Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
If you think of the electorate as one living, breathing entity then 52/48 tells you that “it” wanted to leave the EU, but not overwhelmingly so. Not a hard Brexit. Four percentage points is so marginal I fail to see why anything other than something similar to the Norwegian model is appropriate.
Here you go:
We resign our membership of the EU
We join the European Economic Area - like Norway, in Single Market but not Customs Union. No fisheries, agriculture policies, no euro stuff, exempt from ‘ever closer union’
The (pro remain) people of Northern Ireland can have a referendum on whether they want a customs border with Ireland (like the Norway/Sweden border) or to remain in the Customs Union and for all the imaginary customs tech to be used on goods going UK mainland to NI and vice versa. Or our government can chose on their behalf.

Tolerable for the majority even if not the fanatics at either end of the spectrum. Out of the EU, minimises economic risk, gives us time to ponder, in less febrile times, if we want to move further away in future (subject to debate in elections).
 
I'd say that those who actively seek an outcome that is widely acknowledged to be the most damaging to our economic welfare are the real enemy within, Ellers.
No, don't imply something about me and then slime away. You said
but you seem to be almost gleeful at the prospect. Why would that be?
Why did you need to ask that question? Why are you trying to make me out to be something I am not?
 
Christ on a bike!!
This just goes round and round and ****ing round.

How many times have the same points been made and the same questions asked?
We end up with all manner of personal insults, attacks and indirect digs from some posters when they are trying to get a rise out of someone without actually naming them (and sometimes by actually naming them).


What a pile of ****e!!
 
No, don't imply something about me and then slime away. You said Why did you need to ask that question? Why are you trying to make me out to be something I am not?

Stroller said:
I'd say that those who actively seek an outcome that is widely acknowledged to be the most damaging to our economic welfare are the real enemy within, Ellers.

This was aimed at the 'Moggmeister', Ellers - someone you support.
 
Here you go:
We resign our membership of the EU
We join the European Economic Area - like Norway, in Single Market but not Customs Union. No fisheries, agriculture policies, no euro stuff, exempt from ‘ever closer union’
The (pro remain) people of Northern Ireland can have a referendum on whether they want a customs border with Ireland (like the Norway/Sweden border) or to remain in the Customs Union and for all the imaginary customs tech to be used on goods going UK mainland to NI and vice versa. Or our government can chose on their behalf.

Tolerable for the majority even if not the fanatics at either end of the spectrum. Out of the EU, minimises economic risk, gives us time to ponder, in less febrile times, if we want to move further away in future (subject to debate in elections).
We only import 4% of food from the US 27% from the EU. That will change. The US exports Fish/agriculture and forestry products. Same as Australia only 4%. I was told by my dad that before the EU we used to get great cuts of New Zealand lamb. stuff from Oz and fruit South Africa. That all stopped when we joined in the 70's. When we leave we will get that deal going again.
 
Here you go:
We resign our membership of the EU
We join the European Economic Area - like Norway, in Single Market but not Customs Union. No fisheries, agriculture policies, no euro stuff, exempt from ‘ever closer union’
The (pro remain) people of Northern Ireland can have a referendum on whether they want a customs border with Ireland (like the Norway/Sweden border) or to remain in the Customs Union and for all the imaginary customs tech to be used on goods going UK mainland to NI and vice versa. Or our government can chose on their behalf.

Tolerable for the majority even if not the fanatics at either end of the spectrum. Out of the EU, minimises economic risk, gives us time to ponder, in less febrile times, if we want to move further away in future (subject to debate in elections).

All seems perfectly sensible to me.

As you know, I’m a Brexiteer and would like nothing better than something more radical, but it all really depends upon whether you consider the referendum to have been a “first past the post” event or one that ought to be sympathetic to ‘proportional representation’. Had the outcome been (say) 60/40 or more then there’s a greater argument for a harder Brexit.
 
Bob many have said what the benefits will be. Only problem is as soon as they say something a remoaner denounces it and puts project fear into action. Being able to trade with the World without all the Brussels BS. Getting back our fishing waters so they don't get pillaged by everyone bar us. Don't forget the blue passport! The French and Dutch have offered to make it so there is one deal with the EU after Brexit.

List ten
Ok try five
 
You never been to Australia/US/Canada/Russia you need visa, however I get your point Bob, let's hope it doesn't come to that as it will gain nothing.
Worked in the USA so needed a working visa anyway. Generally holiday in the canaries and never needed a visa. Hope I never will as it will add a nice hefty price on to an already expensive holiday
 
We only import 4% of food from the US 27% from the EU. That will change. The US exports Fish/agriculture and forestry products. Same as Australia only 4%. I was told by my dad that before the EU we used to get great cuts of New Zealand lamb. stuff from Oz and fruit South Africa. That all stopped when we joined in the 70's. When we leave we will get that deal going again.
? What I spelt out is a compromise. It gets us out of the EU while keeping the foundations of our economy solid for a bit. Doesn’t have to be forever but the poisonous atmosphere we have in this country at the moment needs the heat taking out of it. We have to compromise. (I prefer my food to have travelled the minimum possible distance before I eat it, so welsh lamb for me,and I have had local Warwickshire lamb, beef, pork and chicken since I discovered a new and excellent butcher. We export more lamb than we import and most of what we do import comes from NZ and Aus. They just want to sell us more and undercut UK farmers with frozen stuff).
All seems perfectly sensible to me.

As you know, I’m a Brexiteer and would like nothing better than something more radical, but it all really depends upon whether you consider the referendum to have been a “first past the post” event or one that ought to be sympathetic to ‘proportional representation’. Had the outcome been (say) 60/40 or more then there’s a greater argument for a harder Brexit.
Give and take, at the very least to stop us having to talk about it all the time.
 
