Off Topic Mafia game: The island

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

You're the only person who has defended the choice to go upstairs. You haven't actively told people to vote upstairs, but you've jumped in to defend it as an option more than once.

To be fair to Biscan, I have given reasons why I think upstairs is the right choice too. That might put me in the firing line, but I still think it makes sense to investigate upstairs as we know that is where something happened. However, to counter that, we may find out completely new information going elsewhere which will tell us more about the overall game.

 

[astro]

Upstairs votes and reasoning:

I vote for Explore upstairs as that's where the chemical smell came from, sounds like a logical place to start. Guessing it's the area closest next to the balcony.

Lol and the chaos ensues!.

I'm going upstairs. The garden is a death trap personally with all them trees to hide the killer

For me the strongest clue so far is the smell. The smell leads to the gardens.

Tennisball was the first to say upstairs, but with [HASHTAG]#legit[/HASHTAG] reasoning. I vote for BobbyD as the next person to vote for it and a possible bandwagon jumper who hasn't been involved in any further discussion since this post.

 

[afcftw]

With the risk of getting into bed with the devil, nothing personal Bisc, I agree that too much is being made of whether we go upstairs or elsewhere.

As said I would expect upstairs to have more than one room. Even if we end up in the "killing" room the "gas" will already have dissipated and I doubt whether that will kill anyone and we may find something we have overlooked. No harm in double checking.

Is it not suspicious though that we have three options and after a handful of people suggest one option early on, it now seems the only option we are considering? Everyone is saying it doesn't matter where we go....just as long as we go upstairs... Lol

I don't trust it!

 

[Captainchaos.]

Upstairs votes and reasoning:






For me the strongest clue so far is the smell. The smell leads to the gardens.

Tennisball was the first to say upstairs, but with [HASHTAG]#legit[/HASHTAG] reasoning. I vote for BobbyD as the next person to vote for it and a possible bandwagon jumper who hasn't been involved in any further discussion since this post.

I agree but kill afc because hes probably the serial killer

Like dumb policeman youre assuming the biggest clue is the crime scene, however its the evidence leading to the crime that concluded it.

 

[Rum & Black for 2]

To be fair to Biscan, I have given reasons why I think upstairs is the right choice too. That might put me in the firing line, but I still think it makes sense to investigate upstairs as we know that is where something happened. However, to counter that, we may find out completely new information going elsewhere which will tell us more about the overall game.

How are the splinters No Chance?

 

[astro]

I think people are looking into the where to go option way too much.

Because it's the only clue I have to work with, and the only decision I have to make aside from lynching which doesn't have clues yet. Do you have something else to go on? Those famous "reads" that always work so much better than logic?

Something ng happened upstairs, let's go there was as far as my logic goes.

Something happened upstairs earlier in the day and the scene was checked out already. Even if something turns up there, who's to say the bad guys don't have the option to place false evidence at scenes? The garden link comes from MITO's own clue.

 

[afcftw]

I agree but kill afc because hes probably the serial killer

Wtf lol why am I the serial killer? If anything we know I was the one who saw 23 fall from the balcony and so know I wasn't involved! (Not to mention we are pretty much decided 23 died due to trying to escape!) unless I've missed some other highly intelligent bit of info you've given us that suggests I'm a SK? Lol

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Upstairs votes and reasoning:






For me the strongest clue so far is the smell. The smell leads to the gardens.

Tennisball was the first to say upstairs, but with [HASHTAG]#legit[/HASHTAG] reasoning. I vote for BobbyD as the next person to vote for it and a possible bandwagon jumper who hasn't been involved in any further discussion since this post.

Genuine question: Why does the smell lead to the gardens? I know we smelled it there, but if we think 23 was poisoned then wouldn't he poisoning have taken place upstairs? If the poison emanated from the garden I think we would have been exposed to it too.

 

[Style]

Just arrived.

I vote RHC and The Garden

 

[Captainchaos.]

Wtf lol why am I the serial killer? If anything we know I was the one who saw 23 fall from the balcony and so know I wasn't involved! (Not to mention we are pretty much decided 23 died due to trying to escape!) unless I've missed some other highly intelligent bit of info you've given us that suggests I'm a SK? Lol

Just because you saw him fall didnt mean you didnt do it.

 

[afcftw]

Just because you saw him fall didnt mean you didnt do it

Doesn't mean I did do it either!!!

 

[astro]

Genuine question: Why does the smell lead to the gardens? I know we smelled it there, but if we think 23 was poisoned then wouldn't he poisoning have taken place upstairs? If the poison emanated from the garden I think we would have been exposed to it too.

Do a thread search for my posts, I give all the evidence. Basically the smell means it's either ETO or HCN poison. Both of these are used as pesticides so if we explore the gardens and find pesticides then that means we are correct and might get some reward from MITO (why would he reward stupidly going upstairs again?). ETO is also used to make tobacco plants grow, so finding tobacco plants in the garden also confirms the theory.

 

[afcftw]

Can we have a vote table @moreinjuredthanowen ?

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Just because you saw him fall didnt mean you didnt do it

I suspect that MITO wouldn't have given away anybody's role in the opening post. The choice of player who spoke or witnessed things was either done at random or for comedic effect.

 

[Captainchaos.]

Hmmmmm another garden vote

Obviously downstairs

Downstairs

 

[Captainchaos.]

I suspect that MITO wouldn't have given away anybody's role in the opening post. The choice of player who spoke or witnessed things was either done at random or for comedic effect.

You know im usually right

Afc

Garden

 

[afcftw]

You know im usually right

Afc

Garden

Don't think I've ever seen you be right in one of these games

 

[InBiscanWeTrust]

AFC is being far too talkative to have a role... Unless he's learnt that he's an easy read in these games and decided to try switch it up <whistle<

 

[afcftw]

Can I just point out that Gerrez has confirmed he isn't working today and yet he hasn't spammed the hell out of the game.... Someone's got a role

 

[Captainchaos.]

Don't think I've ever seen you be right in one of these games

Youve seen the death in this one though havent you