First thoughts

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Norwich fan in peace. I, like many City fans, have a soft spot for Sunderland and I have to say I'm a little bit worried by some of the signings.

Westwood is a good young keeper and should serve you well and I won't comment on the Korean bloke as I know nothing about him. However the six mention in the original post are cause for concern.

Larssen, Vaughn and Gardener all played for clubs that were relegated, yes they were the better players at those clubs, but I'd still be worried that they weren't good enough last year and now they're that little bit older.

Brown and O'Shea are on the slide. O'Shea never fulfilled his potential due to never really have a specialist position and Brown is in my opinion one of the most over-rated players I've ever seen. He's a good solid player but if he wasn't at Man Utd I don't think he'd ever have played for England or lasted this long in the Premier League.

Wickham is a great prospect, but nothing more than that at the moment. He wasn't bad at championship level and had good games and bad games and will certainly be a star in the future, but at the moment he's probably a championship squad player at best. Even the Ipswich fans were saying he wasn't good enough and shouldn't have won the Football League young player of the year last year.

However I do hope Sunderland do well next season (with the exception of two games ;) ) and I hope every word I've just typed is proved wrong.

With all due respect (and i say this as a lad who is delighted to see Norwich back in the big league <ok>), i think that you'll gather the Sunderland fans are pretty ****ing happy with the aquisitions, thanks for your concern, but i think we'll be ok.
 
You just have to laugh a one of the fans from a club that will be all to probably relegated next season, due to a total lack of EPL quality in their team, coming on to our board and having a pop at us signing 5 EPL players (for less than 12m) with pedigree and experience, one of the hottest young strikers in the game today, an experienced international keeper (who may be back up anyway to our 2 other international keepers) and a wild card in Ji Dong Won (a very highly rated Korean lad)?

I'd worry about beating Derby County's points tally before I would be offering advice to us kidda and I think you are talking out of your tractor driving arse - with all due respects of course?
 
Outside of using Wiki or you tube, what the **** do you know about ANY of your signings?

Every one of ours, bar Ji Dong Won of course, is a household name in the EPL or the English game.

<laugh>

Robbie Savage is a household name in the EPL, but I wouldn't want him anywhere near my club.

What do I know about the players we've signed? Well I saw Ba play a few times last season and he was a class act, and you lot wanted him as much as we did. Admittedly I'm not too impressed by Marveaux, but he's better than Gardner and Larsson, and we have Jonas and Ferguson who also play his position so it doesn't matter if it doesn't work out. Cabaye I haven't seen much of, but I've heard excellent things about him.
 
You just have to laugh a one of the fans from a club that will be all to probably relegated next season, due to a total lack of EPL quality in their team, coming on to our board and having a pop at us signing 5 EPL players.

I'd worry about beating Derby County's points tally before I would be offering advice to us kidda and I think you are talking out of your tractor driving arse - with all due respects of course?

The lad only gave an honest opinion, no need to fly off the handle. It's almost as if deep down you know your signings are ****, and have resorted to lashing out against reasonable comments in order to defend them.
 
One Newcastle fans view from their board
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Players NUFC should sign: Wes Brown
Continuing on from yesterday I have added another player to my blog. This summer I think we should sign Wes Brown.
Sol Campbell will no doubt leave the club in the summer, or maybe even move into the coaching staff so that will leave us one centre defender down.


My choice to fill this position would be Wes Brown from Manchester United. Brown came through the youth ranks at Old Trafford and has been a solid squad member for the past 10 years, but has never really been a constant starter. Brown has bags of experience and could help our younger / less experienced defenders learn the game. You do not spend your entire career at Man Utd and pick up England caps if you are not quality.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

could he be right? I think he could well be.
 
One Newcastle fans view from their board
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Players NUFC should sign: Wes Brown
Continuing on from yesterday I have added another player to my blog. This summer I think we should sign Wes Brown.
Sol Campbell will no doubt leave the club in the summer, or maybe even move into the coaching staff so that will leave us one centre defender down.


My choice to fill this position would be Wes Brown from Manchester United. Brown came through the youth ranks at Old Trafford and has been a solid squad member for the past 10 years, but has never really been a constant starter. Brown has bags of experience and could help our younger / less experienced defenders learn the game. You do not spend your entire career at Man Utd and pick up England caps if you are not quality.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------

could he be right? I think he could well be.

Decided to ignore all the other comments where we said he isnt good enough? <laugh>

& That article is from months ago, before anyone says I'm only saying he is ****e because you lot signed him.

Gardener is a decent player, and I'd have liked O'Shea as he can cover all the defence, so. <ok>