Transfer Rumours Transfer Rumours Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Come now.. He was signed clearly as a replacement for Anelka. And even if we had both, how would having both have made us any better anyway given we played 4-4-2 with two strikers and one of those was Bergkamp?? Its not as Henry was burning himself out or needing the competition. He was quite possibly the greatest striker in the world for a few seasons. But no... You're right... I'm sure Anelka would have been better for us and won us more trophies.
 
But this is a fantasy, hypothetical situation - I didn't realise there were caviates to what could/might have happened if he'd stayed.
It's not fantasy. It's debating cyms statement that if Anelka had stayed it was more than possible that we'd have won more trophies than having Henry up front as our sole front man.

I'd say it's not 'more than possible'. It's as close to 'nigh on impossible' as you can get without ever being able to prove something.
 
Anelka was just a pacy centre forward.

Thierry was a creative, flamboyant genius. I would rate him considerably higher.
Our whole team scored more with Thierry in the side. He got assists, drifted in and out of position - he scared defences rigid.

Also agree with Cini on this - its highly improbable Henry would have been signed had we kept Anelka. The money from the sale of Anelka enabled us buy several World Class players.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Smirnoffpriest
I agree totally and unequivocally that while Anelka was a good (maybe great) striker, Henry was so much more than just a great striker.

But I thought the argument was that if we'd kept Anelka (as well as everyone else we'd had then and signed after him) then we'd have won more than if he'd left.
 
Yeah.. These hypethicals are weird.

Imagine if we still had RVP for example.

---Sanchez------Carzorla-------Ozil---
--------------------VanPersie-----------------

That's a pretty scary attack right there.
 
Yeah.. These hypethicals are weird.

Imagine if we still had RVP for example.

---Sanchez------Carzorla-------Ozil---
--------------------VanPersie-----------------

That's a pretty scary attack right there.


Yeah I'm so annoyed that RVP went - as with the signings we made since (the types of ones he said we weren't making and that's why he left), then we could have had an awesome team - and another hypothetical is that if we'd had a goal scorer 2 years ago we may have won the league.

And to add a bit of spice we could have had as well :) -
--------------------Fabergas--------------
---Sanchez------Carzorla-------Ozil---
--------------------VanPersie-----------------
 
Yeah I'm so annoyed that RVP went - as with the signings we made since (the types of ones he said we weren't making and that's why he left), then we could have had an awesome team - and another hypothetical is that if we'd had a goal scorer 2 years ago we may have won the league.

And to add a bit of spice we could have had as well :) -
--------------------Fabergas--------------
---Sanchez------Carzorla-------Ozil---
--------------------VanPersie-----------------

what !!!!!

you would play Cesc as the DM and drop the Coq !
 
Come now.. He was signed clearly as a replacement for Anelka. And even if we had both, how would having both have made us any better anyway given we played 4-4-2 with two strikers and one of those was Bergkamp?? Its not as Henry was burning himself out or needing the competition. He was quite possibly the greatest striker in the world for a few seasons. But no... You're right... I'm sure Anelka would have been better for us and won us more trophies.
If he was signed as a replacement for Anelka how come we were heavily linked to Henry prior to and during the 1998 World Cup ?
I am sure I have read that Wenger said that his plan was to have Anelka & Henry playing together
 
No value in wondering about the past, we've just got to hope that our Coq doesn't drop
 
Has anyone got an update on Kheidera has he signed new contract with RM or is he still available for free this summer
 
Has anyone got an update on Kheidera has he signed new contract with RM or is he still available for free this summer

Saw an article the other day linking him to a move to some German team so I assume he still hasn't signed a new contract.