Off Topic The SIR Kenny Dalglish Public House

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
jenners04 said:
perhaps you care to elaborate on this comment then

"I'd say people wanting to go on a forum that only as fans of the same club should seek another site as this one isn't for that. They could use both if they wished. This is a open mixed sports forum, you should expect interaction from opposing fans!"

one thread was my suggestion ,and that was your response to me!
Click to expand...

Just did <ok>
 
Jenners & JB...

Here are my comments on the issue as a user of the site...

Gerrez said:
I agree its a bad idea btw
Click to expand...

Gerrez said:
I'd say people wanting to go on a forum that only as fans of the same club should seek another site as this one isn't for that. They could use both if they wished. This is a open mixed sports forum, you should expect interaction from opposing fans!
Click to expand...


And here are my comments as a moderator of our board...

Gerrez said:
How would you mod such a thing? Is it based on what club they support in which case, whats stopping a poster claiming to be a fan of a club they're not?
Click to expand...

Gerrez said:
Feel free to try it. Technically, that is what the pub is there for though <ok>
Click to expand...

Gerrez said:
I've already said to Jenners, give it a go if you wish, let's see what happens. However, if you want it moderating than I suggest the OP to such a thread highlights what the rules are <ok>

PS...and don't expect 24hr moderation either <laugh>
Click to expand...

Gerrez said:
I'm happy to trial any reasonable suggestion. I don't agree about having a LFC Only zone but can't see a reason to just cast it aside either. My concerns are more around how it would be monitored and how can we be sure a poster is a LFC fan? Maybe they need to have made twenty comments before being allowed to participate? This gives us a platform to change a newbie put that also isolates them too.

I'm pulling my weight, I'm just not very heavy :p
Click to expand...

Gerrez said:
I did say several times yesterday that they are welcome to give it a go. Also said the same about rules etc too but added that it wouldn't be moderated 24-7. I don't see the need for the poll (although we do love a good poll), just create it and see what happens. If it works, it works. If it doesn't, it sinks. Simple.
Click to expand...

Think you will find I have not said don't do it at any point. I have passed my opinion and that's all it is, my opinion. I think people need to ignore the mod tag at times, I'm still a user of the site and entitled to pass my view <ok>
 
luvgonzo said:
We could go the other way and have a thread for visitors of the board, a sort of online equivilent of a small dark room.
Click to expand...

Because we've had such a discussion about it, the LFC Only thread may get boycotted by those that voted no anyway. That's if it ever happens (not a dig at anyone!)
 
Gerrez said:
Jenners & JB...

Here are my comments on the issue as a user of the site...


And here are my comments as a moderator of our board...


Think you will find I have not said don't do it at any point. I have passed my opinion and that's all it is, my opinion. I think people need to ignore the mod tag at times, I'm still a user of the site and entitled to pass my view <ok>
Click to expand...

mate, mate, mate, mate, mate, I love you, I really do - this has never been the point of contention.

From my point of view I have said I suggested it once, didn't go down well, don't want to create a thread now, THE END. From jenners point of view, he suggested it in a very throwaway kind of way, got told the response above in which you addressed one thread idea as some sort of new way for running the forum, kept getting told to go and make a thread from you and several others, - which he didn't and doesn't want to do. mito threw in 'changing the ethos of the forum' and all that came from the idea for ONE thread. Can we stop now please??? please.... please
 
johnsonsbaby said:
mate, mate, mate, mate, mate, I love you, I really do - this has never been the point of contention.

From my point of view I have said I suggested it once, didn't go down well, don't want to create a thread now, THE END. From jenners point of view, he suggested it in a very throwaway kind of way, got told the response above in which you addressed one thread idea as some sort of new way for running the forum, kept getting told to go and make a thread from you and several others, - which he didn't and doesn't want to do. mito threw in 'changing the ethos of the forum' and all that came from the idea for ONE thread. Can we stop now please??? please.... please
Click to expand...

Fair enough, we (including Jenners) were obviously at cross wires. Apologies if I caused offence, wasn't intended, I was merely passing comment but can understand feeling like you (including Jenners) are being got at if others put similar comments too. I didn't read every comment on that thread, I generally scan back a dozen or so comments and catch up <ok>
 
luvgonzo said:
Is it invisible to non Leicester City fans as I can't see it and want to know what happens if I post there?
Click to expand...

I thought you were joking here but just popped over to have a gander and I can't see it either <laugh>
 
luvgonzo said:
Is it invisible to non Leicester City fans as I can't see it and want to know what happens if I post there?
Click to expand...

I've no idea. I was reading the Leicester forum on Friday and saw this comment 'can we take this to the Leicester fans only thread, thanks' - so I presumed he knew what he was talking about <ok>
 
Gerrez said:
Fair enough, we (including Jenners) were obviously at cross wires. Apologies if I caused offence, wasn't intended, I was merely passing comment but can understand feeling like you (including Jenners) are being got at if others put similar comments too. I didn't read every comment on that thread, I generally scan back a dozen or so comments and catch up <ok>
Click to expand...

I'm not offended, can't speak for jenners <ok>

It's the people who don't want it who are making a big deal out of it - anyway me and jenners are off to join rawk <laugh>
 
Let's all hug n make up

In going to have a cocktail and expect you all to be one big happy LFC family when I get back drunk on sun, Portuguese food n cocktails later <diva> <smooch> <hug>
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back