No tin hat needed - we've all got opinions
Maguire looks off the pace as he never has a run in the team. You can't judge on a 5 minute cameo.
As a player he defends as well as Curtis but has twice the ability on the ball. Rewatch Arsenal away in the cup to see how he plays. There was a point against Man Utd when the ball came back to Curtis and he noncientally kicked the ball in touch as he didn't have the confidence to do anything with it.
I love Curtis by the way but think given a run Harry could be our best defender.