Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
Call me old-fashioned but I don’t really care what Hungarian politicians are up to compared to what’s happening here. Whataboutery and all that.

Surely the human rights abuses in Hungary are highly relevant to you as an EU supporter? You begin to sound like an old British nationalist now!
 
Im not a mathematician of course......but I’d say overall we put a lot more in than we got out, even if you include the enormous net benefits you mention.
Again that’s just my opinion and I stand to be corrected

The EU is the biggest proponent of socialism in the world. And that's been seen clearly over the last days, when there were huge, acrimonious fights between the profitable and frugal northern countries and the economic basket cases in the south, Greece, Spain, Italy and Portugal, the latter looking for huge financial bail outs.(Macron apparently accused the Dutch prime minister of acting like a British prime minister by protecting his nation's interests!)

The solution they've found where by grants and loans all go through Brussels, propelling the EU towards becoming a federal state, does not look sustainable. It has to get through national parliaments, and if I was a citizen of the Netherlands or Denmark for instance, I'd feel like a sucker. We could be seeing the break up of the EU as we know it, over the next two or three years. Thank God we're out.
 
Surely the human rights abuses in Hungary are highly relevant to you as an EU supporter? You begin to sound like an old British nationalist now!

No more so than anywhere else though I was referring to the issue of corruption. We’re out the EU after all. Not our problem especially when we’ve got so much on our own doorstep.
 
An interesting view. Stainesy believes that the EU stands in the way of Socialism.

On a macro level, I think socialism is at the heart of the EU. It takes from the richer countries, and gives to the poorer. (And then gives back to France by way of CAP and Germany by way of exports!).

But it's also true, there is corruption between big Brussels politics and big business at a lower level.

The question is, for how long will voters in the north be content to subsidise heavily countries in the south? The one thing that the Coronavirus established, is that in times of trouble, countries look to their national governments not to Brussels. And those, like Italy, that were in deep trouble, could expect no help from Brussels when they needed it
 
I can’t correct you although I’d argue the post doesn’t make sense.

Only the future will prove whether the likes of Michael Gove and Jacob Rees-Mogg really had our best interests at heart.

I await your argument that the post doesn’t make sense.....but somehow I expect I’ll see the usual 1 liners you put up.

Ready.....Steady.......GO !!
 
The EU is the biggest proponent of socialism in the world. And that's been seen clearly over the last days, when there were huge, acrimonious fights between the profitable and frugal northern countries and the economic basket cases in the south, Greece, Spain, Italy and Portugal, the latter looking for huge financial bail outs.(Macron apparently accused the Dutch prime minister of acting like a British prime minister by protecting his nation's interests!)

The solution they've found where by grants and loans all go through Brussels, propelling the EU towards becoming a federal state, does not look sustainable. It has to get through national parliaments, and if I was a citizen of the Netherlands or Denmark for instance, I'd feel like a sucker. We could be seeing the break up of the EU as we know it, over the next two or three years. Thank God we're out.

It’s not about socialism or nationalism in my view.....more about who profits from the organisation that is the EU.
To me it seems those at the top of the EU (and the many hangers on) are making vast salaries and have massive pension pots, being paid for by the taxes of the people of Europe.
Maybe I’m being simplistic and I will obviously be corrected by those with far more political knowledge like Bracknell, however I’m looking at it from my view which after the last few months has become apolitical.....they are all a bunch of ****s, as are most human beings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
I await your argument that the post doesn’t make sense.....but somehow I expect I’ll see the usual 1 liners you put up.

Ready.....Steady.......GO !!

I meant I get what you meant by the sentence so it doesn’t really matter but if there are “enormous net benefits” then by definition we’re getting good value for money.

But as you asked for a one liner, I hope a US trade deal and gradual erosion of the NHS at least means the ambulances of the future are Cadillacs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
I meant I get what you meant by the sentence so it doesn’t really matter but if there are “enormous net benefits” then by definition we’re getting good value for money.

But as you asked for a one liner, I hope a US trade deal and gradual erosion of the NHS at least means the ambulances of the future are Cadillacs.

Sorry Brackers, I misunderstood your post....my apologies. I would still argue the fact that those ‘net benefits’ are not just beneficial to one side.
Have you seen the Ambulances we are getting ? Hopefully I’ll be retired by then as pushing a 20 stone patient up a ramp ain’t gonna do my back any good.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
Sorry Brackers, I misunderstood your post....my apologies. I would still argue the fact that those ‘net benefits’ are not just beneficial to one side.
Have you seen the Ambulances we are getting ? Hopefully I’ll be retired by then as pushing a 20 stone patient up a ramp ain’t gonna do my back any good.

No I’ll wait to experience them first hand. It’ll probably be a horse and cart by then.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Staines R's
So Russia poses an immediate and urgent threat yet good old Boris has hidden this report for nearly a year! His reply in parliment....yes but you support this, you dont support that, sandals on Bournemouth beach huff puff blah! We have a ****ing joke of a PM who truly doesnt give a flying **** about this country. Makes me sick.
 
Without wishing to sound like our resident conspiracy theorist, suffice to say that the politicians - Select Committee or not - are not privy to an awful lot of what those "behind the scenes" are actually doing. There has been significantly more happening to counter specific threats than will ever be made public

I can't be more specific myself than that, but suffice to say the media and MPs aren't fully in the picture
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
So Russia poses an immediate and urgent threat yet good old Boris has hidden this report for nearly a year! His reply in parliment....yes but you support this, you dont support that, sandals on Bournemouth beach huff puff blah! We have a ****ing joke of a PM who truly doesnt give a flying **** about this country. Makes me sick.

Magic grandpa would have come down hard on them Russians, eh, Bob? :emoticon-0100-smile
 
Without wishing to sound like our resident conspiracy theorist, suffice to say that the politicians - Select Committee or not - are not privy to an awful lot of what those "behind the scenes" are actually doing. There has been significantly more happening to counter specific threats than will ever be made public

I can't be more specific myself than that, but suffice to say the media and MPs aren't fully in the picture

Intriguing, but begs the question 'Why should you be privy to this information, but not the Select Committee?'

Are you saying that there was a lot done 'behind the scenes' in relation to investigating Russian interference in the EU referendum?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: sb_73
Would he? What he would or wouldnt have done is totally irrelevant. What our PM does or who he takes money from is.

Wonder if social media had been around at the time if lefties would have mentioned Michael Howard half as much as these gammonflakes bang on about Corbyn.
 
Wonder if social media had been around at the time if lefties would have mentioned Michael Howard half as much as these gammonflakes bang on about Corbyn.
People still use Corbyn as their 'get out' even now! What if corbyn, but corbyn blah blah. Why people give a **** about some back bencher over the actual incompetence of our puppet PM is beyond me.