We're very brutal about our players' abilities (or lack of in most cases), so I don't think we're "over the top". Coutinho has all the right attributes to become a really really good player for us
You all think Mignolet is the best GK in the Premiership.
You all think Johnson is the best ENglish RB around.
You all think Toure is still good.
You all think Agger is the best ball playing CB in the world.
You all think Enrqiue should be in the Spain squad.
You all think Lucas is the best DM in the Premiership.
You all think Gerrard is the greatest player of all time.
You all think Henderson was value for money.
You all think Coutinho is the future Messi.
You all think Sterling is the best English winger in the country.
You all think Suarez will pledge loyalty to the KOP and that he will YNWA.
You all think Brendan Rodgers is the future Mourinho.
You all think you have the best squad in the league.
You all think Liverpool will finish at least 2nd next season.
But yes, you're right, you are all very brutal about your players abilities, the most unbiased, knowledgeable and classiest fans in the country.