New Manager Ideas

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Selles looks like a good option for progression as a manager and to progress us as a team, much like Rosy was. Fingers crossed if we get him he can complete his project unlike Rosy. The Walter appointment was all wrong from the start, not often I agree with Simon Jordan but he was spot on about him- no way was a failed Bundesliga 2 manager with a Bundesliga club ever going to be any good for us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kirkellatiger, Greytiger, Real ale tiger and 2 others
Des Head said:
An Open Letter To Ruben Selles

Dear Ruben,

I hope I do not appear presumptuous if I write on behalf of every Reading fan, but I feel I must do so. The message from us is simple: please stay. This club is in a dire state as you know, but a “simple” takeover is all it needs to become more stable.

I appreciate these are simple words for a very complex situation, however if you were to choose to stay and dedicate your personal future to this club, the esteem in which you are held would undoubtedly be among the highest any manager has ever been held in Reading, if not THE highest.

We recognise the start you had was difficult, but the manner in which you have managed to guide this ship through troubled waters both on and off the pitch is beyond admiration. The improvement you have overseen in not only our young players - who you have managed superbly - but also the more senior professionals, is there for all to see.

The rapport you hold with the fans of this club is like no other I have seen in 35 years following this humble football club. The respect held for the players, and understanding of the situation, by the fans, is in no small part down to you and your coaching team.

The manager of a football club is the figurehead of any club, the standard-setter, the sun around which all playing staff orbit. Were it not for you, I am in no doubt that this football club would have collapsed long ago, but it is your work, your tireless effort, that has glued this club together.

It takes a person with significant resolve to navigate such challenges as you have, and I only implore you - plead with you - to stay and ensure that if/when you do leave, the club is left in stable hands, not in the abyss with Dai Yongge. Navigate these challenges through to the takeover and then you will see what this club, its staff and its fans can offer you.

Lastly, I just want to say that we, the fans, love you. The players clearly love you. The coaching staff clearly love you. I know the administrative staff love you. These may not be easy words to read for someone who appears humble, and shuns the limelight a bit, pushing the emphasis only on your players, but they are true. You are loved here. Please do not abandon that love for another club whose ownership appears to be among the most short-sighted and unstable in the Football League.

However, if this is to be the end, I want to offer you the biggest of thank yous. Words cannot do justice to how, I think, every Reading fan feels about the job you have done under the most challenging of circumstances since you arrived at this club.

Your coaching, tactics, political acumen and man-management skills have been demonstrated to the full, and it is no surprise you are courting interest from clubs higher up the pyramid. Nobody can blame you if you choose to leave, and you would leave with our best wishes.

Hasta que nos volvamos a encontrar (¡con suerte en Wycombe!)

Dave Harris

https://thetilehurstend.sbnation.co...open-letter-to-ruben-selles-reading-fc-royals
Click to expand...

ChatGPT. Please summarise the above tripe into 3 bullet points.


* Ruben is urged to stay at Reading FC despite the club's current difficulties.
* His leadership and ability to guide the team through troubled waters are highly praised.
* Fans express their love and admiration for Ruben and his significant contribution to the club.

Ta.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HullCityAFC1904, Leftsaidfred-partdeux, balkan tiger and 1 other person
ChatGPT.
Will Ruben Selles be successful if he is appointed Manager of Hull City?


If Ruben Selles were to become the manager of Hull City, there are several reasons why his tenure might face challenges or result in limited success:


1. Lack of Proven Success at Higher Levels


Selles’ managerial experience is limited, with his most notable stints at clubs like Reading and Southampton, where results were mixed. At Reading, while he earned plaudits for his leadership in tough circumstances, he failed to produce consistent results or navigate the club out of relegation danger. Hull City, with ambitions of promotion or at least stability in the Championship, may require a more experienced figure who has achieved tangible success in similar scenarios.


2. Tactical Rigidness


Selles has been criticized for a tendency to adhere rigidly to his tactical setups, sometimes failing to adapt during games or to opponents’ strategies. The Championship demands flexibility due to its competitive nature and unpredictability. A manager unable to adapt quickly risks losing points in tight games.


3. Pressure and Expectations


The pressure at Hull City, an ambitious club with strong backing from its owners, would be significantly higher than what Selles faced at Reading. Managing in a more stable environment with higher stakes could expose any shortcomings in his ability to handle the weight of expectation and deliver consistent results.


4. Player Buy-in and Man-Management Concerns


While Selles is known for working well with younger players, questions remain about his ability to manage established professionals at a higher level. Hull’s squad features a mix of experienced players and emerging talent, requiring a balanced approach that Selles hasn’t fully demonstrated in his managerial career.


5. Championship Experience Deficit


The Championship is a notoriously demanding and physical league. Success often hinges on understanding its unique challenges, including fixture congestion, diverse playing styles, and high-intensity football. Selles’ limited experience in this environment might put him at a disadvantage compared to managers who have navigated these waters before.


Conclusion


While Ruben Selles possesses commendable qualities, such as resilience and the ability to develop young talent, these alone may not suffice to ensure success at Hull City. The step-up in expectations, the demands of the Championship, and his relatively unproven track record raise legitimate concerns about whether he can meet the club’s ambitions. Hull may require a manager with more Championship experience and a track record of success under pressure.


Kin ell. A yes or no would have sufficed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leftsaidfred-partdeux, balkan tiger and Real ale tiger
willyfog said:
Good grounding…

…studying for a masters under professor Paco Seirul·lo, who has been in charge of FC Barcelona’s training methodologies for the last 30 years. That gave me a knowledge of how to create a high-performance environment in team sports.
Click to expand...

