Transfer Rumours January Transfer Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
It's always funny how players who aren't here or aren't playing become highly rated again because we're not seeing them play. Longman was an absolute favourite target for criticism last season. Now that he's not here and we lack good wingers, people are being generous to him. It's always the way.

A bit like Seri.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PLT
After watching last nights game I still think we're crying out for players this window. 2 upgrades to the full back positions, not young kids who can do a job but proper first team players who will improve the team going forward and in defence. The young kid at left back did a good job and proved he deserves to be in the squad, but we should be looking at a better player starting ahead of him.. Coyle also for me isnt good enough for the way we play, good backup option maybe, but nothing more..

2 wingers, cover for Philogene and a decent right wing option. We're fine everywhere else really, I know a nasty bastard in midfield would please most of us but I dont think Rosenior will ever want that type of player.

Lastly a striker is vital if we want any chance at top 6 this season. I honestly dont care what Rosenior says about not being concerned about that position as I think he's bluffing. We were light before the injuries, now its just ridiculous. Sharp is a nice option to have off the bench, with 15 minutes to go but he shouldnt be starting games for us.

If we are indeed serious about top 6 we need to show it this window. Ship out whoever we dont need and bring in what we do.

The nasty bastard in midfield (Ashbee) just wouldn't work in the modern game. That type of player would constantly have us down to ten men, or be serving suspensions. You can't just point at Norwich tactics. A competent referee would have had them down to 9 players, and there is no escaping that if we get promoted and are subject to the scrutiny of VAR with the amount of "fairy" players who fall over when the wind changes direction. (i.e. a league full of Scott Twines).
 
It's always funny how players who aren't here or aren't playing become highly rated again because we're not seeing them play. Longman was an absolute favourite target for criticism last season. Now that he's not here and we lack good wingers, people are being generous to him. It's always the way.
I don't think anyone is 'highly rating' Longman. It's just that he would have been useful back up these past few and coming weeks. Better than playing players so clearly out of position and would give more than the likes of Lokilo of late (and sorry to say Vaughan too, who inexcusably lost his man for their 2nd on Friday).
 
  • Like
Reactions: highpeak tiger
The nasty bastard in midfield (Ashbee) just wouldn't work in the modern game. That type of player would constantly have us down to ten men, or be serving suspensions. You can't just point at Norwich tactics. A competent referee would have had them down to 9 players, and there is no escaping that if we get promoted and are subject to the scrutiny of VAR with the amount of "fairy" players who fall over when the wind changes direction. (i.e. a league full of Scott Twines).

You don’t need someone like Ashbee or Roy Keane in today’s game but you do need at least one holding midfield player who sits deeper than the rest of the midfield, protects the back four and whose job is to break up play in the middle third. Doesn’t have to be crunching tackles. Defensive mids have to be good at winning headers and making interceptions as well. Morton and Slater both like to get forward. Seri tends to sit deeper when he has Slater or Morton next to him but he himself gets outmuscled off the ball too easily, is weak in the air and doesn’t have the legs to be a defensive mid in today’s English game.

There’s affordable options in League One like Luca Connell at Barnsley, Hector Kyprianou at Posh and George Dobson at Charlton.
 
You don’t need someone like Ashbee or Roy Keane in today’s game but you do need at least one holding midfield player who sits deeper than the rest of the midfield, protects the back four and whose job is to break up play in the middle third. Doesn’t have to be crunching tackles. Defensive mids have to be good at winning headers and making interceptions as well. Morton and Slater both like to get forward. Seri tends to sit deeper when he has Slater or Morton next to him but he himself gets outmuscled off the ball too easily, is weak in the air and doesn’t have the legs to be a defensive mid in today’s English game.
Was penning a similar answer, so thanks, you've saved me the effort.
Although tbf Seri is surprisingly good in the air! But just isn't that sort of player.
In a similar way, it's becoming ever more clear to me that we also need something different at CB imo too.
We are far too lightweight all over. So many signings brought in yet we are missing what's needed. #can'thavetoomany10's
 
  • Like
Reactions: springtiger
Whilst I was at Total Fitness I saw Harry Vaughn and Jacob Greaves in deep conversation with a Left Back who doesn’t play for us…mmmm intriguing


… however, the left back isn’t playing much for Shrewsbury either! It was good to Brandon Fleming having a laugh with his old team mates!
 
