Carroll - is it possible? And would you even want him?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think we all know he will be back somewhen, didn't think it would be so soon, id love him back as he seems to regret leaving and we will make a huge profit, then he would be our -£20M man
 
For £15 million I sincerely ****ing hope not! Thought the plan was always to have Ben Arfa playing behind Ba when HBA finally got fit and firing, why waste £15 million on someone to warm the bench?
 
It's weird because I can imagine us as the only club he'd ever leave Liverpool for. If he starts playing well they wont sell him and if he continues to underperform then only we would buy him.
 
Smudger said:
It's weird because I can imagine us as the only club he'd ever leave Liverpool for. If he starts playing well they wont sell him and if he continues to underperform then only we would buy him.
Click to expand...

I think if he was to leave Liverpool and we didn't want him I could see him joining somebody like Aston Villa.
 
I do not want him anyway. If we did have 15million to spend on a striker, we could get someone much better than him!
 
judzthegeordie said:
For £15 million I sincerely ****ing hope not! Thought the plan was always to have Ben Arfa playing behind Ba when HBA finally got fit and firing, why waste £15 million on someone to warm the bench?
Click to expand...

Ben Arfa on the wing, Carroll and Ba up front.
 
I have just decided there is NO CHANCE we will pay 10m for Mandy.

Can't see that happening , maybe maybe maybe a loan deal but 10m? <laugh>

10m based on what? The fact we sold him to them for 35m and we want to make their losses smaller?

Ha-ha.
 
15-20mil though...

Think of the players we could get who aren't Mandy.
 
Pardew has said he'd like Carroll back, but we all know Pardew isn't the one who decides who we sign.

Carr will have found us better players for the £15-20m
 
judzthegeordie said:
Would Ben Arfa thrive on the wing in that rigid formation though? I see him as a winger but in a more advanced 4-3-3 sort of wing role
Click to expand...

Yeah probably lol, just came out the top of my head lol.

Also, on Mandy - Pardew said players he will sign this January will have to be happy to stay on the bench and wait for their chance, not sure a £15m would be willing to do that, or Ashley would like Pardew to put him on the bench
 
For the sake of formation porn we could play a 4-3-3.

Krul
Santon Taylor Colo NewLB
Cabaye Tiote Guthrie
Benny - - Carroll - - Ba​
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back