Worst XI Post Premiership Era

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
This is always going to be a problem. Assuming that a young player will eventually be good enough, how do we give them the experience to enable them to break through into the 1st team? Unless they are a Chamberlain or a Bale then it is tricky especially in the Premier League.

Cup Games are a good way to blood youngsters, loan spells and now with the extra bench room, we can accomodate them at various points in the League, to bring on when winning comfortably (As happend to McNish, Chamberlain, Martin & Gobern in recent memory)
 
Forecast
Ifil Mettomo Lancashire Molyneux
Smith Pulis Sarmiento Thomson
Robertson Euell

Subs:
Miller
Bennett
Otemobor
O'Hallorhan
Pekhart

Who?

Also I'm surprised st brendy hasn't been in here yet. If he wasn't so afraid to type the name I'm sure his team would be 11 Ryan Smiths.
 
We have had quite a few players over the years who never really got a chance to show us what they could do. One of my favourites was Mario Licka.
 
We have had quite a few players over the years who never really got a chance to show us what they could do. One of my favourites was Mario Licka.

I really rated him, and so did Pearson but Burley signed him yet barely used him - another strange signing by Burley
 
I still cannot forget Folly and Jakobsson although I cannot remember if they left once we exited the Premiership. Obviously they are not in the same League as Bennett although I feel people criticising McGoldrick are being a bit harsh.

AAARRRRRGGGGHHHHHH! Folly is at Aberdeen - he broke his ankle about 15 months ago, and hasn`t been seen since. He`s like a virtual midfield player - come to think of it, he was virtual player even when he was on the pitch.
 
Didnt we make a double signing back in 08 of Smith and Molyneux is that the worst double signing in the history of signings? Man we had some dross that season Peckhart, Jordon Robertson, Gasmi, Jake thomson. Kayne mclagon came in at 16 and looked good compared to rest of them hes now at tonbridge angels on loan!! What a difference a few years make.
 
Didnt we make a double signing back in 08 of Smith and Molyneux is that the worst double signing in the history of signings? Man we had some dross that season Peckhart, Jordon Robertson, Gasmi, Jake thomson. Kayne mclagon came in at 16 and looked good compared to rest of them hes now at tonbridge angels on loan!! What a difference a few years make.

McLaggon had a serious injury that set him back, and he ain't been the same player

Ah, Smith & Molyenux - hailed as the perfect Left Side for the Saints! Class they were
 
McLaggon had a serious injury that set him back, and he ain't been the same player

Ah, Smith & Molyenux - hailed as the perfect Left Side for the Saints! Class they were

Didnt know that shame for him. I did think he looked alright (most would compared to what else we had) just thought strange how quickly a career can dive. Tbh probably did him no good being played so young, is he still our youngest apperance?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=suBnGpXQXHw&feature=player_embedded Molyenuexs even got a youtube vid!!
 
Didnt know that shame for him. I did think he looked alright (most would compared to what else we had) just thought strange how quickly a career can dive. Tbh probably did him no good being played so young, is he still our youngest apperance?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=suBnGpXQXHw&feature=player_embedded Molyenuexs even got a youtube vid!!

Yeah, McLaggon tore his achilles just as he broke into the side, kept him out for a year and was released by Pardew - He looked a damn good prospect but the injury ruined him

Isn't Walcott our youngest appearence though?
 
Isn't Pekhart doing quite well in the Bundesliga?
Yh think so, was only like 19 for us at the time thats the type of player we had to rely on. Really young inexperienced players some had potential (peckhart lallana mckgolrick surman etc.) Alot didnt!

Edit: Im saying this retrospectively to be fair I dont remember Peckhart showing any great signs back then!