Off Topic mafia 5: game thread

My think if 2 people have 2 votes and no lunch has 5 that it still goes to coin toss for thhe 2 people.... Only if everyone votes no lynch does nothing happen... I think?

 

That renders No lynch pointless then.
May aswell just not submit a vote if it works like that.
I thought No lynch was voting to not lynch someone, not just that you personally are abstaining from the vote.
Can you confirm MITO?

 

That's not how I ran it in the previous game, but MITO can clarify.

If people vote no lynch that is something they decide on. For me, a load of innocent people aren't going to stand by while someone tries to lynch somebody with just 1 or two votes when 5 don't want a lynch.

 

I'm not sure. But with no lynch, both sides have opportunities to put their actions to use. I'm not sure of the possible outcomes but if both sides use all their abilities you can get far more information on the second day with reports, the newspaper, witnesses, etc.

I'm not following astro's strategy so I don't really care if it contradicts it haha. Interesting to see you've jumped on the first person to put forth a legible theory against the mafia

 

hi, here is the clarification.

there is no compulsion on the town to lynch which means no lynch is an option here.

simply majority rule is in effect which means if the majority vote no lynch there is no lynch.

 

I haven't decided yet

 

Name​	Vote 1​	Vote 2​	Vote 3​	Vote 4​	Vote 5​
Biscan	Nozzer
No Lynch	Astro	bobbyD	Bodanki	mikey	Danilo
Swarbs	IBWT	RHC
Bodanki	AFCFTW
Danilo	Swarbs

no votes for:

RHC
AFCFTW
Astro
mikey
magic
Billy
Gerrez
Nozzer
Valley
Less hope than neville
Obi wan
real morgan freeman
BobbyD
goonercymraeg

 

What a surprise that 90% of the people with no votes haven't said a god damned word.
Just noticed there seem to be like 4 people keeping this thread going and the rest are ****ing mute!!

You guys playing or what?

 

Still waiting on 8 or so people to even comment!

 

I reckon a couple of those currently on no lynch are mafia... Nice early way to appear innocent....

 

Yup, need a rule that if you dont comment at least 3 times in each day cycle, you contract Ebola, and Small pox, and AIDS.
And you become a United fan.

 

Definitely some quiet ones are mafia too but we need some comments and votes to have more to go on

 

I fully intended to change my vote based on how Day 1 went, but no one is saying anything.

 

afcftw have you #officially decided not to follow the proposal to name a load of players for us to vote for because you can't leave it too late if you're going to.

 

No way I'm voting for no lunch!

 

Well, if we don't lynch anyone tonight it means the mafia money pot is growing and we are no closer to figuring things out, mafia can just sit back and do nothing, not sure how much we can gain from that strategy. Though I suppose the journalist might then have some info for us?

On the other hand there is no guarantee I pick mafia in my selection, but if by chance it's a good selection we could see late vote movement... Hmmm....

 

It's possible MITO already has that rule in place.

You went too far. Plus Swarbs is immune.

 

The table doesn't work on the app so I have no idea on the voting situation

 

That's why you have to decide soon FFS

The point isn't that you magically guess the right people but that you have a list to start from. Then we see movement. If you leave it too late everything goes to **** anyway though.

 

BTW if you are going to suggest a list I propose you start with all the people who haven't posted. They are either mafia hiding, or are useless to us anyway.