Lets have a look at some of the facts an Insolvency Practitioner would want before offering any advice. Firstly Hull City Tigers Limited is the football club. They have a lease with the Stadium Management Company (who presumably owns the training ground, the land at Melton and the Ideal Standard facility as they are not shown in the accounts of Hull City Tigers Limited). The Stadium Management Company has the lease with Hull City Council and would lose Hull City Tigers Limited's rent. It would still be liable for the maintenance of the stadium and would have a valid tenancy with Hull FC. I'm sure Adam Pearson would ensure that the Stadium Management Company would fulfil its responsibilities.
Unless you know what assets and liabilities the SMC has you wouldn't know whether it would be worthwhile putting it into liquidation.
So we come to Hull City Tigers Limited, the last accounts show players worth £21 million. On liquidation they become worthless as their contracts are terminated. Which is how we got Sone Aluko for nothing last season. What assets Hull City Tigers Limited would be left with is cash at bank, debtors, stock in the shop and bits of machinery. All of those assets would be used to pay the liquidator's fees. By putting the club into liquidation Assem Allam loses all his investment. He would also lose the £50 to £60 million worth of tax losses that are available for Allamhouse and Allam Marine. At 20% corporation tax they are worth up to £12 million hard cash. By putting the club into liquidation Assem Allam will lose well over £100 million.
He could put the club into administration. All that means is that the administrator tries to find a buyer for the club. The administrator could only sell if Assem Allam agrees the sale. The costs of the sale together with the administrator's fees come out of the sale price. The fees charged by Portsmouth's administrator, according to Accountancy Age, were £2.2 million. On top of that was the professional advice received to re-negotiate player's contracts and deal with the legal position of about £1.3 million. If Assem Allam wanted to sell the club he'd be far better putting it up for sale himself, he'd save a fortune in fees.
He'd also lose the benefits of the tax losses.
Either way he is likely to lose more than he would gain if he just sold the players himself and pocketed the parachute payments. Unless Assem Allam has no thought for his children and grandchildren he won't be going anywhere near liquidation or administration.
Feel free to take this to an Insolvency Practitioner, I'm sure they'll agree with my analysis, unless, of course, they want the job.
I agree finding a buyer himself would be the cheapest option but I am not sure he will find one in a relegation scenario,
