FA Cup 3rd round

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
D

Deleted #

Well-Known Member
Jun 27, 2011
20,570
10,134
113
Jarrow
I read Sam Allardyces notes in the programme yesterday and reading between the lines, he is moreorless saying that with the Swansea and Tottenham games following, he won't be playing a strong team against Arsenal, as the league is his number one focus. Pickford will be starting.

What do people think the team will be? Is Larsson fit?

Pickford and Beadling should get their first starts, Gooch could well be on the bench. Brown will almost certainly come out of the team and one of Jones and PVA will make way for Yedlin. Cattermole should be rested, IMO. He's coming back from a back injury and he's unbelievably important to us. Defoe will make way for Fletcher, Borini or Watmore will probably make way for Danny Graham. Toivenon will play in place of Johnson or M'Vila.
 
Safc83 said:
I read Sam Allardyces notes in the programme yesterday and reading between the lines, he is moreorless saying that with the Swansea and Tottenham games following, he won't be playing a strong team against Arsenal, as the league is his number one focus. Pickford will be starting.

What do people think the team will be? Is Larsson fit?

Pickford and Beadling should get their first starts, Gooch could well be on the bench. Brown will almost certainly come out of the team and one of Jones and PVA will make way for Yedlin. Cattermole should be rested, IMO. He's coming back from a back injury and he's unbelievably important to us. Defoe will make way for Fletcher, Borini or Watmore will probably make way for Danny Graham. Toivenon will play in place of Johnson or M'Vila.
Click to expand...

That`s a shocking indictment on the shallowness of quality in the squad.

According to the physio room Larsson due back on the 12th, Kaboul on the 23rd.

Seems to me like an opportunity to let the young `uns have a go. Let the buggers loose. Tell them to get out there and enjoy themselves. They just might spring a few surprises.
 
  • Like
Reactions: red&white wanderer, Charley Farley, Billy Death and 3 others
He's got form for playing a weakened team. Remember Forest thrashing West Ham 5-0?

That's fine by me. The squads threadbare and the league is the priority?

Can you imagine if Defoe and Catts were both badly injured, or sent off next week?
 
  • Like
Reactions: clockstander
Didn't Mick Mack get fined 10 grand when he,fielded a weakened side whilst at Wolves, also Holloway got in bother doing the same at Blackpool, then I think the FA had a change of heart as the likes of Arsenal were doing the dame and nowt ever happened to them, does the team have to be made up from the 25 man squad?.
 
cumbrianmackem said:
Didn't Mick Mack get fined 10 grand when he,fielded a weakened side whilst at Wolves, also Holloway got in bother doing the same at Blackpool, then I think the FA had a change of heart as the likes of Arsenal were doing the dame and nowt ever happened to them, does the team have to be made up from the 25 man squad?.
Click to expand...

Didn't Holloway play a weakened team against a top PL side in the league so he could rest his players for the more winnable PL game afterwards?

No wonder he's unemployable nowadays, absolute idiot of a bloke. To think so many labelled him a breath of fresh air that season is beyond belief.
 
Tell wenger we will play the reserves next Saturday, but really play the first team at the last minute ! and catch him out. Liverpool in the 1970's never fielded weakened teams and look what they won and on rubbish pitches. You have to play the strongest team possible in EVERY game in my book.
 
grandpops said:
Sam can`t go too overboard though mate. Not sure but can`t he get into trouble if he deliberately weakens it too much?
Click to expand...
nah you have a squad of 25 where does it say the fa have to pick them its the manager choice, due to form injuries resting players ect
 
monty987 said:
Tell wenger we will play the reserves next Saturday, but really play the first team at the last minute ! and catch him out. Liverpool in the 1970's never fielded weakened teams and look what they won and on rubbish pitches. You have to play the strongest team possible in EVERY game in my book.
Click to expand...


It's all about priorities Monty. The league has to come first, last and always.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SC SAFC
-------------------- Pickford -----------------

Yedlin -- Beadling -- Coates -- PVA

Watmore -- Gomez -- Toivonen -- Lens

------------ Fletcher -- Graham ------------

The team could look something like that <yikes>
 
Play the u21s the fa wouldn't care. The other instances mentioned were in the league where such a thing could cost another or even several teams directly in that competition. With the one off nature of the cup this doesn't happen and is probably why it's not as frowned upon.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Relic, clockstander and grandpops
Think he might go 343 again after it worked so well in the league game there.

-----Coates OShea Beadling

Yeddy Gomez Cattermole PVA

----Watmore Fletcher Lens

Gooners will weaken but play same shape as usual.
 
Tell the pups to go out and kick anything that moves, if you ask me. That said, if the mags can give them a game, perhaps we really should have a go?
 
This is a real dilemma for me. I love the FA Cup and hate the way it has been undermined in recent years.
On the other hand we have three away games in seven days, with the midweek league game against Swansea particularly important.
I will leave this one to the manager's judgement and will not condemn him if we play a weakened side and get a trouncing against Arsenal.
 
Couldn't care less about the FA Cup this year.

Write it off and concentrate on the league.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back