..... So if JR had played crap in the first 4 games and fumbled crosses, missed easy saves and we'd lost because of his ineptitude, that would be expected?
Actually I DO expect early season aberrations. What was the Fulham game but an early season team-wide aberration (and JR didn't in fact have a particularly good game that day)? But these aberrations are no reason to slag guys off or accuse them of being unfit or not preparing properly for the season, as some people have Grant Holt. As I said in my post, it usually takes until mid-October before teams and players get fully into the groove and the idea that every player can be expected to be in peak condition and on top of his game from the start is way off the mark.
..... just because in my opinion Grant Holt has had a poor start to the season, then I'm not having a go or rubbishing him as a person or calling for his head. I'm suggesting he should take his turn on the bench.
My third paragraph wasn't addressed to you redruth, but to people who HAVE been having a go at him and slagging him off. My own opinion is that while he certainly hasn't been at his best, he hasn't been particularly poor either. Indeed against QPR and in particular Spurs, I thought he played pretty well. But I also think that Morison did well when he came on, and like you, I would be in favour of starting Morison against Newcastle.
