Summer '24 transfer window

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
I think a prediction of 1st this season is probably a little over optimistic. The piece makes some very valid points. The main one being that all of the young players that we've signed are maturing and developing all the time. That's the funny thing about young players, if you give them game time and wait a little while, they become experienced players. They may not be good enough to finish first this season, or even in the playoffs (though I wouldn't bet against it) but with careful maintenance of the squad, selling players occasionally and adding some here and there, we'll have a team that has developed together and may well achieve their potential together, resulting in promotion in a year or two's time. Everyone is clamouring for 'experience' because you all want promotion immediately; success right now. Your choice I suppose. Personally, I think it would be more gratifying to watch our young players develop together and achieve promotion (and maybe more) when they reach the level to do so.
 
Sutton been on that space dust like.

We are still short in the striker position and you have to factor in RLB in all of this. First season in English football and he still doesn't have a team of high quality assistants around him.

Play offs would be am achievement, as it currently stands.
Getting into the play offs would be an hell of an achievement without an experienced striker, on the other hand if we get a good capable striker without any of our best players leaving, I'd expect top 6 at least.
 
Definitely been on the pipe

This squad is nowhere near. I’m sure a few will be along to tell me we reached the play-offs not so long ago (with a class above in Diallo playing most games) <laugh>
I mean, we did? And while Amad was a superb talent, he only really showed that in the second half of the season. And as that article suggests, the rest of our squad has 2 more years of experience now. The prediction is pretty wild, but it relies on something that is true. We've got a squad that has a hell of a lot of potential. That doesn't mean that they'll all come to fruition at the same point, but it's not outside the realms of possibility that we have the season next season that we were expected by virtually all smart commentators to have last season. Saying our squad is 'nowhere near' is something that is wick with recency bias and doesn't acknowledge the circumstances that led to the 16th place finish (which wasn't really all that much down to the quality of the playing squad).
 
I mean, we did? And while Amad was a superb talent, he only really showed that in the second half of the season. And as that article suggests, the rest of our squad has 2 more years of experience now. The prediction is pretty wild, but it relies on something that is true. We've got a squad that has a hell of a lot of potential. That doesn't mean that they'll all come to fruition at the same point, but it's not outside the realms of possibility that we have the season next season that we were expected by virtually all smart commentators to have last season. Saying our squad is 'nowhere near' is something that is wick with recency bias and doesn't acknowledge the circumstances that led to it (which wasn't really all that much down to the quality of the playing squad).
Okay, we’ll see this season then eh? Fingers crossed you’re correct. It’s more hope than expectation for me though. I think top 6 would be a cracking achievement, never mind automatic. This squad is nowhere near challenging for promotion - just my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gary Rowell world
I think a lot will depend on how Poveda performs
Let’s hope he Turns out to be a sess type player and hits the ground running as they say
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson
I think a lot will depend on how Poveda performs
Let’s hope he Turns out to be a sess type player and hits the ground running as they say
It all boils down to his fitness. He’s clearly got the talent, just doesn’t play anywhere near enough games.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson


1st – Sunderland

The common approach to judging teams ahead of a new season is looking at where they finished in the previous campaign as a benchmark, before making a prediction based upon improvements made through positive recruitment or a managerial appointment.

In this case, Sunderland finished 16th last year. Nevertheless, our prediction isn’t primarily based on signings nor, especially, the appointment of Régis Le Bris as head coach.

So, why do we have them as our Championship title-winners? The answer: the anticipation of rapid, seismic developmental growth.

Let us explain.

Under the ownership of Kyril Louis-Dreyfus, and the guidance of technical director Kristjaan Speakman, the Black Cats have adopted black kittens, employing an uncompromisingly youth-led recruitment and strategic policy.

This policy has helped them attain, and retain, the prodigious talents of Dan Neil, Jobe Bellingham, and Chris Rigg.

Neil has recently added a defensive reliability to the control and creativity he’s demonstrated since coming into the side as a teenager. Jobe is making a name for himself in his own right after snubbing Spurs, while Rigg plays with a fearlessness that suggests the 17-year-old could become anything he wants.

Furthermore, Sunderland also boast recent France U20s prospects in Pierre Ekwah and Adil Aouchiche, both now 22. The former brings an infectious energy while the latter possesses stunning vision. And that’s just in midfield!

The Wearsiders also possess two of the best wingers in the Championship in Patrick Roberts and Jack Clarke, if the latter were to stay. They equally boast one of the top right-backs in the tenacious Trai Hume, who also has the intelligence to invert into midfield.

The potential in this squad is through the roof, to the extent that it might only take a few subtle tweaks and shifts for them to go from being bottom half dwellers to one of the greatest second-tier sides of all time.

One of those tweaks is having a more settled environment under a good coach. After the chaos caused last season by Tony Mowbray’s dismissal and Michael Beale’s appointment, perhaps Le Bris can live up to his reputation in France as a respected developer of talent.

