Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
People are turning away from Labour in their droves. Who would vote for Corbyn and that idiot Abbott?
Pure lefty fantasy.

I did Ellers, and many from the far-left like me did vote for him because we see it as a refreshing step forward in politics and a move away from the Blairite labour that betrayed the working class.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stroller
I did Ellers, and many from the far-left like me did vote for him because we see it as a refreshing step forward in politics and a move away from the Blairite labour that betrayed the working class.
When you hear of many old-time Labour supporters leaving you have to ask why?
Agree Blair was a lying treacherous muppet but Corbyn is out of date with the modern World. He belongs back in the 70's with Foot and CND. Most importantly he has a big problem with Jews and he will lose many old-time Labour supporters from the Jewish community. Throw Abbott into the mix and you get an unelectable party.
We live in weird political times.
 
When you hear of many old-time Labour supporters leaving you have to ask why?
Agree Blair was a lying treacherous muppet but Corbyn is out of date with the modern World. He belongs back in the 70's with Foot and CND. Most importantly he has a big problem with Jews and he will lose many old-time Labour supporters from the Jewish community. Throw Abbott into the mix and you get an unelectable party.
We live in weird political times.

You’re coming at it from one side Ellers. I would say Corbyn has won back a lot of Labour voters who decided Labours move to the ‘right’, with the likes of the war-criminal Bliar was a step too far and either decided to not vote at all or to vote for more marginal Left leaning parties.

You right-wing racist Tory scumbags wouldn’t understand anyway ;)

(I emphasise the last sentence was a joke :) )
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELLERS and Stroller
Agree with every word of that.
As you say, our Government have been inept since day one, although they have been hampered by rabid remainers within the civil service imo.
This led to Davis being seriously undermined at every turn.
A strong leader would have quashed this, but May (a strong remainer) has been about as useless as it's possible to be.
However, it has been clear to me that the EU have wanted to punish us from the outset, for having the temerity to dare to leave.
As you say, they should know better than to rile the British with their put downs. The way our prime minister was treated yesterday was a total disgrace and it could back fire on Tusk and his cronies.
I know a few people who voted remain who are now saying '**** this attitude from the EU'.
We should tell them that we are now on course to revert to WTO trading regs and that they won't get a penny more from us after 29th March and if they want to talk again, the door is always open.
It truly now is time to tell them to **** off!
Bloody hell Sb, top post!
Agree with all these posts today. EU is being disrespectful and mocking us. If they continue to act like they are, they will push us too far. Even Farage said a few days ago that if the EU do not treat us with respect our bloody-mindedness would kick in (and for all of people who dislike Farage, he has been spot on). This is already happening. Yesterday the radio was full of people who said they voted remain but due to the way the EU has treated us would vote leave in the future. This was even confirmed by the Tory MP last night on QT

Tusk Joke just sums up the people we are dealing with? Macron should keep his mouth shut and worry about why he is less popular than Trump. I didn't realise just how much the French dislike him. He will be gone next election
As for the Irish..
The Irish should do more because that is one country that would sink without us. They need to speak up.

Finally, I have just listened to John Redwood (my MP and family friend) who has just made Sky 'remain' News look stupid yet again. The presenter tried the project fear approach about planes not flying after the deadline. he said "what rubbish you can buy Lufthansa tickets for after that date. Do you think they won't honour those tickets"? The presenter went very quiet.
He said they are going to tell TM to drop the Chequers plan as it's dead. He also said 'keep the money' and use it on the country after we leave.
Spot on.
That's a great post, Stan. I think too, that May needs to look at her UK civil servant advisors, particularly Ollie Robbins, who appears to have advised her that Salzburg would be a walk in the park and all the EU leaders rallying to support her.

Tusk's mocking tweet was designed to humiliate May, and through her, the UK. Macron's speech makes clear he wants to punish the UK for leaving. Add to that, we have EU leaders telling us to have another referendum. Those leaders (not the countries they represent) really do look increasingly like a bunch of gangsters and we will be well out from under their malign influences.
Bloody hell this is a bit disconcerting.

Just to be clear I think stupidity, ignorance and a degree of arrogance on all sides has led us to where we are now, I don’t think there was malign intent. The EU has to carry its share of responsibility for the shambles.

As you say Col decent leadership would have sorted this. I don’t think May has strong opinions on anything, she was virtually silent during the referendum campaign. From my perspective the alternatives to her were terrifying, but on reflection we would have been better off going for a full Brexit from day one and using the last couple of years to actually prepare for it.

Serious question for Leavers. Given the strong remain vote in Northern Ireland, would you be prepared for them to stay in the single market etc, essentially the Irish Sea border, in return for everything else you want? The same would be true for Gibraltar, 97% remain but want British passports.
 
Last edited:
Bloody hell this is a bit disconcerting.

Just to be clear I think stupidity, ignorance and a degree of arrogance on all sides has led us to where we are now, I don’t think there was malign intent. The EU has to carry its share of responsibility for the shambles.

As you say Col decent leadership would have sorted this. I don’t think May has strong opinions on anything, she was virtually silent during the referendum campaign. From my perspective the alternatives to her where terrifying, but on reflection we would have been better off going for a full Brexit from day one and using the last couple of years to actually prepare for it.

Serious question for Leavers. Given the strong remain vote in Northern Ireland, would you be prepared for them to stay in the single market etc, essentially the Irish Sea border, in return for everything else you want? The same would be true for Gibraltar, 97% remain but want British passports.

Northern Ireland is part of the UK. They decide how they are treated for customs purposes. An Irish Sea border would be an ideal fix for the rest of the UK, but it would never be acceptable to the Unionist community, so we must accept that. I still believe a technological solution is the answer. The UK government won't give way on this one.

