Last time I went a few weeks ago we went in a little Italian cafe bar just over the bridge going towards the Abbey.I would recommend having something to eat there, even if it is only some cake. Always rated Magpie more than Trenchers but a friend of mine, who sadly passed away earlier this year, always said the best fish and chips in Whitby are at Hadley's. I think he could be right.
It's just on the right and they do fish n chips with tea and bread and butter for $8 during the day .
Quite nice actually