Neill. It's a funny old game mate as someone once said and two people watching the same match will often see different things.
I agree and have said, Colback was fantastic imo. Not sure about the Scholes thing mind just yet because the one thing young Jack isn't yet is a goal threat. Scholes was a regular 10 goal a season player even at 20. You wonder if Colback will be a 20 goal career.
That apart though, he is well worth his place in the team imo and should not be dropped.