Sunday supplement on catts

[mitchthemakem]

Hi
After being to the hull game yesterday I have waited until I have seen motd before commenting on cats tackle, although a reckless challenge I think a yellow card was punishment enough which was also the opinion of murthy on motd.
I have also the sunday supplement on sky, t.adams and c.kamara also deemed it was a yellow, all pundits said the tackle on Johnson was worse than cats as both feet were off the ground, so how do refs get it so wrong. To me it proves cats reputation is getting him a guilty verdict before refs think about the tackle.

Cats has my backing on this one.

 

[NOFUSSWITHGUS]

Any **** what sticks up for cattermole now is clueless end of.

 

[DMD]

I suspect they were assessing it on the wrong conditions. Cattermole probably wasn't red carded for being off the ground, which is what Kamara was looking for, but for a clumsy tackle that put his studs firmly into Elmo's shin as can clearly be seen on the MOTD footage. Clear red card.

 

[Munkyheed]

Any **** what sticks up for cattermole now is clueless end of.

One of the reasons we are in the mess we are in is because we do not have enough of Catts type in the team !

I agree with mitch, Catts is guilty by default when it comes to referees.

 

[MrRAWhite]

if he did actually catch Elmo, it was minimal contact, so Elmo didn't help with his cheating theatricals.

 

[NOFUSSWITHGUS]

One of the reasons we are in the mess we are in is because we do not have enough of Catts type in the team !

I agree with mitch, Catts is guilty by default when it comes to referees.

We are in this mess because of players like Cattermole pal. we have got to many poor footballers & Cattermole is one of them.

 

[its been fun thanks :)]

[video=youtube;rJlNV3mirwI]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJlNV3mirwI[/video]

any other player it would have been a yellow I- reckon no arguments with the second red shown

 

[NOFUSSWITHGUS]

[video=youtube;rJlNV3mirwI]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJlNV3mirwI[/video]

any other player it would have been a yellow I reckon no arguments with the second red shown

Why do you think he dive in for? he dive in because he give the ball away about 5 times in a row then lost his head. we can't rely on him anymore. he will never ****ing learn.

 

[MrRAWhite]

We are in this mess because of players like Cattermole pal. we have got to many poor footballers & Cattermole is one of them.

I've never been a great fan of Catts, but I have to say he has been one of our better players of late...

 

[NOFUSSWITHGUS]

I've never been a great fan of Catts, but I have to say he has been one of our better players of late...

& that says it all about Sunderland pal. if people think Cattermole is one of our best players then **** me we are **** LOL we are **** tho

 

[DMD]

if he did actually catch Elmo, it was minimal contact, so Elmo didn't help with his cheating theatricals.

It was clear, firm contact shown on the motd footage.

 

[Vincemac]

Cats bad tackle yellow doss I don't want him to were out shirt again leg breaker tackle.hull player out of control straight red.marriner continues to have double standards.HE should be punished

 

[MrRAWhite]

& that says it all about Sunderland pal. if people think Cattermole is one of our best players then **** me we are **** LOL we are **** tho

Did I say that?

 

[MrRAWhite]

It was clear, firm contact shown on the motd footage.

I must have watched another version then..

 

[Vincemac]

It was clear, firm contact shown on the motd footage.

Yeh that's right yellow card.your player was out of control he got a yellow should have been red

 

[NOFUSSWITHGUS]

Did I say that?

No but you did say Cattermole has been one of our better players of late. like I said that says it all about Sunderland.

 

[DMD]

I must have watched another version then..

MOTD, goes on iplayer Monday night. As Shearer is saying "you can't tackle like that. Five years ago it might have been a yellow card, but just look at Cattermole's reaction..." watch the footage showing the studs on Cattermoles left boot going into Elmo's shin.

 

[Smug in Boots]

I suspect they were assessing it on the wrong conditions. Cattermole probably wasn't red carded for being off the ground, which is what Kamara was looking for, but for a clumsy tackle that put his studs firmly into Elmo's shin as can clearly be seen on the MOTD footage. Clear red card.

And Brady?

 

[DMD]

I suspect they were assessing it on the wrong conditions. Cattermole probably wasn't red carded for being off the ground, which is what Kamara was looking for, but for a clumsy tackle that put his studs firmly into Elmo's shin as can clearly be seen on the MOTD footage. Clear red card.[/QUOTE]

And Brady?

I've seen them given as red, yellow and ignored. I actually think the player rolling about and Poyet and coach flapping like sea-gulls pushed it from a red to a yellow.

 

[Smug in Boots]

I've seen them given as red, yellow and ignored. I actually think the player rolling about and Poyet and coach flapping like sea-gulls pushed it from a red to a yellow.

Hypocrite.

I was asking for your opinion which you conveniently avoid giving, surprise surprise .................. unlike your opinion on Cattermole which you give freely.