That won't matter to our fans if he plays a right-footer at left back or doesn't switch to a back three whenever we have a poor run.
 
TurkeyTeeth™ said:
ChatGPT.
Will Ruben Selles be successful if he is appointed Manager of Hull City?


If Ruben Selles were to become the manager of Hull City, there are several reasons why his tenure might face challenges or result in limited success:


1. Lack of Proven Success at Higher Levels


Selles’ managerial experience is limited, with his most notable stints at clubs like Reading and Southampton, where results were mixed. At Reading, while he earned plaudits for his leadership in tough circumstances, he failed to produce consistent results or navigate the club out of relegation danger. Hull City, with ambitions of promotion or at least stability in the Championship, may require a more experienced figure who has achieved tangible success in similar scenarios.


2. Tactical Rigidness


Selles has been criticized for a tendency to adhere rigidly to his tactical setups, sometimes failing to adapt during games or to opponents’ strategies. The Championship demands flexibility due to its competitive nature and unpredictability. A manager unable to adapt quickly risks losing points in tight games.


3. Pressure and Expectations


The pressure at Hull City, an ambitious club with strong backing from its owners, would be significantly higher than what Selles faced at Reading. Managing in a more stable environment with higher stakes could expose any shortcomings in his ability to handle the weight of expectation and deliver consistent results.


4. Player Buy-in and Man-Management Concerns


While Selles is known for working well with younger players, questions remain about his ability to manage established professionals at a higher level. Hull’s squad features a mix of experienced players and emerging talent, requiring a balanced approach that Selles hasn’t fully demonstrated in his managerial career.


5. Championship Experience Deficit


The Championship is a notoriously demanding and physical league. Success often hinges on understanding its unique challenges, including fixture congestion, diverse playing styles, and high-intensity football. Selles’ limited experience in this environment might put him at a disadvantage compared to managers who have navigated these waters before.


Conclusion


While Ruben Selles possesses commendable qualities, such as resilience and the ability to develop young talent, these alone may not suffice to ensure success at Hull City. The step-up in expectations, the demands of the Championship, and his relatively unproven track record raise legitimate concerns about whether he can meet the club’s ambitions. Hull may require a manager with more Championship experience and a track record of success under pressure.


Kin ell. A yes or no would have sufficed.
Click to expand...

Can ChatGPT let me know who will win on the weekend so I can lump on?
 
  • Like
Reactions: rovertiger
TurkeyTeeth™ said:
ChatGPT.
Will Ruben Selles be successful if he is appointed Manager of Hull City?


If Ruben Selles were to become the manager of Hull City, there are several reasons why his tenure might face challenges or result in limited success:


1. Lack of Proven Success at Higher Levels


Selles’ managerial experience is limited, with his most notable stints at clubs like Reading and Southampton, where results were mixed. At Reading, while he earned plaudits for his leadership in tough circumstances, he failed to produce consistent results or navigate the club out of relegation danger. Hull City, with ambitions of promotion or at least stability in the Championship, may require a more experienced figure who has achieved tangible success in similar scenarios.


2. Tactical Rigidness


Selles has been criticized for a tendency to adhere rigidly to his tactical setups, sometimes failing to adapt during games or to opponents’ strategies. The Championship demands flexibility due to its competitive nature and unpredictability. A manager unable to adapt quickly risks losing points in tight games.


3. Pressure and Expectations


The pressure at Hull City, an ambitious club with strong backing from its owners, would be significantly higher than what Selles faced at Reading. Managing in a more stable environment with higher stakes could expose any shortcomings in his ability to handle the weight of expectation and deliver consistent results.


4. Player Buy-in and Man-Management Concerns


While Selles is known for working well with younger players, questions remain about his ability to manage established professionals at a higher level. Hull’s squad features a mix of experienced players and emerging talent, requiring a balanced approach that Selles hasn’t fully demonstrated in his managerial career.


5. Championship Experience Deficit


The Championship is a notoriously demanding and physical league. Success often hinges on understanding its unique challenges, including fixture congestion, diverse playing styles, and high-intensity football. Selles’ limited experience in this environment might put him at a disadvantage compared to managers who have navigated these waters before.


Conclusion


While Ruben Selles possesses commendable qualities, such as resilience and the ability to develop young talent, these alone may not suffice to ensure success at Hull City. The step-up in expectations, the demands of the Championship, and his relatively unproven track record raise legitimate concerns about whether he can meet the club’s ambitions. Hull may require a manager with more Championship experience and a track record of success under pressure.


Kin ell. A yes or no would have sufficed.
Click to expand...

Sounds like a dead man walking.

Probably better to sack him now, before he starts, than risk watching this kind of dross every week.


We never get it right, do we?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leftsaidfred-partdeux, Christophalophados, SW3 Chelsea Tiger and 8 others
willyfog said:
People also refer to his spell at Southampton in the Premier League as unsuccessful but they were already doomed when he took over in February 2023. He did win his first game 0-1 away at Chelsea.

He also got a 3-3 home draw v Tottenham and even more impressive 3-3 away at Arsenal and finished with a 4-4 away at Liverpool.

Perhaps we will see more goals!
Click to expand...
Perhaps Acun is thinking WTF did we not try and get him in August...
 
  • Like
Reactions: SydneyTiger14
Ernie Shackleton said:
Sounds like a dead man walking.

Probably better to sack him now, before he starts, than risk watching this kind of dross every week.


We never get it right, do we?
Click to expand...
I would also suggest sacking our next manager in advance of hiring him / her, this as they will fail at some point (FACT), forward thinking at it's best!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Leftsaidfred-partdeux, look_back_in_amber, rovertiger and 1 other person
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back