Mata to us ?

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
That's the point I was making, you can play Mata wide against the weaker sides, as they won't expose Carrick and Fellaini, but if your gonna play Mata wide against the top sides, you need 2 midfielders like Fernandinho and Toure. So it was a big tactical error from Moyes to play him wide in the Liverpool game, though you don't know it won't work until you try it, so I can't see him trying that again :biggrin:

Maybe against weak sides with two great DMs like City, you could play Mata wide. But Silva and certainly Nasri both track back more than him.

He played inside out wide in 433 under AVB and at Valencia with hard workers around him.

Against top sides you cannot play Mata wide in 442, even with a Matic and Yaya. You would get destroyed by BAyern Chelsea etc
 
Please can we close this thread.

We don't need a new post every time he does something notable, hopefully there will be plenty of those in the future! (notable performances, not meaningless posts)

I think the "Mata to us?" issue has been resolved tbh. <ok>
 
Please can we close this thread.

We don't need a new post every time he does something notable, hopefully there will be plenty of those in the future! (notable performances, not meaningless posts)

I think the "Mata to us?" issue has been resolved tbh. <ok>

I still don't think you're going to get him <ok>
 
By far his performance for us today, he was class for us, its a shame he can't play on wednesday.
 
Yeah I think we got a real good player there, even if we had to pay 37 million. The guy is class, and I think it will turn out to be one of Mourinho's worst ever decisions letting us have him. When I watch Oscar play, it really does make me chuckle that Mourinho thinks he's better than Mata. Mata is miles ahead of him, and Chelsea should have built there team around him. Though there loss is our gain :biggrin:
 
Being perfectly honest, I wouldn't say Mata is miles ahead of Oscar. Oscar is a fantastic player and will go on to be world class. Yeah Mata is ahead now but I think they'll both reach the same level. Mourinho, however, did make a mistake in letting us have Mata, though. He will strengthen us immeasurably when he fully settles in and finds his best form and consistency.
To be fair I think Mourinho has to be given credit for insisting that Mata should be allowed to join us, knowing that we were his preferred destination. Not a lot of managers would have had that much integrity towards a star player.