Off Topic Mafia 6 thread

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
table pre meetings:

Tobes: 1 vote by: billy
Nolynch: 3 votes by: Astro, bodanki, gerrez
Bodanki: 2 votes by: Tobes, AFCFTW
Nozzer: 1 vote by: IBWT
IBWT: 1 vote by: Nozzer
Astro: 2 vote by: BobbyD, morgan

Not voted: Mikey, Obi wan, Valley

do carry on... sigh......
 
astroturfnaut said:
Not bothered. I'm probably dead tonight anyway.

BTW if the mafia don't kill me but convert me you're not allowed to use my foolproof strategy any more OK <ok>
Click to expand...

We're safe then [HASHTAG]#theconvertedcantbeconverted[/HASHTAG]
 
Nozzer said:
Whereas now you play boring football and still lose?

We'll probably be able to trust the investigators, especially if there's two of them and only one can be recruited. It'll be clear pretty early if they can be trusted or not.
Click to expand...

Early once they speak but how long are we going to wait for them to speak.

In the meantime we might as well all log off until 12.50pm each day and vote no lynch.
 
Nozzer said:
Well yes, giving up on the strategy part-way through would be problematic for us. And stupid. It does require the strategy to be done to the end. That said, once the mafia actions are used up, the detectives can come out and start dispensing their knowledge. And it should then pretty quickly become clear who can be trusted and who (if anyone) can't.
Click to expand...

No.... Am I bein stupid (don't answer that) but if the Mafia use all their options then we can't know that both detectives are innocent. Therefor f they start revealing info we still don't know if we should believe them or not....

im
it sitting sround not voting for anyone for about 5 days ... Even if you all vite no lynch I'm picking someone... Might have hung myself here but rather be out the game then sit here wierly for 5 days having 0 to do and being told what to do by people who are no more innocent than I am
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
No.... Am I bein stupid (don't answer that) but if the Mafia use all their options then we can't know that both detectives are innocent. Therefor f they start revealing info we still don't know if we should believe them or not....

im
it sitting sround not voting for anyone for about 5 days ... Even if you all vite no lynch I'm picking someone... Might have hung myself here but rather be out the game then sit here wierly for 5 days having 0 to do and being told what to do by people who are no more innocent than I am
Click to expand...

You are perfectly free to vote for whoever you want. No one is telling anyone what to do.

Seems surprising to me that you'd be so passionate about voting to kill someone when you can't possible have any information right now.

Unless you're mafia of course.
 
astroturfnaut said:
You are perfectly free to vote for whoever you want. No one is telling anyone what to do.

Seems surprising to me that you'd be so passionate about voting to kill someone when you can't possible have any information right now.

Unless you're mafia of course.
Click to expand...

Much more fun to throw accusations and see what's comes up.

I I prefer losing 5-3 epic playing good footvall than win via an OG and not leaving my own half for 90 minutes <ok>
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
No.... Am I bein stupid (don't answer that) but if the Mafia use all their options then we can't know that both detectives are innocent. Therefor f they start revealing info we still don't know if we should believe them or not....
Click to expand...

No, but if the mafia are lucky enough to recruit a detective , the detective will then at some point say a name. This can be either be refuted by the other detective (if they're alive and have that knowledge), or at the latest when we lynch someone who turns out to be innocent. As far as I see it, there's no way for the detectives to have a false reading, so the detective must be lying. and there's not reason for them to do so unless they're mafia.
 
On a side note, I think next game (or even now) we should all be forever to select at the start of the gsme who the Mafia members are (via pm to host). They can then record it and we can see at the end which of the townies has the best gut feeling.

Almost like cluedo, but do it at the very start.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Super G Ted'inho
Nozzer said:
No, but if the mafia are lucky enough to recruit a detective , the detective will then at some point say a name. This can be either be refuted by the other detective (if they're alive and have that knowledge), or at the latest when we lynch someone who turns out to be innocent. As far as I see it, there's no way for the detectives to have a false reading, so the detective must be lying. and there's not reason for them to do so unless they're mafia.
Click to expand...

Or if they disagree then we have to work out who to believe... And then if we kill the wrong one were even more useless <laugh>
 
Nozzer said:
Well yes, we may get it wrong once. But the second time should get them! <laugh>
Click to expand...

But then we still have 0 info to go on making the last 7 days waiting for info seem even more pointless <laugh>
 
Are we saying we vote no lynch just for the first day and then act, as I can live with that

"Entertainers start slowly"

But not if that is the tactic for the game.

"Entertainers fail to entertain".
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back