Off Topic Afcftw Mafia Game

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not though. This is what I have been saying all along. The investigations were clearly nobbled based on the evidence. We got distracted by the MITO thing cos we were gullible and we were desperate for good news after night one.

I don't know what the score is but we need to apply more logic and strategy and less paranoia.

The people in the frame for Mafia in my book.

We know MITO was genuine so there is 2/3 chance that he is mafia.

We also know that the other mafia member would have wanted to play up the MITO info and keep us voting for him to take out an investigator. Valley survived a night longer than expected but we should be asking why the mafia didn't kill him? Are they out of kills after all?

I'll be honest - you are on my radar now after the way you were so adamant about MITO. I know the evidence pointed at him, but why were you so reluctant to look at the evidence on the other side of the coin that was out there. Most people were 50/50 or 60/40. You insisted you were 100% for MITO's guilt despite the evidence. Not saying you are guilty but it needs an explanation. You played much better than this last time if you are a townie after all. That makes me think maybe you are not town.

[HASHTAG]#justsaying[/HASHTAG]

Vote me then. I'll vote you eh? Lets get this over with<ok><laugh> Less hope <laugh>
 
Vote me then. I'll vote you eh? Lets get this over with<ok><laugh> Less hope <laugh>

I can't work out yet whether to vote for you or Sir Tennis. Sir Tennis is now 66% likely to be mafia. Your tunnel vision yesterday was either bad play or (much more likely) mafia work!

I could do with knowing what others think first.
 
How would we even know fella? How would we even find out? we're as blind about that as we will be about the next hidden task which bites us on the arse as there was no way of learning of it. Just randomly point the finger and hope by the end of the game you're on the team that wins. :p

Surely that's the point of Mafia, you need to be blind to a degree?

It would be a ****ing boring game if we had investigated Tobes and MITO on the first two nights, found them both to be Mafia and killed them both! The game is actually quite balanced now - Mafia seem to have shot their bolt early, cartel is now up and running and the serial killer is acting.

I wonder if there will be more witness events like when Valley saw MITO killing Biscan? That would be useful going forwards.
 
I can't work out yet whether to vote for you or Sir Tennis. Sir Tennis is now 66% likely to be mafia. Your tunnel vision yesterday was either bad play or (much more likely) mafia work!

I could do with knowing what others think first.

I don't think Funky is Mafia - he was all over Tobes and Tennis earlier, and is drawing a bit too much attention to himself imo.

Like I said above, I think we need to consider Tennisball, but also Mikey and Lucaaas based on Obi Wan's information.

Heck, Mikey giving money to someone is about the only lead on the cartel we have right now. And with the Mafia not killing last night they may have shot their bolt and be pretty powerless. So unless Mafia kill again I think the priority needs to be finding the cartel.

He's been quite for a while, so I'm going to vote Mikey and see what he says.
 
Funky dick

FFS guys....why the sudden jump on Tash instead of Tennis <grr>
This couldn't have gone worse.

Funky and Tennis surely now have to be mafia.
Tennis especially.

The fact that Funky then voted for Less than, despite him being the only one (well except me, but I didnt fully commit) to defend MITO, is nuts. Are you insane dude?
That is one funky move
 
Also BobbyD was pushing for Tash, infact he was the first to mention it.
So BobbyD has to be in the frame too.
 
Also a little concerned as to why MITO was begging the meth head to kill him. come on man!!
I would never beg someone to kill me in a mafia game.
 
Surely that's the point of Mafia, you need to be blind to a degree?

It would be a ****ing boring game if we had investigated Tobes and MITO on the first two nights, found them both to be Mafia and killed them both! The game is actually quite balanced now - Mafia seem to have shot their bolt early, cartel is now up and running and the serial killer is acting.

I wonder if there will be more witness events like when Valley saw MITO killing Biscan? That would be useful going forwards.

Maybe the mafia have mastered cloning and now we have to kill the remaining Mafia twice? Hmm I wonder, maybe the cartel has a secret option to recruit a cook from the towns people and can now get players hooked with the new meth on the market which allows them to manipulate people into making kills for them,who knows? The lack of structure means the possibilities are endless. It's boring to just speculate. Waste of my life as far as I'm concerned.I'm replaying the fallout 3 and new vegas in prep for fallout 4.Much better use of my free time. :p
 
Funky dick

FFS guys....why the sudden jump on Tash instead of Tennis <grr>
This couldn't have gone worse.

Funky and Tennis surely now have to be mafia.
Tennis especially.

The fact that Funky then voted for Less than, despite him being the only one (well except me, but I didnt fully commit) to defend MITO, is nuts. Are you insane dude?
That is one funky move

I voted for Tennis when Tash was pulling away in the votes and my vote remained on Tennis <laugh>
 
Maybe the mafia have mastered cloning and now we have to kill the remaining Mafia twice? Hmm I wonder, maybe the cartel has a secret option to recruit a cook from the towns people and can now get players hooked with the new meth on the market which allows them to manipulate people into making kills for them,who knows? The lack of structure means the possibilities are endless. It's boring to just speculate. Waste of my life as far as I'm concerned.I'm replaying the fallout 3 and new vegas in prep for fallout 4.Much better use of my free time. :p

I was undecided but that post has made up my mind. To me that is the post of someone who knows they are for the high jump and is pretending not to care in the hope we lose interest. if I am wrong then my defence is that you have played badly.

