More league recontruction?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

EDGE.

Official POTY 2011, 2014, 2015, 2018 & 2023
Jun 8, 2011
38,268
47,131
113
93
Anne Marie’s Facebook
NO one likes admitting they are lost. We’ve all took a punt at a crossroads and ploughed on, only to have that growing gnawing feeling we’re going further in the wrong direction. When you start seeing cows rather than buildings it finally dawns on you there’s nothing else for it, you’ll need to go back. Turning round is sore for the ego – but a far better option than charging on into the wilderness. Let’s face it, this new-but-really-the-same Scottish football set-up is heading in the wrong direction. We need to go back. I know the idea of going back to reconstruction talks is about as appetising as a roll ‘n’ cowpat but whether we like it or not we have to take another bite. It’s just isn’t working. The Premiership is all over before Halloween. Talk about scary. We might as well hold the end-of-season dance this weekend. The title race is over. Not that it ever really started. Same in League One. Relegation is pretty much a done deal in the top division as well. Even Hearts fans know they have more important battles to win. All that’s left is heavily-weighted relegation play-offs and the scrap to see what teams get to start pre-season the earliest to prepare for a European tie in deepest darkest Belarus. Not great is it? And we can’t say it hasn’t gone unnoticed. The Christmas decorations will be getting dug out soon and we still don’t have a title sponsor. Big companies won’t touch our game with a bargepole. They’re not interested and it won’t be long before everyone else feels the same. The one positive from those endless meetings in the last 18 months is we have one body in charge. It’s as easy to change the format of our leagues now as it is to change the curtains at Hampden, so let’s just do it. Fans have constantly been told we can’t afford a bigger top flight but wait and see, it won’t be long before we’re told we can’t afford not to have one. It doesn’t take the gift of second sight to see what’s around the corner. Scottish football is heading back down the rabbit hole. Next season we are likely to have a First Division – or Championship in new money – that includes Rangers and Hearts. Dunfermline could be in there too as well as St Mirren or Kilmarnock. Chuck in Falkirk, Hamilton, Dundee and others and it’s going to look like a mirror image of the division above. There will be weekends when attendances in the second tier outnumber the first, which would be bonkers. Scottish football will never have a better chance to have a bash at a bigger top flight again. So let’s just go for it. Ram the top two divisions together and do the same with the bottom two. Have a top 20 and bottom 22. Can’t hurt to have a go. I’d bet there would be a queue of sponsors who put down the bargepoles and get all touchy-feely. The Old Firm would be back. We’d have derbies in Edinburgh, Dundee, Fife and the Highlands. A 38-game campaign and freedom to play without constant fear of the drop, no split and a proper spread of money. Tempting, isn’t it? Ah, but... of course there’s a but. The undoubted howls of protest. It’s a leg-up for Rangers and a bailout for Hearts, they’ll say. Well, they’ll need to grow up. Rangers have had two years on the naughty step. It’s time to let them back in. If we need to wallop Hearts further to appease the rest then we can take more points off them next year too if need be. But what would be the point? There’s been enough self-harm in Scotland. There’s time to mend wounds and patch up the product. We’re all in this together. We need to turn round before it’s too late to find our way back. http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/michael-gannon-scottish-football-never-2659293 Thoughts?
 
The writer intimates that next season, the crowds in the Championship will be higher than in the SPFL due to the fact, everyone wants to see the Rangers.

#watp
 
NO one likes admitting they are lost. We’ve all took a punt at a crossroads and ploughed on, only to have that growing gnawing feeling we’re going further in the wrong direction.

When you start seeing cows rather than buildings it finally dawns on you there’s nothing else for it, you’ll need to go back.

Turning round is sore for the ego – but a far better option than charging on into the wilderness.

Let’s face it, this new-but-really-the-same Scottish football set-up is heading in the wrong direction.

We need to go back.

I know the idea of going back to reconstruction talks is about as appetising as a roll ‘n’ cowpat but whether we like it or not we have to take another bite.

It’s just isn’t working.

The Premiership is all over before Halloween. Talk about scary. We might as well hold the
end-of-season dance this weekend.

The title race is over. Not that it ever really started. Same in League One. Relegation is pretty much a done deal in the top division as well. Even Hearts fans know they have more important battles to win.

All that’s left is heavily-weighted relegation play-offs and the scrap to see what teams get to start pre-season the earliest to prepare for a European tie in deepest darkest Belarus.

