I agree that he has hindered his reputation, but it is short-sighted to dismiss him for a moment of stupidity. I find Barton's behaviour against Man City a far worse crime yet after a spell away was welcomed with open arms by just about everyone and many on this board and feel he is still badly missed.
I appreciate comparing a manager with a player maybe viewed as a mismatch but I am comparing the crime and let's not forget Barton has re-offended on many other occasions, has Makay?
I think it may well be the case of why take the chance? There are other options out there. The same could of been said when we signed Barton.