I vote Funky
 
  • Like
Reactions: Brian Storm
I was undecided but that post has made up my mind. To me that is the post of someone who knows they are for the high jump and is pretending not to care in the hope we lose interest. if I am wrong then my defence is that you have played badly.

Lol, so if you have played badly at least he has played badly too? ;)

Seriously though, we have to stop jumping on people just because of one or two posts. We are doing what we always do at this stage of the game - going for the people who post and ignoring the people who are quiet. We got lucky with one Mafia, but the other Mafia and cartel are probably just sitting back, not posting, and laughing at us killing each other.

Let's look at the evidence we have:

- From MITO's investigation we have a 67% chance that Tennisball is Mafia
- From Obi Wan's info we have a possibility that Mikey is Cartel
- From Obi Wan's info we have a possibility that Lucaaas is Mafia

Those are the three we need to be on imo. At least one of them is likely to be something dodgy, and we need to ensure somebody dodgy is lynched tonight.

I reckon we need to lynch one, get the meth head to kill another, and get the schizo to focus on the third. The schizo has a chance of killing and investigating, so that would be useful to us.

We've already investigated Tennisball and found he's Mafia and he hasn't claimed a role in defence. So we might as well either lynch him or get the meth head to kill him, as it's a strong lead. But I think we also need to consider taking out Mikey as well with the other option, as he is the only lead on the cartel. Then the schizo can go for Lucaaas and see what he turns up.
 
Bodanki because he seems to think that me voting for Tennis to bring the vote level from 7-5 to Tash means we're in the same team and not seeing that I voted for hope for a laugh because I'm losing interest.:emoticon-0136-giggl
 
Those are my two cents anyway.

One more thing, just remembered Tobes' last post before he was hung:

That'd be dead handy to a man on the gallows wouldn't it?

Or are you suggesting it'd somehow save me?

Either way, odd that you're going for the obtuse angle as opposed to the obvious strange abstention....

Anyway, good night sweet Prince.

That good night sweet Prince thing was directed at Gerrez. Possibly Tobes poking fun at him, knowing the Mafia were going to assassinate him that night? Not much use now, but maybe it means that Gerrez was the Mafia's second hit?

Night night all, and MITO, even though I didn't vote for you I will apologise. You drunken suicidal twat, you :)
 
Tonight's result was bad enough for the state of the game - but even worse than that all of my night-time companions have disappeared so now I have nobody to share my obsessive detective work with! <wah>

[HASHTAG]#bringbackgerrez[/HASHTAG] [HASHTAG]#mitowasinnocent[/HASHTAG] [HASHTAG]#quietwithoutbiscan[/HASHTAG]
 
Evening all. On train home catching up on the hundreds of posts.

One thing I will say is that whether or not you believe the info I get from AFC, some of you have jumped to conclusions about what they mean. OR are maybe even purposely trying to influence others to see them that way.

FOR INSTANCE. Mikey handing money over = meth head
Why not somebody paying for other 'services'?
Or TASH merrily tending to his garden ready for the town fayre = Carrel.
Why not just an innocent townie?


Read my actual posts again as they are copied directly from AFC.
Maybe some on here are trying to influence others to believe distorted 'facts' and dismiss the truth, by claiming these insights MUST mean X or Y.
Who has been doing that? Why?

Check the bit in bold! Am I still messing around?
Somd people on here are trying to manipulate! Who led the charge? And why?
 
Tonight's result was bad enough for the state of the game - but even worse than that all of my night-time companions have disappeared so now I have nobody to share my obsessive detective work with! <wah>

[HASHTAG]#bringbackgerrez[/HASHTAG] [HASHTAG]#mitowasinnocent[/HASHTAG] [HASHTAG]#quietwithoutbiscan[/HASHTAG]

#watchbreakingbadat11thenplayfallout3butturnitontobbc4inthemeantimeandlistentoclassicsoulatthebbcwhileyouwait
 
Check the bit in bold! Am I still messing around?
Somd people on here are trying to manipulate! Who led the charge? And why?

Ok - let's assume you have good info.

The vote for Tash was (in order)

BobbyD, Sir tennisball, Less Hope than Neville, Sebbs campaign manager, Mito, Swarbs

To be fair though, I wouldn't have particularly known what that bit in bold meant so on its own that is not enough in my eyes to hold that against Bobby on its own. We need to see who first made the link between that and Tash being Cartel.

If Tennis is mafia then everyone who switched (including myself) should be under suspicion. I still think his posts have been quite constructive and helpful though. However, now that we know for a fact that MITO was the real PI (like someone kept saying) then I would have no objection to voting for him. It would be a perfectly logical step - though voting for Funky based on his vociferous campaign against MITo and then his posts since the vote is also logical.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.