A second can be the young players, themselves, having had a couple of seasons of development under their belts, beginning to learn how to translate their glowing youth reputations into the senior game.

It’s common for elite youth talents to underwhelm in men’s football in their first season or two, but to then enjoy an enormous spike in their progress.

In Sunderland’s case, just three teenagers remain in their 27-man first-team squad. 17 are now into their early 20s, at an age where they can be relied on to consistently influence games at Championship level.

The third is the influence of Luke O’Nien, who’ll be their most important player: even if he doesn’t start a single game.

The 29-year-old never had the natural ability most of Sunderland’s squad possesses, but he’s overcome his technical limitations – and every other challenge that’s come his way – with the same relentless positivity, infectious exuberance and sheer determination.

Having signed as a midfielder in 2018, the utility man has also filled in at both full-back and wing-back spots, operated as a pressing #10. More recently, he has established himself at centre-back in the last two seasons.

In fact, O’Nien initially covered central defence in 2022-23 due to injuries, but he played so well there that he started 43 league games in that position last season: an extraordinary mentality.

So, if the former Wycombe man can rub off on natural centre-backs like key man Dan Ballard, who himself has now played 61 games for Sunderland, Nectarios Triantis and Jensen Seelt, as well as the rest of the squad, that will make a transformative difference.

If this young group adopt that same mentality as O’Nien, with greater ability, they’ll improve exponentially and hit some incredible heights.

The O’Nienification process will be helped, further, by the addition of midfielder Alan Browne, who plays every game with a unique urgency.

Browne is 29, while Simon Moore has signed at 34 to back-up an outstanding goalkeeper in Anthony Patterson. Evidently, Sunderland have been prepared to compromise their policy this summer to fine-tune the balance between youth and experience.

So, why do we have Sunderland as champions?

This is the highest-potential squad in the league by a country mile. The Black Cats have already had two years of exposure, with most players about to hit their peak. This, alongside a few experienced heads now to lean on, with perhaps a more stable coaching regime for guidance.

Add the right striker and it could be a perfect storm…



Whatever you think about this, our squad is, by my reckoning, worth at least £100 million more than when KLD first took over.
That’s success and for all our complaining there’s a lot of truths in the article.

To be honest, would you swap our squad for any other in the Championship?
The potential really is there and once we get the final one or two in I can see us in the Premier League within 3, possibly 2 years.
 
Okay, we’ll see this season then eh? Fingers crossed you’re correct. It’s more hope than expectation for me though. I think top 6 would be a cracking achievement, never mind automatic. This squad is nowhere near challenging for promotion - just my opinion.
When it's largely the same squad that got to the playoffs two years ago it's difficult to understand where the judgement of 'nowhere near' comes from with any kind of objectivity. That's not saying that we will (just in case you're itching to bookmark). Truth is that our logical ceiling is 5th place due to the parachute payments skewing things so wildly. However, there is absolutely no reason why this squad of players can't be in the pack that will challenge for the playoffs once we get our business done. Christ, we were in the theoretical playoff pack into the last quarter of last season despite the fact that we basically wrote the season off once we acknowledged the error with Beale. As ever, we'll need a bit of form and the ball to bounce our way on injuries a bit. But there's little you can draw from looking at the talent in the squad that points to us being miles out of the picture (once we get that striker done).
 
I mean, we did? And while Amad was a superb talent, he only really showed that in the second half of the season. And as that article suggests, the rest of our squad has 2 more years of experience now. The prediction is pretty wild, but it relies on something that is true. We've got a squad that has a hell of a lot of potential. That doesn't mean that they'll all come to fruition at the same point, but it's not outside the realms of possibility that we have the season next season that we were expected by virtually all smart commentators to have last season. Saying our squad is 'nowhere near' is something that is wick with recency bias and doesn't acknowledge the circumstances that led to the 16th place finish (which wasn't really all that much down to the quality of the playing squad).

It wasn’t just Amad though we had Simms or Stewart fit for half the season, Pritchard and Evans were both important too. We’ve gone from having a well oiled midfield to having chucking anyone in anywhere and hoping it worked last season. We made play offs with the worst ever point tally for 6th in the championship so you could argue it was down to a poor division and Preston not giving a ****e on the final day of the season. Barnsley and Huddersfield both made play offs a season or two before being relegated to L1. Doesn’t really mean much now. I agree we have a talented squad but it’s not all about having loads of potential in every position need the players to do the dirty work and knit it all together and we had none of that last season nor did we have a leader on the pitch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frazier the Lion
I think a prediction of 1st this season is probably a little over optimistic. The piece makes some very valid points. The main one being that all of the young players that we've signed are maturing and developing all the time. That's the funny thing about young players, if you give them game time and wait a little while, they become experienced players. They may not be good enough to finish first this season, or even in the playoffs (though I wouldn't bet against it) but with careful maintenance of the squad, selling players occasionally and adding some here and there, we'll have a team that has developed together and may well achieve their potential together, resulting in promotion in a year or two's time. Everyone is clamouring for 'experience' because you all want promotion immediately; success right now. Your choice I suppose. Personally, I think it would be more gratifying to watch our young players develop together and achieve promotion (and maybe more) when they reach the level to do so.
The whole issue with experience Vs a young talented team was always going to be an issue at some point with the “model “.

