Off Topic The Politics Thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Should the UK remain a part of the EU or leave?

  • Stay in

    Votes: 56 47.9%
  • Get out

    Votes: 61 52.1%

  • Total voters
    117
  • Poll closed .
War it is then

Say, hostile negotiations. If I was a betting man, I would say some arrangement will probably be devised by both sides by November. I still think that's most likely, and then the deal has to be approved by Parliament and each of the 27 nations. It depends largely on EU flexibility
 
  • Like
Reactions: bobmid
Yes, it was a stupid mistake by Tusk. It does turn people here off the EU.

The freedom of movement of EU workers is a red line for the UK. That's part of what people here voted on. Control over all immigration.

The EU have made it plain they don't want Chequers. I accept that. But if they value trading with the UK (and remember the EU sells more to us, than we sell to them), they need to work with the UK to find a solution or it's WTO. The Norway option is out - it's a terrible deal where Norway pays large sums, has no say over rules and not control on immigration. Canada plus plus looks the best solution as it doesn't interfere with the Single Market. I hope May will adopt this before the Tory Conference.
You say that the freedom of movement is a red line Goldie, but I have heard nothing from any Brexiteer about what will actually change at the point of entry into the UK. The problem is that for every one person who wants to work in the UK there are 20 tourists who come, spend their money, and then go. How do you tell them apart at the point of entry ? How do you discourage the one without discouraging the other ? If you bring in a Visa system for all those coming in then casual weekend visitors will simply go to Amsterdam or Paris instead - partly because so many EU. citizens don't have passports (just ID Cards). Or would the actuall border be at the workplace itself ? With increased controls over access to work, housing etc. Bearing in mind that the UK. already has an estimated quarter of a million illegal workers from non EU. countries, and has failed to control this effectively, how do you envisage this being done ? So far all I have heard is the soundbite 'taking back control of our borders' - but that is all.
 
You say that the freedom of movement is a red line Goldie, but I have heard nothing from any Brexiteer about what will actually change at the point of entry into the UK. The problem is that for every one person who wants to work in the UK there are 20 tourists who come, spend their money, and then go. How do you tell them apart at the point of entry ? How do you discourage the one without discouraging the other ? If you bring in a Visa system for all those coming in then casual weekend visitors will simply go to Amsterdam or Paris instead - partly because so many EU. citizens don't have passports (just ID Cards). Or would the actuall border be at the workplace itself ? With increased controls over access to work, housing etc. Bearing in mind that the UK. already has an estimated quarter of a million illegal workers from non EU. countries, and has failed to control this effectively, how do you envisage this being done ? So far all I have heard is the soundbite 'taking back control of our borders' - but that is all.

I was talking principle and you are talking the mechanics, and the mechanics is good question, Cologne. Government will have to persuade the electorate it can deliver on what people want re immigration.

It would have to be based on work visas. I assume the onus would be on employers not to employ anyone without the necessary paperwork. Overstays are a big part of illegal immigration. Personally, I think the country will have to have identity cards. I don't have a problem with that. I have a driving licence. Simply extend that.
 
I was talking principle and you are talking the mechanics, and the mechanics is good question, Cologne. Government will have to persuade the electorate it can deliver on what people want re immigration.

It would have to be based on work visas. I assume the onus would be on employers not to employ anyone without the necessary paperwork. Overstays are a big part of illegal immigration. Personally, I think the country will have to have identity cards. I don't have a problem with that. I have a driving licence. Simply extend that.
Just don't mention Salisbury or Russia and you will be okay Goldie
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goldhawk-Road
If people believe that Tusks 'tweet' and Macron's 'Liars' and the "have a second referendum' was okay for the EU heads to say in Austria and it doesn't matter?
I am not a gambling man and never really bet (although I did do a Euromillions ticket the other night <doh> ). But I bet you now that you will not hear them say stuff like that again. In fact I bet we see the opposite until will get out of course then who knows.
 
Yes, we know domestic politics can be pretty uncivil and the media can be as rude about foreign rulers as they like. But there is a code of etiquette between national leaders and their respective civil services, because if one leader insults another country's leader, they are insulting the whole of that country.
This is very true. I am a civil servant and we are under a code for what we can say on social media dependent on our specific responsibilities.We were all warned not to say anything controversial on Twitter and Facebook about the referendum or Trump for example.
In terms of negotiations we operate under Cabinet Office guidance - it's quite detailed but the nub is that we never be disrespectful to other delegates and remember we are representing the UK at all times (including in the bar!) My favourite bit of that guidance is we are told not to use cricketing analogies as most countries don't understand them...
 
If people believe that Tusks 'tweet' and Macron's 'Liars' and the "have a second referendum' was okay for the EU heads to say in Austria and it doesn't matter?
I am not a gambling man and never really bet (although I did do a Euromillions ticket the other night <doh> ). But I bet you now that you will not hear them say stuff like that again. In fact I bet we see the opposite until will get out of course then who knows.
I agree with that but it would help if some of our politicians reigned in it a bit too.Johnson and Farage in particular have been pretty outrageous in some of their utterances. A bit more respect and cooperation on both sides wouldn't go amiss right now.
The other thing of course is that this is hardly new. A French President once told Disraeli that he was blessed to have been born French remain French and would die French. Disraeli asked why he had no ambition....
 
This is very true. I am a civil servant and we are under a code for what we can say on social media dependent on our specific responsibilities.We were all warned not to say anything controversial on Twitter and Facebook about the referendum or Trump for example.
In terms of negotiations we operate under Cabinet Office guidance - it's quite detailed but the nub is that we never be disrespectful to other delegates and remember we are representing the UK at all times (including in the bar!) My favourite bit of that guidance is we are told not to use cricketing analogies as most countries don't understand them...

