Redknapp talking some sense

[GoldhawkRoad]

Did he?! I have got the impression from here at least that the media loved Scholes.

Personally, I doubt very much it is only English players not being enthusiastic about playing friendlies for their countries. And I reckon players who shine at the World Cup are often ones who haven't particularly done so at their Clubs, and therefore have not played as much football as the ones that did shine, and so come to World Cups much fresher than players who have just finished long seasons in Europe.

My recollection is that Scholes got the best press after he left international football. He was fair game before that.

Found this past quote, which has some resonance now;

QUOTE
Paul Scholes has accused "very selfish" players of ruining England's international chances by putting their own careers ahead of the national team.

Scholes quit the England set-up in 2004 aged just 29 and revealed: "I just got fed up. When you are going to a team, you want to be part of a team and play well, but there are individuals who are after personal glory.

"When there is a simple pass of 10 yards, they might try and smack it 80 yards. They will do things to try and get themselves noticed."

He went on: "I always felt players at clubs like your Aston Villas try to use England as a way to get to a top club. Which, I don't know, you feel, 'Are they there for the right reason?' I think they are very selfish people.

"That is the biggest problem with English players – most of them are too selfish."

The former Manchester United midfielder, who retired at the end of last season, also denied that being played out of position had been behind his decision to make himself unavailable for Sven-Goran Eriksson's England squad.

"Playing on the left was never a problem. I played on the left for United I don't know how many times. I probably had my most successful time scoring goals in that position so it was never a problem."

Scholes insisted that teamwork was the key to success at international level. "If you look at the Spain team now, they all seem to play for each other," he said. "There isn't one of them who would try to do something in a game that doesn't suit the team and the way they play. And that could happen over here." UNQUOTE

 

[GoldhawkRoad]

This is a difficult one. If you were one of the players having their name quoted as a possibility, but were not guilty I doubt if you would be happy with this.

In those circumstances you would want the players named to clear yourself of blame. I'm not sure what Harry wished to achieve with his comments.

I think Harry was right to raise the issue, although in hindsight, he might have been wiser not to make it club specific ie should have left out references to Tottenham

 

[terryb]

I think Harry was right to raise the issue, although in hindsight, he might have been wiser not to make it club specific ie should have left out references to Tottenham

If he hadn't mentioned Tottenham, then his comments would have been unsupported hearsay.

I have no doubts that players have arranged for their clubs to pull them out of international friendlies & also for managers to persuade players that they don't want to play in these matches. I wonder if that happened at clubs Harry has been manager of? After all, this has happened for decades & how many friendlies did Ryan Giggs pull out of?

Is it not true to say that the only "new" information told by Harry was in his naming a specific club?