Last season was always going to be the point at which we would have the youngest squad in the transition from signing older players with experience of winning in the league we were playing, which was the way we did things until three years ago. We were always going to introduce and develop young kids into the first team and stand by them, to develop their game and value and the team. At times I think we might have taken it too far, Jobe was over used for his age, a 17/18 year old should have been given a rest at some point.

The issue with very young teams is, yes if they are very talented they can explode onto the scene and play some really attractive fear free football, but if it starts to go wrong, as it did from the appointment of Beale, they can also implode as they don’t have the experience to change things. Implode is what we did after the Leeds home game, when we were still on with a chance of automatic promotion we lost our shape and confidence and the kids didn’t have the guidance of experienced players on the pitch to pull things around.

Looking at the new season however we now have a young team, but one with a lot more experience than at this stage last season, we appear to be holding on to players we thought might go, I still think Clarke will go, but no one else who is integral to the development of the team. So rather than buy experience we are growing experience. We are still two years away from the point at which we will have grown enough in house experience, which is why a a couple of experienced heads of the sort we have been linked with or already brought in, Browne for example, are still needed this year.

The next stage with the “model”, will be improving the quality of recruitment at youth levels. Having a team as young as we do will block the progress of players in the under 21’s, as there will not be the space created by older players retiring or dropping down the leagues we had in League 1. So we will need to look at two areas, first we need to be looking at developing good links with a number of clubs both here and in Europe who have a good culture and would give the next crop of talented kids game time in adult football, the second is to be even more ambitious in the kids we sign, knowing that they must have the potential to be better than the players already in the first team.

If we do this then I think we have a bright future, the problem is we need to be patient and as football fans that is one thing we are not!
 
When it's largely the same squad that got to the playoffs two years ago it's difficult to understand where the judgement of 'nowhere near' comes from with any kind of objectivity. That's not saying that we will (just in case you're itching to bookmark). Truth is that our logical ceiling is 5th place due to the parachute payments skewing things so wildly. However, there is absolutely no reason why this squad of players can't be in the pack that will challenge for the playoffs once we get our business done. Christ, we were in the theoretical playoff pack into the last quarter of last season despite the fact that we basically wrote the season off once we acknowledged the error with Beale. As ever, we'll need a bit of form and the ball to bounce our way on injuries a bit. But there's little you can draw from looking at the talent in the squad that points to us being miles out of the picture (once we get that striker done).
I think this but also players who give us the ability to change the system and a coach who can spot things early and change it. We were too one dimensional last year, some of that was a lack of quality, ie we only had a plan A because it was our only threat. Le Bris seems to have spotted that, hopefully Poveda give us a right sided version and a better performing 10/AM and a couple of functional striker options give us more threat.
 
I think he’s been sniffing glue

It's not as mental as it seems IF we sign a striker or two and play a proper CDM (not sure if Browne can play there).

Defensively we were pretty solid despite how people feel about O'Nein, 5th best defensive record in the league last season speaks for itself. The defence really do need some cover if only to allow them to play out from the back more comfortably.

We really have absolutely massive potential and on our day can outplay anyone...outscoring is by far the biggest issue.
 
Whatever you think about this, our squad is, by my reckoning, worth at least £100 million more than when KLD first took over.
That’s success and for all our complaining there’s a lot of truths in the article.

To be honest, would you swap our squad for any other in the Championship?
The potential really is there and once we get the final one or two in I can see us in the Premier League within 3, possibly 2 years.

Honestly no, one or two positions but overall definitely not considering potential and how low the wage bill is also.

We have arguably some of the best players in the league in certain positions with Ballard, Neil, Patterson, Hume and Clarke. There also won't be a better teenage player than Rigg this season. We are in a very good position to kick on and I can't wait for the season to start.
 
To be honest, would you swap our squad for any other in the Championship?
Absolutely <laugh>

Leeds, Burnley and Sheff United have comfortably better squads at this level - just look at their forward options. That’s just off the top of my head too. To claim we have the best squad in the league is utter madness imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Young Ted


1st – Sunderland

The common approach to judging teams ahead of a new season is looking at where they finished in the previous campaign as a benchmark, before making a prediction based upon improvements made through positive recruitment or a managerial appointment.

