Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
You must log in or register to see images

Nadine Dorries couldn’t make the ERG’s 6pm meeting last night and so instead has sent a list of seven key points she would have liked to have raised. She hits out at members who have “let the ERG down as a group”, those who see themselves as “above” sending a letter,and those who are constantly briefing journalists.
Read the mammoth message in full here:
At 6pm, I will be chairing the finance bill on the floor of the house and therefore, cannot attend the meeting.
If I were there, I would be very, very keen to speak and make the following points. I would be grateful if the chairman would acknowledge my comments during the meeting.

  1. There are a handful of you who have badly let the ERG down as a group, opening us up to ridicule and abuse in the media and online. I am referring to those MPs who have not put their letters in. It is being said that you have let the side down and are not the type of people anyone would want to go into battle with. You have left others to do the dirty work of pushing forward the debate and hid under the covers. Only one person in the group has an excuse that is even fractionally credible, the rest are transparent and risible.
  2. There is an assumption that some believe themselves to be ‘superior’ or ‘senior’ and above the tackiness of submitting a letter. You are not. We are all equal, all elected members, all have one vote and should all have each other’s back.
  3. The excuse that some will wait until the vote is lost, and it will be, are doing neither the party or the country a favour. No10 are reportedly already preparing for a general election. Your strategy is high risk and dangerous as what could very quickly follow, after a second lost vote, if there were one, would be a vote of confidence in the government. If the worst were to happen, a general election would follow.
  4. We either change the PM or face an election. None of want to do this, we would all prefer an easier life, but there can be no other outcome and those who are too self important to put in their letters at this stage, will deliver the latter. I cannot think of any greater imperative to submitting a letter and changing leader than the thought that we are faced with a general election and some of our precious colleagues, new MPs with barely any time in their seat, walking into an election 5 points behind in the polls with a communist government waiting in the wings.
  5. It is not a good plan to tip the media off about a meeting in No10 and then refuse to give the media comment. It results in ridicule of the whole group rather than the few holding the meeting.
  6. Certain members of the group are constantly briefing Beth Rigby and Laura Kuenssberg. As someone who pays my dues to the group (and I would like to see a list of those who do compared to how many are on this WhatsApp) less briefing and more strategy might be good? Beth and Laura are both professionals and great journalists, but no one on the group has any professional experience in comms and I think that is beginning to show.
  7. The DUP mean business. Not one of us travelling to Brussels or meeting with the PM is going to get her to change her mind, however well the meetings go. There is a belief in the party that the DUP will buckle and come back to the fold. That is an absolute underestimation of the determination of the DUP. They understand principle and the art of negotiation better than most. Our majority has almost left the room as a result of this deal. We all know what will follow.
 
So if I'm correct in understanding the statement 'I believe in our country', then I definately don't believe in it. I think it's going to the dogs! Stabbings and murders, poverty and homelessness, fat cats getting richer, poor getting poorer, social injustices, underfunded servicemen and underpaid. Cuts to social services, food banks. Front line staff not recognised for the work they do. Politicians lies and politics at an all time low etc etc

Rant over. Apologies if that upsets anyone

Maybe you should move to the UAE and complain about the state and leaders and see how long you last.
 
bob your dislike of politicians has nothing to with being 'proud' or 'believing' in your country'. Can you not see the difference? Talking about food banks has nothing to do with being proud or not. Food banks are caused for a number of reasons (mostly I will admit is actions by the government). It saddens but doesn't surprise me that some people are not proud of their country.
It quite saddens me too ellers.
Pride is a personel opinion on something. I'm proud of my son. I'm not proud of the neighbours son. Of course talking about food banks has something to do with myself being proud or not. I donate weekly to them. I'm proud of that, whilst I feel no pride at all that we live in a society where people have to use them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Willhoops
You must log in or register to see images

Nadine Dorries couldn’t make the ERG’s 6pm meeting last night and so instead has sent a list of seven key points she would have liked to have raised. She hits out at members who have “let the ERG down as a group”, those who see themselves as “above” sending a letter,and those who are constantly briefing journalists.
Read the mammoth message in full here:
At 6pm, I will be chairing the finance bill on the floor of the house and therefore, cannot attend the meeting.
If I were there, I would be very, very keen to speak and make the following points. I would be grateful if the chairman would acknowledge my comments during the meeting.