According to the Irish Foreign Minister, a Brexit deal is 90% there. But the 10%, the Northern Irish border and the Customs arrangements on goods and services may be insoluble. We'll find out at the next EU meeting on October 18
 
  • Like
Reactions: sb_73
Bloody hell this is a bit disconcerting.

Just to be clear I think stupidity, ignorance and a degree of arrogance on all sides has led us to where we are now, I don’t think there was malign intent. The EU has to carry its share of responsibility for the shambles.

As you say Col decent leadership would have sorted this. I don’t think May has strong opinions on anything, she was virtually silent during the referendum campaign. From my perspective the alternatives to her where terrifying, but on reflection we would have been better off going for a full Brexit from day one and using the last couple of years to actually prepare for it.

Serious question for Leavers. Given the strong remain vote in Northern Ireland, would you be prepared for them to stay in the single market etc, essentially the Irish Sea border, in return for everything else you want? The same would be true for Gibraltar, 97% remain but want British passports.

I don't think a UK government would ever take a decision that could lead to a united Ireland whilst the people in Northern Ireland wish to remain British.
It is quite a problem, but I can't believe it is beyond the capability of Nations to find a solution.
This is where I disagree with you, as I firmly believe that the EU have had malign intent towards us since we voted to leave and their intransigence has made the Irish border problem even harder to solve.
I'm convinced that the EU will sit on their hands, waiting for us to cave in or change our minds.
 
Bloody hell this is a bit disconcerting.

Just to be clear I think stupidity, ignorance and a degree of arrogance on all sides has led us to where we are now, I don’t think there was malign intent. The EU has to carry its share of responsibility for the shambles.

As you say Col decent leadership would have sorted this. I don’t think May has strong opinions on anything, she was virtually silent during the referendum campaign. From my perspective the alternatives to her where terrifying, but on reflection we would have been better off going for a full Brexit from day one and using the last couple of years to actually prepare for it.

Serious question for Leavers. Given the strong remain vote in Northern Ireland, would you be prepared for them to stay in the single market etc, essentially the Irish Sea border, in return for everything else you want? The same would be true for Gibraltar, 97% remain but want British passports.
For balance, I thought it was a top post too!

If the EU representatives had half a brain, they'd realise that May has isolated herself with this Chequers deal which probably caused some disappointment to everyone but not so much to any one group.

If she had been given encouragement by theEU leaders then there could have been a bit of negotiation but a real prospect of a deal.

Now she's more isolated and cannot give an inch to the EU without it looking like a complete cave in which, with so many knives out, would be political suicide.

The EU need to back track or it'll be no deal and Macron is looking rather two faced in all this. If they don't make conciliatory gestures then I will be angry enough to, as Col so eloquently puts it, tell them to **** off.
 
I don't think a UK government would ever take a decision that could lead to a united Ireland whilst the people in Northern Ireland wish to remain British.
It is quite a problem, but I can't believe it is beyond the capability of Nations to find a solution.
This is where I disagree with you, as I firmly believe that the EU have had malign intent towards us since we voted to leave and their intransigence has made the Irish border problem even harder to solve.
I'm convinced that the EU will sit on their hands, waiting for us to cave in or change our minds.

Seems that Brexit changes the weight of opinion in NI towards a united Ireland.

https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/...ack-united-ireland-after-brexit-37275256.html
 
May making statement from Downing Street at 1:45. Pound fallen 1 cent on Dollar.
I wonder what this is about? :1980_boogie_down:
 
Northern Ireland is part of the UK. They decide how they are treated for customs purposes. An Irish Sea border would be an ideal fix for the rest of the UK, but it would never be acceptable to the Unionist community, so we must accept that. I still believe a technological solution is the answer. The UK government won't give way on this one.

According to the Irish Foreign Minister, a Brexit deal is 90% there. But the 10%, the Northern Irish border and the Customs arrangements on goods and services may be insoluble. We'll find out at the next EU meeting on October 18
For balance, I thought it was a top post too!

If the EU representatives had half a brain, they'd realise that May has isolated herself with this Chequers deal which probably caused some disappointment to everyone but not so much to any one group.

If she had been given encouragement by theEU leaders then there could have been a bit of negotiation but a real prospect of a deal.

Now she's more isolated and cannot give an inch to the EU without it looking like a complete cave in which, with so many knives out, would be political suicide.

The EU need to back track or it'll be no deal and Macron is looking rather two faced in all this. If they don't make conciliatory gestures then I will be angry enough to, as Col so eloquently puts it, tell them to **** off.
Fair enough, but I just get the feeling that 65m people are being held hostage by a few hundred thousand Unionists in NI. Still, best to stay off the Irish question, another intractable one, but at least it will be eventually solved by demographics.
 
I think it's interesting that die hard remainers on here are getting pissed off with the attitude of the EU.
That is a real indication, imo, that the EU have made a mistake in misjudging the British when riled.
 
Ball firmly in their court from my understanding. They’ll probably come back with some bollocks about ‘you are the ones wanting to leave, it’s up to you to sort it’ and we will descend ever closer to the playground.
They acted and treated her disgustingly yesterday. We always hear from the EU about treatment of people yet they act like that to the British Prime Minister? They shot themselves in the foot there because many many people are disgusted and are coming out in support for her.
 
The balls back in their court now so let's see if they react. Will we receive a joke tweet from Tusk or a different approach.
My view is if they treat us like this again we should tell them to @@@@ off and keep the money. Then we will see how clever Macron/Tusk and co look when they have to come up with that money?
 
OMG listening to Keir Starmer on Sky and after knocking May's Brexit plan was asked 3 questions on what he/Labour would do. <doh> No 2222ing idea! People go on about the Tories not having a solution. He contradicted himself twice in the interview and when challenged on it, looked lost. <doh>