Since Roy Keane

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Commachio

Commachio

Rambo 2021
Jan 25, 2011
92,685
43,152
113
Got the club promoted on 07, there has been a revolving door, in regards to players.

Now if i asked the question, 'who has been the best player since promotion', i expect quite a lot would say 'Sess', with a few variations, of maybe Bent and err?

But what if i asked, 'since promotion, who has been the worst player'?

The list could be long, so fire away.
 
O'Shea is the most overrated by managers for me.

Worst to pull on the strip... Private? Murphy? Nos?

Nah... Angeleri. The lad looked diabolical.
 
commachio1 said:
Got the club promoted on 07, there has been a revolving door, in regards to players.

Now if i asked the question, 'who has been the best player since promotion', i expect quite a lot would say 'Sess', with a few variations, of maybe Bent and err?

But what if i asked, 'since promotion, who has been the worst player'?

The list could be long, so fire away.
Click to expand...

Alfred N'Diaye.
 
O'Shea and Larsson the most overrated by managers.

Worst, probably Stokes, Murphy and McLean.
 
Mignolet was far more consistent than Sess, more dedicated and ambitious.

There are some poor players, in their own right, but O'Shea corrupts the entire team.

He leaves gaps, makes other defenders unsure of their own position and passes to players who are marked.

He obviously hates to receive the ball from the keeper and breaks up our own play by hoofing it forward aimlessly.

If he'd arrived from Sheffield United and not the other United he'd have been dropped and pedalled by now .......... and that is an indictment of our managers.
 
Bloody good question comm, for what we paid for him and what we got i'd have to go with danny graham
 
Malbranque the best..

Larsson the last 2 years and O'Shea since he got here the worst. Chimbonda & Diouff weren't to clever either..
 
Greg Halford, Anthony Stokes, Russell Anderson, Michael Chopra, Roy O'Donovan, Ian Harte, Rade Prica. That's just from the 07-08 season.
 
Anton Ferdinand, George McCartney (didn't west ham see us coming) David Healy, Teemu Tainio (made of glass) Pascal Chimbonda. Thats from the 08-09 season
 
Elmo again, Connor Wickham, Ji Dong-Won, Wes Brown(crock) John O'Shea, Wayne Bridge, Sotirios Kyrgiakos from the 11-12 season.


Lots of names to jog your memories lads. <ok>
 
commachio1 said:
Got the club promoted on 07, there has been a revolving door, in regards to players.

Now if i asked the question, 'who has been the best player since promotion', i expect quite a lot would say 'Sess', with a few variations, of maybe Bent and err?

But what if i asked, 'since promotion, who has been the worst player'?

The list could be long, so fire away.
Click to expand...

Greg Coca-Cola Halford
Andy Cole
the Egyptian Beckham
Rada Prica

...too name but a few
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back