Burge is a poor keeper, looks a nervous wreck.. that's how I feel when he's picked. Hope we can get someone better in but may not be a priority.
Summer transfer rumours
- Thread starter Washysafc
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
I think that part of the problem with Burge isn't Burge himself, more that we had Mclaughlin before him, who in his first season in particular was so much more assured, and gave confidence.
Had we not had Mclaughlin and gone from Camp to Burge, he wouldn't get half the stick that he does.
In Jon McLaughlin we had a championship level goalkeeper in a league one side.
Burge is a league one goalkeeper.
Could he be improved upon? 100%. But he’s nowhere near as bad as many make out.
Burge is a league one goalkeeper.
Could he be improved upon? 100%. But he’s nowhere near as bad as many make out.
Im still waiting for Whitby town to make an offer we cant refuse for Flannagan aswell
2 portions of Fish, chips, Mushy peas and scraps would seal the deal for me. Apparently their Chairman is trying to leave the Peas out of the offer
2 portions of Fish, chips, Mushy peas and scraps would seal the deal for me. Apparently their Chairman is trying to leave the Peas out of the offer
Depends on your tolerance for nervy, indecisive keepers I suppose. To some it's an issue, others think as long as the save % is good that's all that matters.
I don't expect us to sign a keeper above where we are quality wise, although it should be possible, but it depends on how much stock you put in your keepers character. To some people it's a key factor for that position.
Burge is the worst keeper I’ve seen at Sunderland in my lifetime. Camp was bad, but he was doing it at championship level. He’s also been solid for Swindon since coming down to league one as well.
He’s poor but Ha’way man…
Aye at least he's a decent shot stopper, made some great saves last season and some important ones too. It was like Camp was made of smoke when he was with us, the ball seemed to mysteriously pass through him no matter how crap the shot. Steele and Ruiter had the same problem.
The question I have is how on earth is a 3 year old posting on these forums?!?
Abit harsh and massively over exaggerated in my opinion
He was doing what at Championship level? Not ****ing goalkeeping.
He is poor, we need a new keeper, it is very important that we get one.
Coventry fans warned us about him. He looks a nervous wreck anytime the ball goes near the box.
S
sad-eyed prophet
Guest
I think we have to give Burge a bit of slack. His biggest fault is that he doesn't come to claim the ball and try to dominate his box,but,he made a number of excellent shot stopper saves last year which kept us in it at times. I think he would be a lot better if and when he plays behind a settled,competent defensive line,which,last season we were hardly ever able to put out.
Sadly those who think we should have a Premier League keeper will fail to see this.
Agree. Nor was McLaughlin as good as people like to romanticise about - he made several mistakes at the start of his 2nd season with us
Not even in the top 5 - what a ludicrous statement. (Unless you are 3 years old of course)
I can't ever remember Camp actually diving, I'm not Burges biggest fan , but like has been mentioned before unless we can get a Premier League player on loan like the young lad from Stoke, signing any league 1 keeper on a permanent is not really going to be an improvement.
No matter what anyone thinks about Burge, before the collapse of our defence in the last 12 games he was actually statistically one of the best in the league