Summer transfer thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Isn't there a rule anyway that you can't loan 2 players from same club? People saying Forest can't get Garner on loan from Utd as they have Henderson. Therefore we showed our hand when we signed Sims on loan.
Correct
 
Broadhead has clearly done what he feels is best for his career. Good luck to him, he played a huge part in getting us out of league 1 so ill always wish him well.

Just because a player doesnt come to us doesnt mean they lack ambition or has bottled it, theyll be doing what they feel is best for themselves to have the best career possible.

Lets move on from the Broadhead chat and focus on who might next be through the door
 
Aye - and I reckon there may be psychological issues with him and niggles. Its very easy for players to blow minor things out of proportion and feel injured. Bear in mind all pain is actually mental!! I reckon Rodwell suffered from this. And Wilshere.

And in World Cup year, especlaly if doing well, he could easily not want to risk injury and become even more protecting

I speak from some experience as I know I feel "niggles" much more than most people. I need to man up as well :D
Dangerous territory suggesting there may be psychological issues in my opinion. Unless anyone here is his doctor it is guesswork, and frankly lazy guesswork iny opinion. All about opinions mate, but think some of what has been posted about him today has been extreme, and frankly a bit odd. Maybe it is me that is in the wrong though, wouldnt be the first or last time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Southern A
Re Broadhead : Allow me to play devil's advocate here on the argument of bottling it and guaranteeing playing prior to the world cup. I haven't checked but people have said that Wigan have 5 strikers before Broadhead signed. If I was 1 of those strikers, I wouldn't be best pleased that an u23 striker had been given guarantees that he'd be playing especially as he has an injury record and hasn't done any preseason training prior to signing, even if that means he'll start on the bench
 
Dangerous territory suggesting there may be psychological issues in my opinion. Unless anyone here is his doctor it is guesswork, and frankly lazy guesswork iny opinion. All about opinions mate, but think some of what has been posted about him today has been extreme, and frankly a bit odd. Maybe it is me that is in the wrong though, wouldnt be the first or last time.

That's fair. I'm only saying it because I have something called GAD myself (Generalised Anxiety Disorder) which causes every thought and niggle to be magnified. It basically stopped me playing the game as I couldn't deal with all the little niggles I'd get. Some players that get a lot of niggles will likely suffer from the same. And some players getting the same niggles might not even notice them, or at best be able to easily forget about them
 
Re Broadhead : Allow me to play devil's advocate here on the argument of bottling it and guaranteeing playing prior to the world cup. I haven't checked but people have said that Wigan have 5 strikers before Broadhead signed. If I was 1 of those strikers, I wouldn't be best pleased that an u23 striker had been given guarantees that he'd be playing especially as he has an injury record and hasn't done any preseason training prior to signing, even if that means he'll start on the bench

He's 25 this season, so not really U23 but I get your point.
 
No disrespect mate, but of course he is. Who else should he look after exactly? I think us fans as underestimating what playing in a world cup means for a professional footballer. Th

But if it his main concern I wouldn't want him, though I would have been happy for us to sign him permanently and I'm very surprised he didn't, either here or somewhere else.

Well see , but I'm not sure he'll get another , say three plus year deal at our level dangled in front of him, given his unfortunate injury issues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FellTop
That's fair. I'm only saying it because I have something called GAD myself (Generalised Anxiety Disorder) which causes every thought and niggle to be magnified. It basically stopped me playing the game as I couldn't deal with all the little niggles I'd get. Some players that get a lot of niggles will likely suffer from the same. And some players getting the same niggles might not even notice them, or at best be able to easily forget about them
Great post mate. I respect fully your experience and I hope I have caused no offence. I manage a lad at the moment who is struggling and all I can do is give him my maxumum support, on and off the pitch. I am just a bit upset at how people have assumed the worst of him because he went, and if I am honest really disappointed at AN for even hinting he thinks the reason may have been being scared of Simms and Stewart. The assertion from Alex Neil really is laughable in my opinion, but I have said my bit. Like I say mate, no offence.
 
Great post mate. I respect fully your experience and I hope I have caused no offence. I manage a lad at the moment who is struggling and all I can do is give him my maxumum support, on and off the pitch. I am just a bit upset at how people have assumed the worst of him because he went, and if I am honest really disappointed at AN for even hinting he thinks the reason may have been being scared of Simms and Stewart. The assertion from Alex Neil really is laughable in my opinion, but I have said my bit. Like I say mate, no offence.

none taken at all. I should have worded the original post better and frankly you were right to call me out on it
 
  • Like
Reactions: FellTop