Transfer Rumours Winter 2025 January 1st until February 3rd

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
In a single game of football, if we were 4-0 down at half-time, would you take off all our best players to rest them for the next game, because the current one is already lost?

If so, fair enough. After all a loss is a loss.

Personally I wouldn't. I would argue that there is a big difference between losing 8-0, and losing 4-2, for a number of, perhaps less obvious, reasons.
I get your logic but I think having an extra £8m in the bank next season will benefit us significantly more than an extra 3 or 4 points this season (which is not guaranteed either way).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dark Lord SFC
I get your logic but I think having an extra £8m in the bank next season will benefit us significantly more than an extra 3 or 4 points this season (which is not guaranteed either way).

6 to 8m yes, I agree. But anything much less than that, I'd say no. Certainly not the 3-4 million that some people seem content with.
 
Jhon Duran off to Saudi for £70m, should help Villa with PSR
I thought Saudi football was attracting players at the end of their careers but Duran is just 21.
I suppose by going there at such a young age, he can return to a competitive league after a couple of years, should he want to.
 
I thought Saudi football was attracting players at the end of their careers but Duran is just 21.
I suppose by going there at such a young age, he can return to a competitive league after a couple of years, should he want to.

It’s a mixture really. The really high profile players are the older players but a fair few highly rated players in their mid/early 20s have gone as well.
 
Meh, I wouldn't be actively looking to sell him at this point but he's clearly well down the pecking order under Juric and I'm not convinced he's the type of striker that will succeed at Premier League level.
 
I'd be a bit disappointed to sell at this juncture, but I totally see the logic in letting him find his confidence and racking up some goals for a team in the promotion race for six months before we drop back down to Champ level
I would understand a straight loan but it is the rumoured insistence on the obligation to buy that I am worried by. Hopefully it is just a rumour.
 
Still a little bit of time, but I'm a little disappointed that we've not done much in the outgoings department.

Guess no-one wants players who aren't good enough for the worst ever PL side <laugh>
Yep unfortunately this is what happens when you sell the good and keep the **** over many years. You’re left with a bunch of unsellable crap.

We are in the exact same position as Manchester United at the moment. No one wants the low effort crap that’s filling the bench and the first team that we desperately need to offload. So the only bids are for the best players.

We will struggle to sell anyone that isn’t Dibling or Sulemana because they are the only two doing anything. Some clubs may want to loan others but that’s all yer getting.

Unfortunately this is all a mess of the clubs on making.
 
So just to get this right, we bought a load of ****e Championship level players in the summer. Unsurprisingly they've not been very good and we sit rock bottom of the PL effectively relegated before Christmas. So SR in their infinite wisdom decide now is the time to sell said Championship players and not buy anyone else.

What the actual **** is going on? An attempt at asset stripping before they **** off?
 
So just to get this right, we bought a load of ****e Championship level players in the summer. Unsurprisingly they've not been very good and we sit rock bottom of the PL effectively relegated before Christmas. So SR in their infinite wisdom decide now is the time to sell said Championship players and not buy anyone else.

What the actual **** is going on? An attempt at asset stripping before they **** off?

No. Just no.

To all of it.
 
So just to get this right, we bought a load of ****e Championship level players in the summer. Unsurprisingly they've not been very good and we sit rock bottom of the PL effectively relegated before Christmas. So SR in their infinite wisdom decide now is the time to sell said Championship players and not buy anyone else.

What the actual **** is going on? An attempt at asset stripping before they **** off?

On the plus side if we let Archer go out on loan this month you'll be collecting from me 4 months early :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: LincolnSaint
I don't see any reason to be worried about Archer leaving. He's not a key player for us and, while he might do well in the Championship, he's not (yet?) a proven performer at that level. I also suspect we're going to be playing in a way that works better with a big striker in the Pelle/Lambert mould rather than someone like Archer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ian Thumwood
I don't see any reason to be worried about Archer leaving. He's not a key player for us and, while he might do well in the Championship, he's not (yet?) a proven performer at that level. I also suspect we're going to be playing in a way that works better with a big striker in the Pelle/Lambert mould rather than someone like Archer.

18 goals in 40 games suggests he is fairly proven at Championship level.