So you can't say the Maybot is on a sticky wicket with Barnier and Tusk bowling Googlies and Chinamen...:grin:
 
we need more political photos

Elena Bunbury‏@CllrBunbury Sep 21
Following my appearance on #bbcqt, the #FBPE are sending death threats, labelling me a stupid slut, posting private photos of me and outing me as bisexual online. So I thought I’d beat them to it. Enjoy these photos of a stupid slutty Tory bisexual who loves Brexit
You must log in or register to see images


You must log in or register to see images

You must log in or register to see images
 
On another note..
That Eurosceptic, jew problem, turn coating, mind changing terrorist loving Comrade Corbyn says he may support a second ferendum. <yikes> Surely not! He has sat on the sidelines for 2 years saying noting (except about Jews) and now decides to change his mind? mmm I am glad he sticks by his principles. :1980_boogie_down:
I'm pretty sure he has said if his party vote for a second referendum at their conference then he would be bound by it although he would prefer a general election. You can twist the wording to suit yourself though mate, no problem.
 
I'm pretty sure he has said if his party vote for a second referendum at their conference then he would be bound by it although he would prefer a general election. You can twist the wording to suit yourself though mate, no problem.
even if its only 52% in favour
 
  • Like
Reactions: ELLERS
thats me ****ed then

China has a 'chilling' system to control everyone
By Megan Palin | news.com.au
You must log in or register to see images

A man waves the Chinese national flag as an amateur choir performs in a park in a residential neighbourhood in Beijing, China February 28, 2017. REUTERS/Thomas Peter - RTS10PYV
China's chilling dictatorship is moving quickly to introduce social scorecards, in which all citizens will be monitored 24/7 and ranked on their behavior.
The Communist Party’s plan is for every one of its 1.4 billion citizens to be at the whim of a dystopian social credit system, and it’s on track to be fully operational by the year 2020.
An active pilot program has already seen millions of people each assigned a score out of 800 and either reap its benefits or suffer its consequences — depending on which end of the scale they sit.
Under the social credit scheme, points are lost and gained based on readings from a sophisticated network of 200 million surveillance cameras — a figure set to triple in 18 months.
The program has been enabled by rapid advances in facial recognition, body scanning and geo-tracking.
The data is combined with information collected from individuals’ government records — including medical and educational — along with their financial and internet browsing histories. Overall scores can go up and down in “real time” dependant on the person’s behaviour but they can also be affected by people they associate with.
“If your best friend or your dad says something negative about the government, you’ll lose points too,” the ABC reports.
The mandatory “social credit” system was first announced in 2014 in a bid to reinforce the notion that “keeping trust is glorious and breaking trust is disgraceful,” according to a government document.
In a Foreign Correspondent episode, to air on the ABC tonight, financial credit system Alipay, Tianjin general manager Jie Cong, summarised the system in black and white.
“If people keep their promises they can go anywhere in the world,” he said. “If people break their promises they won’t be able to move an inch!”
MODEL CITIZENS
Under the system, those deemed to be “top citizens” are rewarded bonus points.
The benefits of being ranked on the higher end of the scale include waived deposits on hotels and rental cars, VIP treatment at airports, discounted loans, priority job applications and fast-tracking to the most prestigious universities.
Dandan, a young mother and marketing professional, is proud of her high score. If she keeps it up her infant son will be more likely to get into a top school.
“China likes to experiment in this creative way … I think people in every country want a stable and safe society,” she said.
“We need a social credit system. We hope we can help each other, love each other and help everyone to become prosperous.”
BOTTOM OF THE SCALE
But it doesn’t take much to end up on the wrong side of the scale with an estimated 10 million people are already paying the price of a low rating.
Jaywalking, late payments on bills or taxes, buying too much alcohol or speaking out against the government, each cost citizens points.
Other mooted punishable offences include spending too long playing video games, wasting money on frivolous purchases and posting on social media, according to Business Insider.
Penalties range from losing the right to travel by plane or train, social media account suspensions and being barred from government jobs.
Chinese journalist Liu Hu is one of millions who have already amassed a low social credit rating. Liu Hu was arrested, jailed and fined after he exposed official corruption.
“The government regards me as an enemy,” Liu Hu told the ABC.
He is now banned from travelling by plane or fast train. His social media accounts with millions of followers have been suspended. He struggles to find work.
“This kind of social control is against the tide of the world. The Chinese people’s eyes are blinded and their ears are blocked. They know little about the world and are living in an illusion.” Liu Hu said.
Seventeen people who refused to carry out military service were last year barred from enrolling in higher education, applying for high school, or continuing their studies, Beijing News reported.
Uighur poet and filmmaker, Tahir Hamut, who fled to the US, told the ABC that China’s surveillance system “suddenly ramped up after the end of 2016”.
“Since then, advanced surveillance technology which we’ve never seen, never experienced, never heard of, started appearing,” he said.
This story originally appeared in news.com.au.
 
Off to Germany for work tomorrow. I’ll be working with Germans, French, Italians, Spanish, Brits and Yanks. I’ll check out the mood. Be interesting to hear from real people rather than politicians.
It's a huge privilege eh Stan? I've been meeting our stakeholders over the summer and the breadth of views has been amazing. The one good thing about this is people finally have the opportunity to say how they really want us to operate from a blank sheet of paper. I would urge you all to take that chance. There's loads of white papers asking what you think - so tell them.
 
It's a huge privilege eh Stan? I've been meeting our stakeholders over the summer and the breadth of views has been amazing. The one good thing about this is people finally have the opportunity to say how they really want us to operate from a blank sheet of paper. I would urge you all to take that chance. There's loads of white papers asking what you think - so tell them.

Is that in code? I don't understand any of it.