Not great is it? And we can’t say it hasn’t gone unnoticed. The Christmas decorations will be getting dug out soon and we still don’t have a title sponsor.

Big companies won’t touch our game with a bargepole. They’re not interested and it won’t be long before everyone else feels the same.

The one positive from those endless meetings in the last 18 months is we have one body in charge. It’s as easy to change the format of our leagues now as it is to change the curtains at Hampden, so let’s just do it.

Fans have constantly been told we can’t afford a bigger top flight but wait and see, it won’t be long before we’re told we can’t afford not to have one.

It doesn’t take the gift of second sight to see what’s around the corner. Scottish football is heading back down the rabbit hole. Next season we are likely to have a First Division – or Championship in new money – that includes Rangers and Hearts.

Dunfermline could be in there too as well as St Mirren or Kilmarnock.

Chuck in Falkirk, Hamilton, Dundee and others and it’s going to look like a mirror image of the division above.

There will be weekends when attendances in the second tier outnumber the first, which would be bonkers.

Scottish football will never have a better chance to have a bash at a bigger top flight again.

So let’s just go for it. Ram the top two divisions together and do the same with the bottom two. Have a top 20 and bottom 22.

Can’t hurt to have a go.

I’d bet there would be a queue of sponsors who put down the bargepoles and get all touchy-feely.

The Old Firm would be back. We’d have derbies in Edinburgh, Dundee, Fife and the Highlands. A 38-game campaign and freedom to play without constant fear of the drop, no split and a proper spread of money.

Tempting, isn’t it?

Ah, but... of course there’s a but.

The undoubted howls of protest. It’s a leg-up for Rangers and a bailout for Hearts, they’ll say.

Well, they’ll need to grow up. Rangers have had two years on the naughty step. It’s time to let them back in.

If we need to wallop Hearts further to appease the rest then we can take more points off them next year too if need be.

But what would be the point? There’s been enough self-harm in Scotland. There’s time to mend wounds and patch up the product. We’re all in this together.

We need to turn round before it’s too late to find our way back.

http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-news/michael-gannon-scottish-football-never-2659293

Thoughts?

You must log in or register to see images
 
Meh. No bovvered. Although it wid annoy Timmy, so, aye let's instruct the Establishment to make it so.

Two Leagues of 18...

2 doon/2 up with 3rd bottom v 3rd top play off

No splits
 
Grand ideas . Never gonne happen though . The Self preservation football league premiership junta couldny run a tap .

Past caring anyway tbh .
 
Grand ideas . Never gonne happen though . The Self preservation football league premiership junta couldny run a tap .

Past caring anyway tbh .

Yeah, I don't pay any attention to all this **** either any more. As long as there is a team turning out on a weekend to kick a baw around am happy.
 
I will kick your **** in. In your lengthy post you claim no big company would
touch our leagues with a barge pole . That is why the fans of nearly every club
in Scotland forced their boards to do the right thing and that was to not allow
The Rangers into their leagues . The ordinary decent fans of Scottish Football
knew that The Rangers were toxic, too closely associated with Rangers 1872.
No decent company neither big or small will have anything to do with a
league or Association that has The Rangers as a member .
Surely they couldn't be expected .
 
I'm against having bigger leagues. We had them before and they were crap. Too many meaningless mid-table matches. Regular games against part-timers. Just 2 Old Firm league games a year.

The author of the article claims that the current set up is screwed, but fails to argue convincingly what benefits bigger leagues would bring. His sole selling point seems to be that there will be derbies in Edinburgh, Dundee, Fife and the Highlands. They've hardly set the heather on fire in the past.

Simply shuffling the league format when you have the same ****ty teams will achieve nothing. A real radical solution would be to merge a load of clubs so that 4 or 5 teams had a realistic chance of winning the top division.
 
I will kick your **** in. In your lengthy post you claim no big company would
touch our leagues with a barge pole . That is why the fans of nearly every club
in Scotland forced their boards to do the right thing and that was to not allow
The Rangers into their leagues . The ordinary decent fans of Scottish Football
knew that The Rangers were toxic, too closely associated with Rangers 1872.
No decent company neither big or small will have anything to do with a
league or Association that has The Rangers as a member .
Surely they couldn't be expected .

Big sponsors aren't interested until Rangers are back in the top tier.

That's the truth so it is <ok>