Fair enough, he's not been as good recently as he was earlier in the season, that is undeniable. However, he did help us beat Arsenal and Man City (sticking to your guys top four claim here). Maybe you should try acknowledging his all round game rather than just his goals? Afterall, I still argue against others that claim he is a natural goalscorer, I used to argue that he's not a striker but not sure that applies when he's got thirty goals in thirty-one games.
PS...if only this season counts, how **** is Rooney...? And RvP for that matter!