Sorry - "you break it you buy it" is the policy. He was good enough for England 2 years ago but now isn't good enough for Newcastle - You can keep hold thanks and keep paying his massively over-inflated wages!
Nah - the returns policy clearly stated a 2 year guarantee, and it only functioned properly for one year. Fancy taking your former legend Javier Manquillo back while you're at it?
If you attached £5m to his thatch I'd accept, but only if we could loan him back for the remaining term of his contact and his current employer continued to pay his wages. That way we'd get rid of Rodders in the process