  1. There are a handful of you who have badly let the ERG down as a group, opening us up to ridicule and abuse in the media and online. I am referring to those MPs who have not put their letters in. It is being said that you have let the side down and are not the type of people anyone would want to go into battle with. You have left others to do the dirty work of pushing forward the debate and hid under the covers. Only one person in the group has an excuse that is even fractionally credible, the rest are transparent and risible.
  2. There is an assumption that some believe themselves to be ‘superior’ or ‘senior’ and above the tackiness of submitting a letter. You are not. We are all equal, all elected members, all have one vote and should all have each other’s back.
  3. The excuse that some will wait until the vote is lost, and it will be, are doing neither the party or the country a favour. No10 are reportedly already preparing for a general election. Your strategy is high risk and dangerous as what could very quickly follow, after a second lost vote, if there were one, would be a vote of confidence in the government. If the worst were to happen, a general election would follow.
  4. We either change the PM or face an election. None of want to do this, we would all prefer an easier life, but there can be no other outcome and those who are too self important to put in their letters at this stage, will deliver the latter. I cannot think of any greater imperative to submitting a letter and changing leader than the thought that we are faced with a general election and some of our precious colleagues, new MPs with barely any time in their seat, walking into an election 5 points behind in the polls with a communist government waiting in the wings.
  5. It is not a good plan to tip the media off about a meeting in No10 and then refuse to give the media comment. It results in ridicule of the whole group rather than the few holding the meeting.
  6. Certain members of the group are constantly briefing Beth Rigby and Laura Kuenssberg. As someone who pays my dues to the group (and I would like to see a list of those who do compared to how many are on this WhatsApp) less briefing and more strategy might be good? Beth and Laura are both professionals and great journalists, but no one on the group has any professional experience in comms and I think that is beginning to show.
  7. The DUP mean business. Not one of us travelling to Brussels or meeting with the PM is going to get her to change her mind, however well the meetings go. There is a belief in the party that the DUP will buckle and come back to the fold. That is an absolute underestimation of the determination of the DUP. They understand principle and the art of negotiation better than most. Our majority has almost left the room as a result of this deal. We all know what will follow.

Love that this was leaked, hilarious!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
Why would I want to do that?

I am stating a point that for all the faults we have...we are still a better country than many others around the World.
You say "I donate weekly to them. I'm proud of that" and so you should be proud. :emoticon-0148-yes: The fact that you do this makes me 'believe in my country' and the people we have in it. Forget for a minute the reasons why many people use food banks. Think about the people that help out. As I said I am proud of my country and I believe in it.
I said earlier that Deal/may's deal/no deal we will come through all this stronger because of who we are and what we can do. I believe in my country... cue the National anthem!
 
I am stating a point that for all the faults we have...we are still a better country than many others around the World.
You say "I donate weekly to them. I'm proud of that" and so you should be proud. :emoticon-0148-yes: The fact that you do this makes me 'believe in my country' and the people we have in it. Forget for a minute the reasons why many people use food banks. Think about the people that help out. As I said I am proud of my country and I believe in it.
I said earlier that Deal/may's deal/no deal we will come through all this stronger because of who we are and what we can do. I believe in my country... cue the National anthem!
Very well put Ellers.
 
I am stating a point that for all the faults we have...we are still a better country than many others around the World.
You say "I donate weekly to them. I'm proud of that" and so you should be proud. :emoticon-0148-yes: The fact that you do this makes me 'believe in my country' and the people we have in it. Forget for a minute the reasons why many people use food banks. Think about the people that help out. As I said I am proud of my country and I believe in it.
I said earlier that Deal/may's deal/no deal we will come through all this stronger because of who we are and what we can do. I believe in my country.
You and others can be as proud of being British (English?) as you want, and good luck to you. I’m very happy to be British, and in the grand scheme of things there is plenty of stuff to be proud of, not least our history, inventiveness, and cultural influence, especially in law and justice. I travel a lot, including to places that have reason not to be our biggest fans, and never feel any shame in declaring where I’m from. But that does not convert into unwavering ‘belief’ that my country is special other than the accident of birth that I happen to be from here.

