Transfer Rumours Transfer Rumours thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
In for Clyne again. He's a unit but not all that technically.

If montoya and Clyne cost the same I'd go for Clyne on the basis it annoys Southampton fans
 
  • Like
Reactions: astro
moreinjuredthanowen said:
To swap Coates for him is a good deal. We must see our youth defenders are not all that like lloyd Jones etc.

We will see. I'd say hey stay at Charlton next seadon once he signs it is a higher level than our u21s.
Click to expand...

Loan deal is imperative. <ok>

I like Clyne - I think he's a good all-round full back but I do question him defensively, but that's only because he's protected by a top class midfield so he hasn't been exposed as much to test his true ability.

I think £11m isn't too bad.

But .. I do think there are better full backs out there. Sakai of Stuttgart is a really classy fullback who can play on both flanks. However, De Scigilio is the one for me - potential world class and apparently Milan need to sell.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
Yup it's a case of if he does really well that help everton so if barca step back in they step back in.

It's an excellent price as he prove he can do it.

It means no lennon right?
Click to expand...

Not necessarily no.

Gerard will in effect replace Atsu. So the need for another wide man is still there, we'll play the long game with Levy though.
 
Nozzer said:
According to the German media, it expired yesterday.

Not a huge fan of Höwedes to be honest. He's ok, but not exceptional. Though he would improve our defence.
Click to expand...

Yep, that's a real shame.

He's not a spectacular defender but that's the beauty of his game. He does the basics to such a high level.

Versatile - can be play RCB, CM, RB, LB and DM, all at a high level.

Most importantly, he's a leader, captain, organiser and his style would compliment Sakho's perfectly.

For a player who has played a lot of top level football, in a good league, in the CL and at international level - think he was a starter at the world cup - all for £12m.

Really can't understand why there aren't more takers.
 
Jimmy Squarefoot said:
Yep, that's a real shame.

He's not a spectacular defender but that's the beauty of his game. He does the basics to such a high level.

Versatile - can be play RCB, CM, RB, LB and DM, all at a high level.

Most importantly, he's a leader, captain, organiser and his style would compliment Sakho's perfectly.

For a player who has played a lot of top level football, in a good league, in the CL and at international level - think he was a starter at the world cup - all for £12m.

Really can't understand why there aren't more takers.
Click to expand...

Not sure about him really. He's a good defender but he's a bit like Merts in that he's quite slow (imo). He would probably fit our system at Chelsea where we protect the slow defenders but have good competent defenders but if you want to play high i'm not sure he is your man
 
BobbyD said:
Not sure about him really. He's a good defender but he's a bit like Merts in that he's quite slow (imo). He would probably fit our system at Chelsea where we protect the slow defenders but have good competent defenders but if you want to play high i'm not sure he is your man
Click to expand...

Yeah, he's slow but not that slow. He would act as the sweeper, and cover Sakho who is naturally more aggressive.

He would be perfect as the CB in a back 3 also.
 
i am of the opinion we need to look at a more holistic view and i am not sure the club is doing that.

If you pack your team with forward options like say clyne whos a runner and moreno who's god knows what. then imagine kovacic as deep lying playmaker. henderson and milner at cm and coutinho at acm.. like...... in that case the two cbs would have to be mobile and able to screen.

lovern for example is best step up rather than retreating as he's that type of player and you need a smart man behind that sweeping up. can't play that behind the midfeild and full backs i've just listed!

i just don't know right now what format of team this purchasing thus far suggests.
 
Tobes said:
Not necessarily no.

Gerard will in effect replace Atsu. So the need for another wide man is still there, we'll play the long game with Levy though.
Click to expand...

ok... fair enough.

so your left side in then baines and this guy and you want lennon and coleman on the right.

is it then 4-2-3-1 or what? Mccarthy, barkley and barry in the centre? Lukaku up front?

will you sell stones or will it be stone and jagielka at theb back?
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
ok... fair enough.

so your left side in then baines and this guy and you want lennon and coleman on the right.

is it then 4-2-3-1 or what? Mccarthy, barkley and barry in the centre? Lukaku up front?

will you sell stones or will it be stone and jagielka at theb back?
Click to expand...
I think we'll manage to hold onto Stones for another season, but he progresses at the same rate next year, he'll be off next summer I'm afraid.
 
Tobes said:
I think we'll manage to hold onto Stones for another season, but he progresses at the same rate next year, he'll be off next summer I'm afraid.
Click to expand...

To a Championship team?

Don't worry, if Everton match their "progress" from last season too you'll be there before him <ok>
 
please god but we have to get the 16mil back or if they had installments at least get them written off.

we shoudl not pay any of his wages nor accept some stupid payment system
 
No one knows what Rodgers's style, identity, formation is so God only knows the type of players we need.

I'm just guessing that Rodgers wants versatile players who can a bit of everything...?
 
Jimmy Squarefoot said:
No one knows what Rodgers's style, identity, formation is so God only knows the type of players we need.

I'm just guessing that Rodgers wants versatile players who can a bit of everything...?
Click to expand...

Are you joking? Rodger's style and identity is one of the most obvious in the league, probably only second to Mourinho's "foul, bus, and spend" philosophy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back