Following on from the Arca thread..

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Teessidemackem

Teessidemackem

Well-Known Member
Jan 27, 2011
19,850
25,806
113
Name the best SAFC team from your life time,as in best players youve seen in our Red and White stripes.
Its harder than you think.

Mine is........

.....................Sorenson................
Bardsley.....Bould.....Thome......Gray.
Sess......Kirchoff...Schwartz..Arca
..............Quinn....Phillips.........

Subs- Norman, Defoe, Bent, Hutchinson, Steed, Ball, Gabbiadini.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson, Gil T Azell, The Norton Cat and 1 other person
Teesdarlomakem said:
Name the best SAFC team from your life time,as in best players youve seen in our Red and White stripes.
Its harder than you think.

Mine is........

.....................Sorenson................
Bardsley.....Bould.....Thome......Gray.
Sess......Kirchoff...Schwartz..Arca
..............Quinn....Phillips.........

Subs- Poom, Defoe, Bent, Hutchinson, Steed, Ball, Gabbiadini.
Click to expand...

Im going for Ball because of how much of a fantastic captain he was for us, I also needed cover at CB.
I hope i havent missed anybody out, im on my 4th beer so my memory is abit vague.
 
Pickford

Kubicki. Bould Ball. Gray

Malbranque Henderson Schwartz Sess

Phillips. Defoe

Bench. Johnstone, Reyna, Hutchinson, craddock, sorenson, quinn, goodman

Alonso and mvilla would of had a shout if I was including loanees.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smithy in nl and Teessidemackem
Nonsense Potter said:
Pickford

Kubicki. Bould Ball. Gray

Malbranque Henderson Schwartz Sess

Phillips. Defoe

Bench. Johnstone, Reyna, Hutchinson, craddock, sorenson, quinn, goodman

Alonso and mvilla would of had a shout if I was including loanees.
Click to expand...

No Quinn? Thats a big call mate, he was arguably the reason Phillips was so good. Respect to you for being honest though mate, thats what we want to see on here.
 
Teesdarlomakem said:
No Quinn? Thats a big call mate, he was arguably the reason Phillips was so good. Respect to you for being honest though mate, thats what we want to see on here.
Click to expand...

Aye, I agree with that. It was a coin toss between quinn and defoe to be honest. Both legends in their own right. B£nt was mint too but I couldn't bring myself to even put him on the bench for reasons. Likewise Lee Cl**k.

We've had some top quality players through the doors over last 25 years. Makes the current situation even harder to swallow.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Teessidemackem
Nonsense Potter said:
Aye, I agree with that. It was a coin toss between quinn and defoe to be honest. Both legends in their own right. B£nt was mint too but I couldn't bring myself to even put him on the bench for reasons. Likewise Lee Cl**k.

We've had some top quality players through the doors over last 25 years. Makes the current situation even harder to swallow.
Click to expand...

It does mate. Chris Waddle even crossed my mind at one point.
A club of our stature should never be going into year 3 in the 3rd division. Its humiliating and soul destroying
 
  • Like
Reactions: clockstander and Nonsense Potter
For me the first decisions were partnerships
(where the sum is greater than the parts). Up front is the easiest Quinny & SKP.
At back I’ve gone for Watson & Pitt. The rest are just personal choices and on another day they could be swapped out according to my mood.
Oh snd one vital position also sways the other choices - that is captain. This has to be Bally for me.
So :-
Monty.
Ces Irwin. Pitt. Watson. M. Gray
Bally.
Hutch Johnson
Sess​
Quinn. Phillps​
subs <doh> can I have 15 please.
 
Teesdarlomakem said:
No Quinn? Thats a big call mate, he was arguably the reason Phillips was so good. Respect to you for being honest though mate, thats what we want to see on here.
Click to expand...

I picked Phillips and Defoe for my team on (I think) your 5 a side thread but I'm not sure how well it would work on a full size pitch. Not many teams play two small strikers but I could see it working if the chemistry was there.
 
Nonsense Potter said:
Aye, I agree with that. It was a coin toss between quinn and defoe to be honest. Both legends in their own right. B£nt was mint too but I couldn't bring myself to even put him on the bench for reasons. Likewise Lee Cl**k.

We've had some top quality players through the doors over last 25 years. Makes the current situation even harder to swallow.
Click to expand...
You are lucky mate I can’t even swallow.
 
Whilst I agree with teams from the different generations surely a subs place at least would need to be found for Summerbee or Johnstone during the Quinn n Phillips reign. Not saying they were the best players but must have contributed at least 75% in assists for their goals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RTB and DH4
Here's mine . . . . that's a solid back five, a strong central midfield with guile either side of them, and the most potent front two that we've ever had :emoticon-0105-wink:



..................Pickford.............
Makin.......Craddock.......Watson........Bolton
Summerbee...Ball...Hutchinson.....Tueart
................Quinn....Phillips............…

Subs: Tommy, Mickey Gray, Thome, Hoolioooo, Rowell, Magic, Defoe
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson, Gil T Azell and Nads
Considering that the OP asked for the 'best SAFC team in my lifetime, it has to be the '64 promotion team - not the best players in each position BUT I think they would have (collectively) wiped the floor with any SAFC team since (including the '73 side).

Montgomery.

Irwin, Ashurst.

Harvey, Hurley, McNab.

Usher, Herd, Sharkey, Crossan, Mulhall
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robertson
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back