Who thinks Maya is better than Cedric?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Who is the better RB?

  • Total voters
    92
  • Poll closed .
Pointless thread. I cannot believe you actually made this.

1. Cedric is the best right back
2. Yoshida is better than Martina at right back (and left back)
3. There is 99% chance Cedric was being rested on Saturday. As I've shown in the match thread you don't really pick a right back based on height because they don't contest many aerial duels, sometimes they contest none.
4. Yoshida is a good centre back, he's ok back up for left and right back. But he should never be starting games over a fit to play Cedric. I would have thought Cedric was being rested as mentioned above.
5. If someone questions team selection it doesn't mean they hate the player that they wanted to be left out. I like Yoshida. He just shouldn't be playing over (a fit to play) Cedric at right back, ever.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Ivan Golac's shoe laces, SouthamptonFCroatia, Ronnie Hotdogs (MLsfc) and 4 others
fatletiss said:
You can blame him, if almost all of his posts are that tone.

I'll risk dragging old ground up here so people realize I am not being a happy clapper. I criticized Pelle as I felt that over a period of time he had slipped in one key area of his game. You should read how that was met - I was battered, so I have sat that side of the fence. I, like TinTin, stood my ground. I don't believe I abused people. I may have been 'dog with a bone-esque,' but not abusive. I was also prepared to debate it and counter views, but TinTin doesn't; he just shouts at you.

The most nuts thing is (and why I did this poll) is everyone agrees that Cedric is the better full back. The coach sometimes chooses not to play him sometimes, that's all.

Finally and I may be wrong here. I believe that "Fonte Of All knowledge" was the one who first posted comments against that team selection that lead to a few people questioning him. I didn't read him getting aggressive. In fact he made light of it.
Click to expand...

And why? Maybe he plays horses for courses, or is giving Cedric a rest. Either way the bloke doesn't get much wrong
 
Tintin said:
I like Yoshida. He just shouldn't be playing over Cedric at right back, ever.
Click to expand...

Unless there is good reason for it which, short of Ron explaining to us very selection, we might never know.

Ron, of course, should explain his every decision to us. Save a lot of aggro!
 
  • Like
Reactions: fatletiss
Lff said:
Unless there is good reason for it which, short of Ron explaining to us very selection, we might never know.

Ron, of course, should explain his every decision to us. Save a lot of aggro!
Click to expand...
Save this one up for the next Fans' Forum, I suggest.

"Ron, you know when you played Yoshida at RB in the Sunderland game...?"
 
  • Like
Reactions: Saint Birdsnest, Le Saint and TheSecondStain
Tintin said:
Pointless thread. I cannot believe you actually made this.

1. Cedric is the best right back
2. Yoshida is better than Martina at right back (and left back)
3. There is 99% chance Cedric was being rested on Saturday. As I've shown in the match thread you don't really pick a right back based on height because they don't contest many aerial duels, sometimes they contest none.
4. Yoshida is a good centre back, he's ok back up for left and right back. But he should never be starting games over a fit to play Cedric. I would have thought Cedric was being rested as mentioned above.
5. If someone questions team selection it doesn't mean they hate the player that they wanted to be left out. I like Yoshida. He just shouldn't be playing over Cedric at right back, ever.
Click to expand...

I agreed with every single word except the last one. Horses for courses.
 
Tintin said:
Pointless thread. I cannot believe you actually made this.

1. Cedric is the best right back
2. Yoshida is better than Martina at right back (and left back)
3. There is 99% chance Cedric was being rested on Saturday. As I've shown in the match thread you don't really pick a right back based on height because they don't contest many aerial duels, sometimes they contest none.
4. Yoshida is a good centre back, he's ok back up for left and right back. But he should never be starting games over a fit to play Cedric. I would have thought Cedric was being rested as mentioned above.
5. If someone questions team selection it doesn't mean they hate the player that they wanted to be left out. I like Yoshida. He just shouldn't be playing over Cedric at right back, ever.
Click to expand...

Your argument about a RB not needing to win many aeriel duals from open play is sound, but you have to remember that Allardyce relies a lot on direct set pieces. Without Wanyama or Romeu on the pitch, it's perfectly understandable that Ron would want another big lad on the pitch to help the CB's out.
 
Tintin said:
Pointless thread. I cannot believe you actually made this.
.
Click to expand...

I think you should have posted this:

"Pointless thread and I haven't got the point as to why you posted it" because once again you haven't read properly here or other comments on the match thread. You've gone charging off again.

I think that we've done enough laughable circles now, so I'll leave it and just giggle in future. Just beware the grey areas. You'll find them somewhere between black and white ones.

I agree with your first two words.
 
Last edited:
Lff said:
Unless there is good reason for it which, short of Ron explaining to us very selection, we might never know.

Ron, of course, should explain his every decision to us. Save a lot of aggro!
Click to expand...

Unless Ron explains he only selected someone to create aggro on the forums :)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back