Can make arguments for both and will come down to individual preference. GTA has more to it due to being in a modern setting and therefore having more variety of missions/vehicles etc whereas RDR is far more immersive and slow paced and carries a bit more of an old school vibe with the hunting etc.
I prefer RDR2 as I don't ever play games online and like to immerse myself in them and take my time rather than the chaos of GTA. GTA better for a short play but rdr2 better overall imo.
Arguably GTA V isn't even the best GTA too...
got all the other GTA’s…got annoyed trying to play them a few months back…my youngest was on them because he’s autistic and a bit special, I thought I’ll have a go too.
the story line is supposed to be better with that Niko geezer being the main character but the gameplay is terrible compared to 5. Can’t play the others once you play 5 and playing 5 make the graphics look amateurish. I think most people choosing the older ones are just suffering from nostalgia tbh.
I hear RDR3 is in production
