Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
I'm unsure as to what reasons Ken Clarke has given to not voting Tory. Didnt he vote for the withdrawal agreement? I may be mistaken. I've seriously never heard of the other guy. What he says are again just opinions and slogans. Why will he wreck the economy? Why is he not fit to be leader? A bit of substance wouldnt go a miss.
I read Austin was so well respected on the Labour benches his colleagues were yelling at him to go and join the other side, recently I think. He's a K***
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobmid
No, Clarke voted for the Benn Act and lost the Tory whip with 20 others.

I think you will be hearing more from Ian Austin in due course. I suspect the media will be all over him like a rash.
But didn't he vote for May's withdrawal agreement 3 f***** times?
 
Don't see it myself. Clumsy language, yes. But what he was focusing on was what should have been done with the benefit of hindsight. Get out of a burning building at the earliest opportunity. Again, with hindsight, the advice the Fire Service gave could not have been more wrong

Sorry goldy im going to have to disagree with this. Its appalling, most people listen to the experts (and expect it to be correct). Rees mogg is a twat for coming out with this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobmid
Sorry goldy im going to have to disagree with this. Its appalling, most people listen to the experts (and expect it to be correct). Rees mogg is a twat for coming out with this.

No problem, Bobby. I've listened to the excerpt again. He says the problem was the cladding and the stay put policy. If you ignore what you're told and leave, you are so much safer. It's common sense etc.

I still think he is looking ahead to future problems. He is certainly not criticising those that stayed and died, but his language was clumsy. But you can tell, listening to him, he is agonising over the whole issue. I thought the Bridgen quote was worse, it was arrogant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BobbyD
It's made entirely with the benefit of hindsight, Nines. It's not a criticism of the Fire Service. They do not have second sight. But knowing what we do now, an evacuation of the building at the earliest moment must surely have been the best option.

Who knows all the heat blowing up the stairs, the carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide and anyone else who will faint. The best policy might be to stay put provided your building isnt isnt surrounded by cladding that helps the building go up in flames.

Wasnt there that fire in japan where the advice and action was to go onto the roof?
 
I mean to say that’s not what’s driven his slightly bizarre outburst. If you really want to denounce racism you don’t tell people to back Boris Johnson. This is a personal feud with Corbyn.

Don't disagree about the feud. But having listened to him, I'd say what was at the bottom of the feud was Austin's sense of Corbyn's negative attitude towards Jewish people. If you know of something else, be interested to hear. But I think we can leave out the stuff about him being mentally impaired
 
No problem, Bobby. I've listened to the excerpt again. He says the problem was the cladding and the stay put policy. If you ignore what you're told and leave, you are so much safer. It's common sense etc.

I still think he is looking ahead to future problems. He is certainly not criticising those that stayed and died, but his language was clumsy. But you can tell, listening to him, he is agonising over the whole issue. I thought the Bridgen quote was worse, it was arrogant.

Tbf i have only seen the headlines so i will get back with an answer.

Just heard the excerpt, i don't think he's malicious about it but i disagree about the common sense aspect of it.

Definitely the criticism has been over the top but i think comparing to leaving a fire in a house to a giant block apartments is different.

I agree with you now though people i think rees Mogg is being unfairly maligned on this occasion
 
Who knows all the heat blowing up the stairs, the carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide and anyone else who will faint. The best policy might be to stay put provided your building isnt isnt surrounded by cladding that helps the building go up in flames.

Wasnt there that fire in japan where the advice and action was to go onto the roof?

There is a period before the fire takes hold and is localised, when people can evacuate.

Say put can have problems generally. Look at 9/11.

If you can get out of the building, get out
 
Yes, I believe he did, perhaps because May was a Remainer. But Boris is too close to the ERG, and Ken would rather walk away and revoke Article 50. It's not incredibly newsworthy.

He is the"Father of the House"! Grandad more likely. Unlike Austin he is well respected. And always struck me as a very loyal Tory. He's been Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer, Home Secretary,and now he's no longer going to vote for his own party! That says a lot. Far more newsworthy than someone who has a career at odds with his fellow MP's. He never could play football either.
 
Last edited:
He is the"Father of the House"! Grandad more likely. Unlike Austin he is well respected. And always struck me as a very loyal Tory. He's been Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer, Home Secretary,and now he's no longer going to vote for his own party! That says a lot. Far more newsworthy than someone who has a career at odds with his fellow MP's. He never could play football either.
Exactly the point Abbott was making! Biased media coverage!
 
He is the"Father of the House"! Grandad more likely. Unlike Austin he is well respected. And always struck me as a very loyal Tory. He's been Tory Chancellor of the Exchequer, Home Secretary,and now he's no longer going to vote for his own party! That says a lot. Far more newsworthy than someone who has a career at odds with his fellow MP's. He never could play football either.

Clarke has been a Europhile for years and years. He is a leading Remainer. Everyone knew he was struggling. And finally he admits he want to revoke Article 50 and Remain. He's retiring and won't vote for Boris. If this was put on the front page of a newspaper, it wouldn't sell.

But Austin was a Labour MP until earlier this year, who has been working class all his life, and is saying that Corbyn is so unfit to be leader, that Austin has no alternative but to recommend to Labour voters that they vote...for Boris Johnson! That is huge, and the feeling is, he won't be the last...

Find me a Tory leaving MP that recommends to Tory voters they give their vote to Jeremy Corbyn!
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr and BobbyD
Clarke has been a Europhile for years and years. He is a leading Remainer. Everyone knew he was struggling. And finally he admits he want to revoke Article 50 and Remain. He's retiring and won't vote for Boris. If this was put on the front page of a newspaper, it wouldn't sell.

But Austin was a Labour MP until earlier this year, who has been working class all his life, and is saying that Corbyn is so unfit to be leader, that Austin has no alternative but to recommend to Labour voters that they vote...for Boris Johnson! That is huge, and the feeling is, he won't be the last...

Find me a Tory leaving MP that recommends to Tory voters they give their vote to Jeremy Corbyn!
I'm not sure if clarke ever voted for article 50 in the first place to be fair to him. As for not being on the front of the papers, that is exactly the point Abbott is making ffs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QPR Oslo
Clarke has been a Europhile for years and years. He is a leading Remainer. Everyone knew he was struggling. And finally he admits he want to revoke Article 50 and Remain. He's retiring and won't vote for Boris. If this was put on the front page of a newspaper, it wouldn't sell.

But Austin was a Labour MP until earlier this year, who has been working class all his life, and is saying that Corbyn is so unfit to be leader, that Austin has no alternative but to recommend to Labour voters that they vote...for Boris Johnson! That is huge, and the feeling is, he won't be the last...

Find me a Tory leaving MP that recommends to Tory voters they give their vote to Jeremy Corbyn!

There are plenty telling people to vote Lib Dem. Most have joined them.