Rival watch

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Come on bro, chin up not like you got Jose managing yous.

I only tune in for the pens mate. Bit gutted when we only get the one. <laugh>
Funny dele pic on the GM thread.

Dele after the game "just lump it forwards and fuking defend" <laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Treble
So Bednarek's red card v ManU has been overturned. Right decision but I'm kind of surprised they did it, you know, doing the right thing. Well actually the right thing would be not to send him off in the first place, and possibly give a yellow card to Martial for diving. But that would never happen. The fact that it directly and indirectly contributed a few goals to ManU's goal difference is no doubt irrelevant, and the fact that it casts doubts over this refs competence (I can't bring myself to say the name) is also of course irrelevant. He gave a pen, was told to go to the monitor, and instead of thinking the decision might be wrong he instead sent off the Southampton player. But don't worry, he would have done exactly the same thing had the situation been reversed and a ManU player not fouled a diving Southampton player.
I still haven't seen it, but I assume that the implication of this is that Martial dived.
If that's the case, then why isn't he being banned, like Niasse was a few years ago?
 
I still haven't seen it, but I assume that the implication of this is that Martial dived.
If that's the case, then why isn't he being banned, like Niasse was a few years ago?
The "implication" (or actual reasoning i would think) is that Martial had lost control of the ball therefore no denial of goal scoring opportunity <ok>
 
I still haven't seen it, but I assume that the implication of this is that Martial dived.
If that's the case, then why isn't he being banned, like Niasse was a few years ago?
I think the inference is that it was an accidental collision.
There was clearly contact, which caused Martial, who was running at speed, to fall.
Bednarek went to make a challenge, tried to pull out when he realises he can't get the ball and will take out the man, but still made contact.
He has been given the benefit it being deemed accidental, which is generous.
 
I think the inference is that it was an accidental collision.
There was clearly contact, which caused Martial, who was running at speed, to fall.
Bednarek went to make a challenge, tried to pull out when he realises he can't get the ball and will take out the man, but still made contact.
He has been given the benefit it being deemed accidental, which is generous.
Luiz made accidental contact and his ban was upheld. Not very consistent.
 
Ajax aren't having the best week. The laughable mistake over Haller's European registration has been upheld and now this:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/55949730

Andre Onana has been banned for 12 months for taking a banned substance.
Really poor timing for him, in a bunch of ways. Linked with a big move and misses the African Nations in his own country.
 
Luiz made accidental contact and his ban was upheld. Not very consistent.
Consistency is a different issue altogether!

One of the many problems with VAR is that it distorts perspective. Watching images from mutiple cameras in slow motion creates a misleading impression of how an event happened in real time. Physical contact of this kind happens in a fraction of a second. In slo-mo, a false impression is created that a player (Bednarek) has time to make a decision e,g to pull out of a tackle, when in reality he has acted instinctively and had very little time to readjust.

It's the same with handballs. Things can look deliberate in slo-mo, as if the raising of an arm into the path of the ball was intended to block it, when, at full speed, it's apparent a player is simply gaining leverage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vimhawk
Consistency is a different issue altogether!

One of the many problems with VAR is that it distorts perspective. Watching images from mutiple cameras in slow motion creates a misleading impression of how an event happened in real time. Physical contact of this kind happens in a fraction of a second. In slo-mo, a false impression is created that a player (Bednarek) has time to make a decision e,g to pull out of a tackle, when in reality he has acted instinctively and had very little time to readjust.

It's the same with handballs. Things can look deliberate in slo-mo, as if the raising of an arm into the path of the ball was intended to block it, when, at full speed, it's apparent a player is simply gaining leverage.

I've disagreed with you a lot, but I completely agree with you on this :-)
 
A couple of things which illustrate a massive problem with the Laws at least in my opinion. A few minutes ago Xhaka blatantly and deliberately badly fouls Grealish to stop a breakaway. Gets a yellow card and concedes a free kick neither of which affect anything.
In our match Dier slightly mistimes a kick on the ball in the penalty area and that effectively hands the opposition a goal.
No argument with either decision under the current Law. But wouldn't the game be much fairer if any deliberate foul was a penalty and a mistimed challenge never was?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spurf
A couple of things which illustrate a massive problem with the Laws at least in my opinion. A few minutes ago Xhaka blatantly and deliberately badly fouls Grealish to stop a breakaway. Gets a yellow card and concedes a free kick neither of which affect anything.
In our match Dier slightly mistimes a kick on the ball in the penalty area and that effectively hands the opposition a goal.
No argument with either decision under the current Law. But wouldn't the game be much fairer if any deliberate foul was a penalty and a mistimed challenge never was?

No
 
  • Like
Reactions: Diego