In this case, Sunderland finished 16th last year. Nevertheless, our prediction isn’t primarily based on signings nor, especially, the appointment of Régis Le Bris as head coach.

So, why do we have them as our Championship title-winners? The answer: the anticipation of rapid, seismic developmental growth.

Let us explain.

Under the ownership of Kyril Louis-Dreyfus, and the guidance of technical director Kristjaan Speakman, the Black Cats have adopted black kittens, employing an uncompromisingly youth-led recruitment and strategic policy.

This policy has helped them attain, and retain, the prodigious talents of Dan Neil, Jobe Bellingham, and Chris Rigg.

Neil has recently added a defensive reliability to the control and creativity he’s demonstrated since coming into the side as a teenager. Jobe is making a name for himself in his own right after snubbing Spurs, while Rigg plays with a fearlessness that suggests the 17-year-old could become anything he wants.

Furthermore, Sunderland also boast recent France U20s prospects in Pierre Ekwah and Adil Aouchiche, both now 22. The former brings an infectious energy while the latter possesses stunning vision. And that’s just in midfield!

The Wearsiders also possess two of the best wingers in the Championship in Patrick Roberts and Jack Clarke, if the latter were to stay. They equally boast one of the top right-backs in the tenacious Trai Hume, who also has the intelligence to invert into midfield.

The potential in this squad is through the roof, to the extent that it might only take a few subtle tweaks and shifts for them to go from being bottom half dwellers to one of the greatest second-tier sides of all time.

One of those tweaks is having a more settled environment under a good coach. After the chaos caused last season by Tony Mowbray’s dismissal and Michael Beale’s appointment, perhaps Le Bris can live up to his reputation in France as a respected developer of talent.

A second can be the young players, themselves, having had a couple of seasons of development under their belts, beginning to learn how to translate their glowing youth reputations into the senior game.

It’s common for elite youth talents to underwhelm in men’s football in their first season or two, but to then enjoy an enormous spike in their progress.

In Sunderland’s case, just three teenagers remain in their 27-man first-team squad. 17 are now into their early 20s, at an age where they can be relied on to consistently influence games at Championship level.

The third is the influence of Luke O’Nien, who’ll be their most important player: even if he doesn’t start a single game.

The 29-year-old never had the natural ability most of Sunderland’s squad possesses, but he’s overcome his technical limitations – and every other challenge that’s come his way – with the same relentless positivity, infectious exuberance and sheer determination.

Having signed as a midfielder in 2018, the utility man has also filled in at both full-back and wing-back spots, operated as a pressing #10. More recently, he has established himself at centre-back in the last two seasons.

In fact, O’Nien initially covered central defence in 2022-23 due to injuries, but he played so well there that he started 43 league games in that position last season: an extraordinary mentality.

So, if the former Wycombe man can rub off on natural centre-backs like key man Dan Ballard, who himself has now played 61 games for Sunderland, Nectarios Triantis and Jensen Seelt, as well as the rest of the squad, that will make a transformative difference.

If this young group adopt that same mentality as O’Nien, with greater ability, they’ll improve exponentially and hit some incredible heights.

The O’Nienification process will be helped, further, by the addition of midfielder Alan Browne, who plays every game with a unique urgency.

Browne is 29, while Simon Moore has signed at 34 to back-up an outstanding goalkeeper in Anthony Patterson. Evidently, Sunderland have been prepared to compromise their policy this summer to fine-tune the balance between youth and experience.

So, why do we have Sunderland as champions?

This is the highest-potential squad in the league by a country mile. The Black Cats have already had two years of exposure, with most players about to hit their peak. This, alongside a few experienced heads now to lean on, with perhaps a more stable coaching regime for guidance.

Add the right striker and it could be a perfect storm…
That’s very optimistic.

We’d need a top quality striker, CDM & CB to even be in with a shout of finishing top imo. Not to mention we’d have to have them avoid injuries for 95% of the campaign.

I’d be happy with top 6 personally.
 
That’s very optimistic.

We’d need a top quality striker, CDM & CB to even be in with a shout of finishing top imo. Not to mention we’d have to have them avoid injuries for 95% of the campaign.

I’d be happy with top 6 personally.
I’d be over the moon with play-offs. Snap your hand off.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SAFC Wilks
It's not as mental as it seems IF we sign a striker or two and play a proper CDM (not sure if Browne can play there).

Defensively we were pretty solid despite how people feel about O'Nein, 5th best defensive record in the league last season speaks for itself. The defence really do need some cover if only to allow them to play out from the back more comfortably.

We really have absolutely massive potential and on our day can outplay anyone...outscoring is by far the biggest issue.

Apart from a couple of games last season, Boro (10 men) Jimmy Hill FC and I think Plymouth away we were only 1 goal away from picking up a point or all 3 with a goal either way. It's not a huge gap to improve. However a goalscorer is an absolute necessity.