Would you rather?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
oneforthebristolcity

oneforthebristolcity

Well-Known Member
Jan 26, 2011
9,228
3,096
113
NULL
Win the FA Cup or promoted to the Premiership?
With our current form a playoff place is quite a possibility and you never know with this league, if the form continues, the dream could become a reality...So just for the record, Bristol City FA Cup winners or Bristol City promoted to the Premiership?....Your thoughts!!!
 
Obviously I want them both but with a reality check I decided promotion is the best deal because it takes care of the bank balance for several years. When I look at the under rated teams that have not only been there, but stayed there, it makes me wonder why not us?
 
Supcon72 said:
FA Cup winners for me as that’s a trophy and will be in the history books forever.
Click to expand...
Agreed - though the 'sensible' option would probably be promotion, what are the reasons we watch football for? A 2nd tier side winning the FA Cup would be particularly historical and we'd be in Europe to boot!

Bookies have us as 100/1 odds, which is probably still too short (the Leicester effect maybe?), whereas for promotion we're now at around 5/1. Exciting times!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Supcon72
invermeremike said:
Obviously I want them both but with a reality check I decided promotion is the best deal because it takes care of the bank balance for several years
Click to expand...
It can also lead to grief! Get promoted and not ready for it, and I do not think we are … we are close! BUT NEED A LOT more.....
win the cup and hey ho that is something that will join the history books … even getting to WEMGLEE would be " a runners up cup" …..
CUP
 
  • Like
Reactions: RedorDead
One promotion could be easily forgotten, especially there's a chance we could come straight back down.....FA cup win from 2nd tier is in the history books forever...Having said that, the chances of us winning the cup, I would say to be very slim, where as promotion is a distinct possibility, so that's what we should concentrate on...IMO
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Reliant Robin TC2
The heart says win the FA Cup

The head says get promoted to the Premier League - not jus the great games, but the financial implications for the club would be massive
 
johngalleyfan2 said:
It can also lead to grief! Get promoted and not ready for it, and I do not think we are … we are close! BUT NEED A LOT more.....
win the cup and hey ho that is something that will join the history books … even getting to WEMGLEE would be " a runners up cup" …..
CUP
Click to expand...
Not often do I think you talk sense, mostly goobly goop to me. So I doth my cap to you on this reply.
 
Promotion by a country mile fa cup final fantastic but a one of game, imagine Man City, Man Utd, Spurs, Arsenal, Chelsea and so on and we play each of them twice, now that's what dreams are made of.
 
Promotion for me. Cup would be nice, and I do get the view that cup would be something in the record books for eternity, but still would prefer promotion.

I also understand, and to a point agree with John, about being promoted before we’re ready , but there’s always that risk , get there first and then do everything possible to attempt to stay there.

If we then get relegated we will at least have the parachute payments to allow us to compete on a more level playing field with many other championship teams .
 
Win the FA Cup for me, promotion to the premiership would be great and all but the novelty would wear off pretty quickly me thinks when we lose most weeks and the only thing to play for is finishing 17th every season like most teams now, I still remember Wigan Athletic winning the FA Cup in 2013 and something like that will never be forgotten
 
Win the F A Cup for me personally, dreamt about that all my life...we WILL win promotion to the Prem, if not this season, then we will next.
 
Yep win the cup, get into Europe get some high profile players on the back of this and storm the league next season :1980_boogie_down::angel::emoticon-0105-wink:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back