He still took a title off Pep's Barca, had a very good el classico record and reached 2 or 3 C.L semi finals (cant remember for sure), losing 1 on pens. Hardly a massive failure. Moyes would kill for that kind of record!
I'm not saying he had no success at Madrid, he did ok with the most expensive group of players in world football for his first couple of seasons, but he lost the dressing room in his 3rd season there, and was forced to quit or be sacked.
Mourinho is a maverick, and his approach works a lot of the time, but sometimes you need to be a little more tactful about how you do things. Mourinho was stupid enough to think he could bully the stalwarts of the Madrid dressing room into behaving in the same un sporting way that he does towards opponents, despite none of them being comfortable with it. It all backfired on him in his last season, with the players not wanting to play for him. Hence them finishing miles behind Barca in the league, and ending the season trophiless





