going pretty smoothly until you turned up. Forgot we had absolutely zero injuries last year as well, how silly of me.

League position doesnt mean all that much, if we had held on and won 3-2 last game of the season you wouldnt have admitted we were a better side, even though that would have made us finish above you.
 
Smudger said:
See, this was going pretty smoothly until you turned up. Forgot we had absolutely zero injuries last year as well, how silly of me.

League position doesnt mean all that much, if we had held on and won 3-2 last game of the season you wouldnt have admitted we were a better side, even though that would have made us finish above you.
Click to expand...

How else do you judge a team over the season?
 
Raaaul said:
How else do you judge a team over the season?
Click to expand...

So a last minute goal didnt get conceded and we'd be the better team in your eyes? Bullshit.

Admittedly the team that wins the league obviously deserves it but it's not to say the best team always wins and the second best team always comes second etc, luck obviously plays a massive part.
 
Smudger said:
So a last minute goal didnt get conceded and we'd be the better team in your eyes? Bull****.

Admittedly the team that wins the league obviously deserves it but it's not to say the best team always wins and the second best team always comes second etc, luck obviously plays a massive part.
Click to expand...

Better team can grind wins out even if they're not playing well, which is why Sunderland finished above you. Every point counts.
 
5-1, you been leaving me cack rep young man?????

No, I know it wasn't you.

Just pulling your pisser like.
 
Raaaul said:
Better team can grind wins out even if they're not playing well, which is why Sunderland finished above you. Every point counts.
Click to expand...

Sunderland finished above us because we royally ****ed up and threw away a 3 goal lead in our final game of the season. That's it. So we pounded them once, almost beat them again and only gave up finishing above purely down to our own doing. I'm not too bothered about this seasons results to be honest. I couldn't give a **** about what anyone else thinks. I personally know the real performances and who was the better team. Us.
 
Not a bad thread, and one thing is true the mags DID have a good midfield last year, the one worrying this is,Chicken wings was mentioned..

Now i personally think he's a good player, and did a good job, but tell me again, where is he now?

If i'm not mistaken, he preffered to take a drop in leagues, rather than staying.

Tiote will only play half a season, and that leaves Barton (will he still be there) and an unknown snail muncher. So maybe one of our new signings may sneak into their team.

Doubt it though, they probably have an unknown tibetan monk super midfield general hidden away somewhere. Maybe he's hiding in the trophy cabinet and no ****er can find him..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back