What the **** this has to do with ‘being better’ than other countries is beyond me. If we are ‘better’ than many other countries, how are we better, and which countries are better than us? From the evidence of my eyes on 11 November the Poles are much better than us in demonstrating pride in their country (not the few nationalist nutters in Warsaw, but ordinary and friendly families in Krakow and Kielce).

It’s not a competition in my view.
 
That's not a fair comment. Just because you think it's an 'empty soundbite' doesn't mean the rest of us do. You cannot possibly tell what a country means to someone else, and just calling it a soundbite is another ill-informed comment.

I am proud of my country...get over it. Don't confuse the 'cretins' as you call them with being proud of a nation. Two different things. You don't have to support a government to be proud of the country.
Are you proud of the staff of the NHS or Army?
If yes, then they are the sort of things that should make people proud of our country. Last week I went over to France and saw thousands of graves of British soldiers who fought and gave up their lives for this country so that we could be free. Are you saying you are not proud of them? Did they give up their lives for nothing?
As for your 'Poorest' bit? WTF! did you mix up two different posts... actually make it three.

We are proud of the UK we are Anglo Saxons

But we have things wrong
Having the courage to admit that is half the battle
This lot currently in power same as the last two decades sold our country out imo
 
No much to be proud of the UK at the moment imo

Apart from the football music and the arts

Historically there is a wonder to look upon

The sum of all the parts currently should make people pissed off
 
You and others can be as proud of being British (English?) as you want, and good luck to you. I’m very happy to be British, and in the grand scheme of things there is plenty of stuff to be proud of, not least our history, inventiveness, and cultural influence, especially in law and justice. I travel a lot, including to places that have reason not to be our biggest fans, and never feel any shame in declaring where I’m from. But that does not convert into unwavering ‘belief’ that my country is special other than the accident of birth that I happen to be from here.

What the **** this has to do with ‘being better’ than other countries is beyond me. If we are ‘better’ than many other countries, how are we better, and which countries are better than us? From the evidence of my eyes on 11 November the Poles are much better than us in demonstrating pride in their country (not the few nationalist nutters in Warsaw, but ordinary and friendly families in Krakow and Kielce).

It’s not a competition in my view.
Maybe I should have said we are more democratic than a lot of crap countries around the World. However, what I have read from some they don't understand the word.
 
So arch May ally Amber Rudd voices what the vast majority of MPs already know - parliament won't allow No Deal to happen. That being the case, what happens when May's deal gets voted down?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Willhoops
Hard to see how, with Labour, Liberals, SNP, DUP and ERG voting against.

I was surprised to see Ken Clarke saying he would be voting for it today. Can see some Labour rebels being bounced into it now to avoid hard Brexit. All comes down to ERG - you have to wonder, if they can't even manage 48 letters if they may realise that this deal is the best they will get. Humiliation over last few days may cause them to think twice.

Still a long shot, I fully appreciate, but looking more likely than it was two days ago.
 
So arch May ally Amber Rudd voices what the vast majority of MPs already know - parliament won't allow No Deal to happen. That being the case, what happens when May's deal gets voted down?

How about they shoot that tosser on College Green with the People's Vote placards that tries to get into the frame of every interview!
 
  • Like
Reactions: rangercol
How about they shoot that tosser on College Green with the People's Vote placards that tries to get into the frame of every interview!
He said that he has been there every day for 15 months...How about getting a job. He probably wants to stay in the EU because he thinks under new law he may have to work. Just another muppet obsessed with being in the limelight.
Agree shoot him.
 
Looking forward to the proud British allowing the proud Scottish and the proud NI people at least have a decent say on how their sectors of the UK continue

UAE my arse

Pride today in the UK means a couple of weekends in the summer when we can all play guess the fruit ... oh that’s a prickly pear