Last edited:
Second half of the season there's usually one or two teams that suddenly go on a run, get our lads back from the African nations Cup, Philo fit and firing again, and Carvalho up to speed there is no reason why we can't be one of them, I'm pretty sure by the end of January we'll have sorted at least one of the full back positions. Who knows, we may even have a couple of extra to throw into the mix. Not giving up hope yet.
 
I don't think anyone is 'highly rating' Longman. It's just that he would have been useful back up these past few and coming weeks. Better than playing players so clearly out of position and would give more than the likes of Lokilo of late (and sorry to say Vaughan too, who inexcusably lost his man for their 2nd on Friday).
We’d switched to three at the back to bring him on and to be fair, he was probably looking to get forward again as we all thought that Jones had won the ball back, only for him to inexplicably present it back to their player who crossed it to the back post for their substitute to score.
 
Whilst I was at Total Fitness I saw Harry Vaughn and Jacob Greaves in deep conversation with a Left Back who doesn’t play for us…mmmm intriguing


… however, the left isn’t playing much for Shrewsbury either! It was good to Brandon Fleming having a laugh with his old team mates!
I am completely puzzled as to why they would be at Total FItness i presume its a gym. Surely City have a gym.
 
I am completely puzzled as to why they would be at Total FItness i presume its a gym. Surely City have a gym.
I’ve seen a few of the Hull FC players there to undertake recuperation the day after a game, but very rarely any of our lads - so yes it was a bit of a surprise. They used the steam room, sauna and hydrotherapy pool. Like you, I would have imagined they would have those facilities - some where, although perhaps Brandon can’t access them whilst he’s Shrewsbury?
 
I’ve seen a few of the Hull FC players there to undertake recuperation the day after a game, but very rarely any of our lads - so yes it was a bit of a surprise. They used the steam room, sauna and hydrotherapy pool. Like you, I would have imagined they would have those facilities - some where, although perhaps Brandon can’t access them whilst he’s Shrewsbury?

do we have those facilities though
our training ground is a couple portacabins with a tiny gym in it
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tigerboy98
Whilst I was at Total Fitness I saw Harry Vaughn and Jacob Greaves in deep conversation with a Left Back who doesn’t play for us…mmmm intriguing


… however, the left isn’t playing much for Shrewsbury either! It was good to Brandon Fleming having a laugh with his old team mates!
I saw Vinagre wandering around town yesterday morning. He was on his tod mind.

When I recognised him he noticed me doing so and looked like he was dreading a bit of fan interaction, leading me to wonder why he was wearing a Hull City gilet if he didn’t want to be noticed.

So I just have him a nod and carried on my way…
 
I saw Vinagre wandering around town yesterday morning. He was on his tod mind.

When I recognised him he noticed me doing so and looked like he was dreading a bit of fan interaction, leading me to wonder why he was wearing a Hull City gilet if he didn’t want to be noticed.

So I just have him a nod and carried on my way…

Probably worried you were one of those fans who would bombard him with stats, xGs, transitioning through the thirds, low blocks etc…
 
We’d switched to three at the back to bring him on and to be fair, he was probably looking to get forward again as we all thought that Jones had won the ball back, only for him to inexplicably present it back to their player who crossed it to the back post for their substitute to score.
He was back in position marking him during that phase but their player just drifted away from him and he totally let him go / lost him. It was piss poor.
 
Probably worried you were one of those fans who would bombard him with stats, xGs, transitioning through the thirds, low blocks etc…
I’ve got no idea how good his English is or how confident a bloke he is so I imagine he was dreading having a conversation at all to be fair!
 
Supposedly Brizzle will have a deal agreed for Twine within 24 hours. Would be leaving ourselves very short if so, he played very well on Friday too.
 
Supposedly Brizzle will have a deal agreed for Twine within 24 hours. Would be leaving ourselves very short if so, he played very well on Friday too.
Yep it sounds like he’s close to going if he hasn’t already. Agree on his performance on Friday, still not sure whether he’s worth the money being suggested but there is a player in there if he’s played in the right position.

It really does seem idiotic that we’re letting him (although maybe not much our choice) and Allahyar leave with seemingly no imminent replacements when we have such a threadbare squad.