Match Day Thread Hull City v Middlesbrough

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

City win?

  • City

  • Draw

  • Boro


Results are only viewable after voting.
Rewriting history to suit your ego fuelled opinion .

QPR & Stoke, we were bang average & lucky to win both. Burnley we managed 2 shots on target.

Zambrano didn’t start v Burnley or QPR. Millar was our 2nd worse rated player v Burnley, only Jones worse.

All 3 games we could easily have lost, probably should have & definitely would have if it wasn’t for Pandur.

We didn’t have a single “great game” under Walter. You’d struggle to highlight a great half. Maybe Stoke 2nd half at best.

You're right in a lot of what you said, but on the balance of fairness, yes pandur saved us in some games but there's also a fair few games that we should have picked up points if it wasn't for players missing sitters or gifting goals with awful individual errors. So it works both ways
 
Just think if Vaughan had decided to go into the corner to try and win a free kick, corner or throw in instead of trying to play kamara in we also may have hung on. Either way it just shows how weak our squad is, anyone know why drameh was subbed at ht?
I thought the same at the time as we were never going to score. It was about trying to hang on for the point.
 
Presumably that is because 80% disagree with your fawning assessment of the tactical genius that is Tim Walter?
There you go again. Read my post. I literally said his biggest issue was that he failed to adapt tactically when he realised the players he had been lumbered with were appalling. If he was a tactical genius he would be still in a job as he would have done what selles has done and resorted to long balls and using donkeys to run around a lot in the middle of the park.

The way we lose matches under Selles and the way we lost under Tim are similar. One moment of weakness, softness, a mistake. And that is down to the majority of the group being out of their depth.

It's a pointless conversation but many of the points we dropped under Tim were by single goals or sloppy draws. The exact same thing Selles is finding. We don't have the mental toughness in our team to see games through. It's a huge issue.
 
You're right in a lot of what you said, but on the balance of fairness, yes pandur saved us in some games but there's also a fair few games that we should have picked up points if it wasn't for players missing sitters or gifting goals with awful individual errors. So it works both ways

Agreed but in the three games mentioned as “great” we would have been at least 3 possibly 4 (Stoke) down if not for Pandur & that’s before we even had a sniff of a goal. We were far from great. The 3 wins in a week were just masking Walter’s ineptitude.

Some of our finishing has been abysmal, a lot not even forcing a save. We certainly look more steady under Selles & there’s signs of a little confidence sneaking back in to some players. Hopefully that will start to show in the “goals for” stats
 
There you go again. Read my post. I literally said his biggest issue was that he failed to adapt tactically when he realised the players he had been lumbered with were appalling. If he was a tactical genius he would be still in a job as he would have done what selles has done and resorted to long balls and using donkeys to run around a lot in the middle of the park.

The way we lose matches under Selles and the way we lost under Tim are similar. One moment of weakness, softness, a mistake. And that is down to the majority of the group being out of their depth.

It's a pointless conversation but many of the points we dropped under Tim were by single goals or sloppy draws. The exact same thing Selles is finding. We don't have the mental toughness in our team to see games through. It's a huge issue.

I think one interesting thing about the whole sorry season is that, although we languish in the relegation zone and are likely candidates for relegation we've only really been battered in one game. You might be correct about a lack of mental toughness but if so, the problem is exacerbated by a chronic inability to score goals. Right from the off its been obvious that not signing a proven, quality goalscorer or two was going to cripple us, a situation which only highlights the problems when you try to rely on the likes of Slater to fill the goalscoring gap. It's been said before but Pedro wouldn't be here if his legs hadn't gone, Burstow may get there but his season at Sunderland should have given a bigger warning than it appears to have done and Bedia was just a poor signing. Simply not at this standard.

We need to address this immediately. If we don't then any others signings are going to be in vain.
 
I think one interesting thing about the whole sorry season is that, although we languish in the relegation zone and are likely candidates for relegation we've only really been battered in one game. You might be correct about a lack of mental toughness but if so, the problem is exacerbated by a chronic inability to score goals. Right from the off its been obvious that not signing a proven, quality goalscorer or two was going to cripple us, a situation which only highlights the problems when you try to rely on the likes of Slater to fill the goalscoring gap. It's been said before but Pedro wouldn't be here if his legs hadn't gone, Burstow may get there but his season at Sunderland should have given a bigger warning than it appears to have done and Bedia was just a poor signing. Simply not at this standard.

We need to address this immediately. If we don't then any others signings are going to be in vain.
You're right. Even under the big bad wolf from Germany we hardly ever looked like we were unable to compete. Norwich is the one game I remember, he got that totally wrong and played into their hands. In the majority of the rest we were in the game and it was an error or dumb piece of play that cost us.

The fact its still happening now under Selles shows that we have a group of players who are soft. When Coyle is your captain you know you're in trouble.
 
Last edited:
Because Selles is currently relying on the same 11 for every game in the busiest part of the season. When we get to 1 game a week again we’ll be much better providing we aren’t already cut off from the rest of them by that point

We made three changes..
 
We made three changes..
You get my gist. It’s probably a 12
Pandur
Drameh/Giles
Maka
Jones
Coyle
Alzate
Puerta
Slater
Burstow
Pedro
Kamara/Longman

The middle 8 players are pretty much running themselves into the ground every game ATM for us to compete.
 
You're right. Even under the big bag wolf from Germany we hardly ever looked like we were unable to compete. Norwich is the one game I remember, he got that totally wrong and played into their hands. In the majority of the rest we were in the game and it was an error or dumb piece of play that cost us.

The fact its still happening now under Selles shows that we have a group of players who are soft. When Coyle is your captain you know you're in trouble.

Coyle was captain last season - don't remember us being in trouble then
 
Coyle was captain last season - don't remember us being in trouble then
I can't work out if you're being serious or not but presuming you are why don't you compare the squad like for like. The answer is in there. Its easy to be captain when your centre half is Jacob Greaves and you have the best attacking line up in the league.

Captains are supposed to be leaders of men. If you know anything about him he certainly ain't the man you want in front of you going into battle. Maybe his brother but not him. Nice lad to send on community projects but on field captain, not a chance.
 
You get my gist. It’s probably a 12
Pandur
Drameh/Giles
Maka
Jones
Coyle
Alzate
Puerta
Slater
Burstow
Pedro
Kamara/Longman

The middle 8 players are pretty much running themselves into the ground every game ATM for us to compete.

Slater looked absolutely knackered in the second half.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NewcastleTiger
I can't work out if you're being serious or not but presuming you are why don't you compare the squad like for like. The answer is in there. Its easy to be captain when your centre half is Jacob Greaves and you have the best attacking line up in the league.

Captains are supposed to be leaders of men. If you know anything about him he certainly ain't the man you want in front of you going into battle. Maybe he's brother but not him. Nice lad to send on community projects but on field captain, not a chance.

He's an absolutely amazing club captain and ambassador. But we need more on the pitch
 
I can't work out if you're being serious or not but presuming you are why don't you compare the squad like for like. The answer is in there. Its easy to be captain when your centre half is Jacob Greaves and you have the best attacking line up in the league.

Captains are supposed to be leaders of men. If you know anything about him he certainly ain't the man you want in front of you going into battle. Maybe he's brother but not him. Nice lad to send on community projects but on field captain, not a chance.
There’s only one Ian Ashbee…but I’d love us to find another.