Evans' tackle

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
He is from Leeds so fair play for supporting his home team. The fact he's from Yorkshire probably made the decision to come here easier too. Dudgeon is also from Leeds. I'm guessing he's a Leeds fan too. Nothing wrong with it.

Here here well said if you do not support where you come from you would be a Manchester United fan lol
 
Id sign Myhill if we went up, only keeper we've had in recent years that won us 10 points a season with some great performances, and his kicking was nowhere near as bad as folk made out.

Spot on he never wanted to leave he may have made mistakes but he is Hull City through and through
 
Myhill def for me.. been watching alot of the games from the second season of the prem and myhill was fantastic in pretty much every game
 
whats interesting is, bruce was the one who actually officially relegated us <laugh>
 
Myhill was a decent 'keeper but not great. He was a great servant to the club but not that great a 'keeper. He's of similar ability to Stockdale to be honest, Mannone was and is better than both of them, I'd be thrilled if we could get him back.
 
Myhill was a decent 'keeper but not great. He was a great servant to the club but not that great a 'keeper. He's of similar ability to Stockdale to be honest, Mannone was and is better than both of them, I'd be thrilled if we could get him back.

Totally agree. Both Myhill and Stockdale are accidents waiting to happen on every CK and high ball into the box. Myhill great close in shot stopper...incredible reactions...hopeless on long shots. Stockdale pussies out on every one on one with a striker...latest see Hendersons goal. Mannone far better than both...gives defenders confidence...tough as nails. Same as Schmeichel. Bo and Stockdale...not even close!
 
Totally agree. Both Myhill and Stockdale are accidents waiting to happen on every CK and high ball into the box. Myhill great close in shot stopper...incredible reactions...hopeless on long shots. Stockdale pussies out on every one on one with a striker...latest see Hendersons goal. Mannone far better than both...gives defenders confidence...tough as nails. Same as Schmeichel. Bo and Stockdale...not even close!

Agree about that, myhill always tended to badly parry long shots into the penalty area
 
When you collect a ball like that and take such a nasty fall you're bound to drop the ball.

I was amazed it wasn't a foul.

I know no bugger actually touched him but whenever a 'keeper goes down it's always a foul for some reason. We've even had goals disallowed when the 'keeper has fouled the attacker who scored rather than vice versa.

Really? So how come he coudn't get a game at a bottom feeding PL club, and how come that when his availability was made obvious by Fulham that there wasn't a queue of PL clubs waiting to snap him him up, even if only to drop into their squads?

Stockdale in a self confessed Leeds supporter, that never goes down well, and an average keeper that would be ok as a number 2 in a PL squad, in my honest opinion.

He's also made England squads...

Totally agree. Both Myhill and Stockdale are accidents waiting to happen on every CK and high ball into the box. Myhill great close in shot stopper...incredible reactions...hopeless on long shots. Stockdale pussies out on every one on one with a striker...latest see Hendersons goal. Mannone far better than both...gives defenders confidence...tough as nails. Same as Schmeichel. Bo and Stockdale...not even close!

That's mostly balls though. Myhill made some amazing long-range saves including several from Van Persie and Fabregas when we won at the Emirates. And Stockdale made a really good one on one save against Vaughan yesterday, wasn't scared at all.
 
Not had time to read this thread but if people are picking at Stockdale then thats incredible really but not surprising, there was a fair few on here thinking Guzan was substandard when we had him too. As an ex-keeper myself Stockdale I can say is well up to the task in hand. Keepers always come in for criticism as if they make a single mistake it usually stands out, he lost grip of the ball yesterday but came down to earth from a pretty good height and was there to try and take the ball.
 
I think stockdale is ****ing brilliant. He needs a little less crazy when he leaps out to punch or collect balls but otherwise he is a solid goalkeeper. we haven't had that since myhill.

I think the bigger worry for us is what we do with jakupovic and proschwitz considering they cost 3 million together.

we can't keep buying players , play thema couple times and then buy someone else to replace them.
 
If we go up (if), and Sunderland go down, then what about Mignolet? Bruce signed him and from what I've heard he's been by far one of their better players this season.
 
We should sign Tony Warner, he,s got a sensible haircut and is a brilliant keeper. I,m telling you I know my onions I do
 
Can't imagine we'll see a better tackle all season.

The timing of the tackle, the position on the pitch and the time of the game right at the end.

Right, I've decided. I'm going to call it sensational.
 
Kinda see why Stockdale comes in for a bit of criticism - he seeme to have bottled a few one on ones - my take on that is, he probably doesn't want to get injured during his loan spell and is desperate to sign for us on a permanent. Also he hasn't had that many games and is still not up to speed this season.

As for him being a white ****e - like Dudge if he's good enough I could't give a fig..


Good basis to work on - liked Mannone but even he had his moments of madness - Boro home season before last?
 
I think stockdale is ****ing brilliant. He needs a little less crazy when he leaps out to punch or collect balls but otherwise he is a solid goalkeeper. we haven't had that since myhill.

I think the bigger worry for us is what we do with jakupovic and proschwitz considering they cost 3 million together.

we can't keep buying players , play thema couple times and then buy someone else to replace them.

Jakupovic and Proschwitz did not cost a combined fee of £3M.

Proschwitz cost less than £2.3M as that was the total spent on all players in the financial year we signed him. There may be add ons which can increase the fee in future, but they are appearance based, or based on us achieving promotion or other successes.

Jakupovic was a free transfer as he was in a contract dispute with his old club. That's why his international clearance took ages to come through. Unlike Aluko where we have to wait for the legal proceedings to finish before we know, Jakupovic definitely won't cost a fee in future as the matter was resolved and FIFA gave him proper clearance rather than temporary.
 
Agree about that, myhill always tended to badly parry long shots into the penalty area

That's if he even saw them. How many 20-30 yarders sailed in over his head. He just couldnt pick up or judge a long shot. Classic one was the goalies kick in the US last year which just went clean over him and he didnt have a clue. Remember Richardsons goal for Sunderland. Many others. He needed his eyes tested.

Then again he could be amazing on the close in stuff. Away at Tottenham...Watford in the playoffs. As for high balls I never had any confidence in him. Stockdale is an average Championship GK at best. No thanks. He nearly bottled the Vaughan 50/50 yesterday.