The weakest link

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I'd have to disagree here I think Santon can defend and he will prove his value to the team this season. You've got to think that last season was his first in a new City and league where he didn't know the language or what to expect. Other players have settled easier and quicker, but the bulk of our foreign signings have all either been French or spoken French and know people already at the club which has made settling that bit easier.

As the only Italian I can imagine he had a job getting adjusted to the club and the City, but all the talk from him (and surprisingly his agent) quashing rumours of a move back to Italy and wanting to stay here sounds really positive. He showed in spells last season how good he is going forward and how well he can defend, but consistency was his major problem. Pardew will get the best out of him though I've no doubt about that.

The weakest link is definitely Simpson by a country mile. Absolutely hopeless going forward, which must be frustrating for Ben Arfa or whoever is played infront of him and while his goal line clearances were a godsend at times last season his inability to close down defenders and the amount of times he was done for pace on the wing is worrying considering his age.

He's improved a lot since we signed him on loan in the Championship, but he's hit a wall where he doesn't look like he'll improve any more and to continue to challenge top eight he needs to be moved on and someone better brought in

Agree with you there Joe Kinnear (blimey, never thought I'd type that sentence).

Foreign players often take a good season to settle in. Colo + Enrique both had difficult times in their first season here. I think Santon will do well this year and go on to become a first choice legend / fan's favouite much the same way as Jose did.
 
Agree with you there Joe Kinnear (blimey, never thought I'd type that sentence).

Foreign players often take a good season to settle in. Colo + Enrique both had difficult times in their first season here. I think Santon will do well this year and go on to become a first choice legend / fan's favouite much the same way as Jose did.

It's ok Obi, I don't think it's the real Joke in Ear.
 
I'd have to disagree here I think Santon can defend and he will prove his value to the team this season. You've got to think that last season was his first in a new City and league where he didn't know the language or what to expect. Other players have settled easier and quicker, but the bulk of our foreign signings have all either been French or spoken French and know people already at the club which has made settling that bit easier.

As the only Italian I can imagine he had a job getting adjusted to the club and the City, but all the talk from him (and surprisingly his agent) quashing rumours of a move back to Italy and wanting to stay here sounds really positive. He showed in spells last season how good he is going forward and how well he can defend, but consistency was his major problem. Pardew will get the best out of him though I've no doubt about that.

The weakest link is definitely Simpson by a country mile. Absolutely hopeless going forward, which must be frustrating for Ben Arfa or whoever is played infront of him and while his goal line clearances were a godsend at times last season his inability to close down defenders and the amount of times he was done for pace on the wing is worrying considering his age.

He's improved a lot since we signed him on loan in the Championship, but he's hit a wall where he doesn't look like he'll improve any more and to continue to challenge top eight he needs to be moved on and someone better brought in

I agree, this seems wholly unfair to the lad. He is in a new country like you say, learning a new language and trying to adapt to a game that is played at a frenetic pace in comparison to Italy. He was playing in what is not his best position and had to come in and out of the team a bit early on due to niggling knee injuries carried over from Inter. The lad oozes class and I expect big things from him this year.
 
As you guys have said, I am also excited to see what a season has done to settle our new recruits...



Settled French connection + Ten times better than last season Tiote = <party>
 
Williamson isn't in our first choice starting line up.... <doh>

The OP's question was who is our "weakest mainstream player". Willo is in the first team squad and likely to be on the bench - unless either Colo or Saylor are injured / unfit, in which case he'll most likely start. <ok>
 
The OP's question was who is our "weakest mainstream player". Willo is in the first team squad and likely to be on the bench - unless either Colo or Saylor are injured / unfit, in which case he'll most likely start. <ok>

Ah I didn't realise he had wrote that
 
i agree with willo, simmo & obertan

but...and I'll prob get slated for this.....i actually think HBA can be a weak link. if the game isn't going his way he can go missing for good chunks and loose the ball needlessly, he's kind of a Laurent Robert on hs day a cracking player but non-existant on a bad day.
 
i agree with willo, simmo & obertan

but...and I'll prob get slated for this.....i actually think HBA can be a weak link. if the game isn't going his way he can go missing for good chunks and loose the ball needlessly, he's kind of a Laurent Robert on hs day a cracking player but non-existant on a bad day.

I was going to say HBA as well, but bravely waited for someone else to take the opening salvo. When he's on, he's unstoppable but if he isn't on, he loses the ball and doesn't track back, which puts Simpson under more pressure. Still, I'd rather see his name on the team sheet than the alternatives.
 
If HBA is our weakest link then we're flying!! <magic><somersault><wizard>:emoticon-0103-cool:<diva>

Actually, if any of those are our weakest link then we're in pretty good shape. Willo is a generally solid, if unspohisticated defender. Obertan has plenty of pace and is a very useful outlet, and is showing hints of developing an end product. I always am worried that Simmo will make a mess of things but he usually doesn't, and he has had some moments of real quality.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.