Yes, exactly. I’m not asking for the typical hard-man in midfield like Ashbee. But, every successful club even today has a physically-strong, athletic defensive midfielder who reads the game well, makes well-timed tackles, interceptions and generally recovers the ball. Most of the best defensive midfielders these days are good at playing the ball in addition to winning it back. Think Rodri, Rice, Caicedo, Lavia etc.
I do believe Simons can be this sort of player but for me, it’s such an integral part of a team, even possession-based teams, that he needs to be starting more games than not. Will Rosenior start Simons most games? Probably not, so we’re still lacking that sort of player. I don’t think Bird is that player either. He reminds me a lot of Jorginho in the way he plays which makes him the ideal replacement for Seri and Woods but doesn’t solve the issue that we struggle to win the ball back in the middle of the pitch.