Last edited:
Bob many have said what the benefits will be. Only problem is as soon as they say something a remoaner denounces it and puts project fear into action. Being able to trade with the World without all the Brussels BS. Getting back our fishing waters so they don't get pillaged by everyone bar us. Don't forget the blue passport! The French and Dutch have offered to make it so there is one deal with the EU after Brexit.
Sweet jesus if that's the best all this ****e is about then it seems even crazier by the minute. What a load of crap. Passport colour and fishing!!! Give me ****ing strenghth
 
Worked in the USA so needed a working visa anyway. Generally holiday in the canaries and never needed a visa. Hope I never will as it will add a nice hefty price on to an already expensive holiday
To be honest I don’t think it will Bob. I’m sure we will have a preferential status like we do with the US and Canada (for visitors) now where you get a two year visa (for about $10) on line, no need to send passports away or anything. If visas are needed at all, we didn’t have them before we joined the Common Market.
 
  • Like
Reactions: rangercol
? What I spelt out is a compromise. It gets us out of the EU while keeping the foundations of our economy solid for a bit. Doesn’t have to be forever but the poisonous atmosphere we have in this country at the moment needs the heat taking out of it. We have to compromise. (I prefer my food to have travelled the minimum possible distance before I eat it, so welsh lamb for me,and I have had local Warwickshire lamb, beef, pork and chicken since I discovered a new and excellent butcher)

Give and take, at the very least to stop us having to talk about it all the time.

I’m only talking about it all the time because Col is making me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr and sb_73
We only import 4% of food from the US 27% from the EU. That will change. The US exports Fish/agriculture and forestry products. Same as Australia only 4%. I was told by my dad that before the EU we used to get great cuts of New Zealand lamb. stuff from Oz and fruit South Africa. That all stopped when we joined in the 70's. When we leave we will get that deal going again.

Great I expect there are stocks of goods waiting for us to shop for

South Africa and Kenya all ready pre pack U.K. supermarket branded veg Ellers
No time differences as such
My neighbours son lives in Kenya
It’s about U.K. airport capacity it’s at its limit
Staines maybe able to confirm that
 
? What I spelt out is a compromise. It gets us out of the EU while keeping the foundations of our economy solid for a bit. Doesn’t have to be forever but the poisonous atmosphere we have in this country at the moment needs the heat taking out of it. We have to compromise. (I prefer my food to have travelled the minimum possible distance before I eat it, so welsh lamb for me,and I have had local Warwickshire lamb, beef, pork and chicken since I discovered a new and excellent butcher)

Give and take, at the very least to stop us having to talk about it all the time.
Agree beef in France is crap. When I go to the limousin they brag about their beef. Too much fat. Give me an Angus steak any day! I keep hearing about the price of food going up but lamb from New Zealand and Oz seems the way to go.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kiwiqpr
All seems perfectly sensible to me.

As you know, I’m a Brexiteer and would like nothing better than something more radical, but it all really depends upon whether you consider the referendum to have been a “first past the post” event or one that ought to be sympathetic to ‘proportional representation’. Had the outcome been (say) 60/40 or more then there’s a greater argument for a harder Brexit.

Exactly it’s the divide that is key here
As these I know where to come and find you when I rise to office as Witchfinder Pursuivant x
 
Agree beef in France is crap. When I go to the limousin they brag about their beef. Too much fat. Give me an Angus steak any day! I keep hearing about the price of food going up but lamb from New Zealand and Oz seems the way to go.
We don’t need it, we export more than we import and 90% of what we import comes from NZ and Oz, with most of the rest from Ireland.

Where do you want to import your steak from? More than 85% of our beef exports go to the EU.
 
Last edited:
Great I expect there are stocks of goods waiting for us to shop for

South Africa and Kenya all ready pre pack U.K. supermarket branded veg Ellers
No time differences as such
My neighbours son lives in Kenya
It’s about U.K. airport capacity it’s at its limit
Staines maybe able to confirm that

They will have to build a bigger airport then. Things will change.
However
I know lots of planning building manufacturing can take up to 10 years. We sold out many years ago and now we need to get it going again. As we know it won't be the end of the World as it's only 20% with the EU (I believe).
 
  • Like
Reactions: DT’s Socks
Agree beef in France is crap. When I go to the limousin they brag about their beef. Too much fat. Give me an Angus steak any day! I keep hearing about the price of food going up but lamb from New Zealand and Oz seems the way to go.

No no no Beef is what is it anywhere in the world Told you before they like fat on their meat

They like goose fat duck fat pork fat lamb fat
Butter fat fatty faux fat horse fat calf fat bird fat skins tripe fat winkle fat and dollop fat

Farmers produce food to the demand
Let’s hope argiculture is backed in the U.K. after Brexit ... there is enough space but a shortage of skills.

Look at younger people you know could they be farmers ?
 
They will have to build a bigger airport then. Things will change.
However
I know lots of planning building manufacturing can take up to 10 years. We sold out many years ago and now we need to get it going again. As we know it won't be the end of the World as it's only 20% with the EU (I believe).

That’s the spirit I am all for reinventing Britain once it has been accepted we are currently a little bit **** at things at the moment
 
We don’t need it, we export more than we import and 90% of what we import comes from NZ and Oz, with most of the rest from Ireland.

Where do you want to import your steak from? More than 85% of our beef exports go to the EU.
We only import 4% from Oz
actually I have just checked. Of food consumed in the UK only 1% comes from Oz.