Transfer Rumours Summer 2025 Transfer Thread…

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Allsop pinged balls up to the wingers against Stoke and other sides that directly led to goals though. The idea being by passing it short you invite the press and back yourself to pass through OR you create space over the top for the Delaps, Philogenes to run onto.

The amount of times he could have thrown the ball 20/30 yards to set up attack and didn’t bother, he’d simply roll it to our full backs who pass, it was infuriating.
 
To me there's a difference in criticism between fullbacks getting into the final third then passing back to the keeper which I agree is incredibly painful, and keepers passing it out to CBs who pass it back to the keeper to knock it out wide or up the pitch. The latter can be incredibly effective and we did it on a number of occasions last season to great effect, but the former is the boring football people have been critical of for years with us and stems from a lack of ability/movement from our full backs and forwards to link up or better run the lines and channels.

We have a goalkeeper that obviously isn’t great at it. So play a different way. The fact the goalkeeper can’t set a goal up maybe 3/4 times a season shouldn’t have a bearing on your style. If your goalkeepers average with his feet set your team up so he doesn’t have the ball 5o times a game.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Evington
We have a goalkeeper that obviously isn’t great at it. So play a different way. The fact the goalkeeper can’t set a goal up maybe 3/4 times a season shouldn’t have a bearing on your style. If your goalkeepers average with his feet set your team up so he doesn’t have the ball 5o times a game.

I don't think it's as simple as that without entirely changing your style of play. Which is why managers tend to find it easier to replace the keeper with one who is better with their feet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PLT
Looking at the fannying about at the back from the other angle, when there are two or three defenders and the keeper passing the ball about between themselves what are the forwards of the other team doing? If you take our game against Derby as an example Pedro and Palmer were chasing shadows, needlessly running back and forth never getting near the ball before the keeper hoofed the ball up field. Then the few occasions when we hoofed the ball up field they were too knackered to run and chase it.
 
I think the narrative that promoted teams like Southampton are failing due to playing out from the back is way over the top. They changed their manager and started playing off the big man up top and they've been even worse, yet still everywhere you look pundits are going on about Martin making them play out from the back. There was an Athletic article a few weeks ago about how they basically gave up on the season in the summer having accepted that their squad was nowhere near the level required. But no one wants to consider that when you can just blame it on a manager and rail against modern football.
 
I think the narrative that promoted teams like Southampton are failing due to playing out from the back is way over the top. They changed their manager and started playing off the big man up top and they've been even worse, yet still everywhere you look pundits are going on about Martin making them play out from the back. There was an Athletic article a few weeks ago about how they basically gave up on the season in the summer having accepted that their squad was nowhere near the level required. But no one wants to consider that when you can just blame it on a manager and rail against modern football.
Modern football to you though is just playing out from the back. Brentford have barely spent compared to some others who’ve come up and they’ve never been a team who relies on their centre backs and goalkeeper starting their attacks. Probably because their manager knows it’s not viable for a team without the quality to play through the ridiculous presses we see in the premier league now unlike managers like Martin, Kompany etc who force their players to do it and end up having terrible seasons.
 
I think the narrative that promoted teams like Southampton are failing due to playing out from the back is way over the top. They changed their manager and started playing off the big man up top and they've been even worse, yet still everywhere you look pundits are going on about Martin making them play out from the back. There was an Athletic article a few weeks ago about how they basically gave up on the season in the summer having accepted that their squad was nowhere near the level required. But no one wants to consider that when you can just blame it on a manager and rail against modern football.
Agree. For me that's the main point, and the basic fact, that their squads typically just aren't good enough over all. And it's getting a bigger and bigger bridge to somehow cross.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NewcastleTiger
I think the narrative that promoted teams like Southampton are failing due to playing out from the back is way over the top. They changed their manager and started playing off the big man up top and they've been even worse, yet still everywhere you look pundits are going on about Martin making them play out from the back. There was an Athletic article a few weeks ago about how they basically gave up on the season in the summer having accepted that their squad was nowhere near the level required. But no one wants to consider that when you can just blame it on a manager and rail against modern football.
I also agree with the quality of the squad idea. But they don’t even try recruit for a potentially more safe gritty side that could keep them up. More teams should be signing physical ball winners that can defend deep, quick wingers for counter attacks and defenders whose first job is defending the 6 yard box, not playing passes in it.
 
Who's going down? Luton, Plymouth, Cardiff. Who from them could do a job in the Championship...?
Alli, Aasgaard, Bundu, Callum Robinson...after them I start to struggle..

I always thought Aasgaard was from Scandinavia, but now discover he's a flaming Scouser.....Near enough I suppose.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NewcastleTiger
Who's going down? Luton, Plymouth, Cardiff. Who from them could do a job in the Championship...?
Alli, Aasgaard, Bundu, Callum Robinson...after them I start to struggle..

I always thought Aasgaard was from Scandinavia, but now discover he's a flaming Scouser.....Near enough I suppose.
I liked the look of Luton's Makosso when we played them, a young right sided centre back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: The B&S Fanclub
Modern football to you though is just playing out from the back. Brentford have barely spent compared to some others who’ve come up and they’ve never been a team who relies on their centre backs and goalkeeper starting their attacks. Probably because their manager knows it’s not viable for a team without the quality to play through the ridiculous presses we see in the premier league now unlike managers like Martin, Kompany etc who force their players to do it and end up having terrible seasons.

Martin was doomed from the off though. That squad was diabolically poor. Even if he had adapted I don’t think it would’ve made much difference.

Kompany on the other hand with Burnley probably could’ve made something out of it
 
Martin was doomed from the off though. That squad was diabolically poor. Even if he had adapted I don’t think it would’ve made much difference.

Kompany on the other hand with Burnley probably could’ve made something out of it

Kompany did make something out of it by sticking to his principles. Burnley didn't oh well...
 
  • Like
Reactions: NewcastleTiger
Who's going down? Luton, Plymouth, Cardiff. Who from them could do a job in the Championship...?
Alli, Aasgaard, Bundu, Callum Robinson...after them I start to struggle..

I always thought Aasgaard was from Scandinavia, but now discover he's a flaming Scouser.....Near enough I suppose.
Aasgaard's dad was probably off one of the scandi ships docked in Liverpool.
 
Who's going down? Luton, Plymouth, Cardiff. Who from them could do a job in the Championship...?
Alli, Aasgaard, Bundu, Callum Robinson...after them I start to struggle..

I always thought Aasgaard was from Scandinavia, but now discover he's a flaming Scouser.....Near enough I suppose.

Aasgaard is a Nowegian international (1 full cap, plus youth ones). I think he qualifies through his Dad.
 
Martin was doomed from the off though. That squad was diabolically poor. Even if he had adapted I don’t think it would’ve made much difference.

Kompany on the other hand with Burnley probably could’ve made something out of it
Yeah because they spend £20m on Taylor Harwood Bellis who wasn’t even one of the best in the championship last season. £20m on Cameron Archer…. Ramsdale was the only good signing they made
 
  • Like
Reactions: HCAFCHangout
We lack pace in forward areas as it is.

Yeh you will be hard pushed to find a lot of pace in an attacking mid. We need to address both power and pace but that will be out wide and in the striker area. He would be a good player to compete with Crooks and has pretty much always scored goals which is the other thing we lack.